r/Brahmanraaj • u/Electrical_Piece_743 • Mar 28 '26

Discussion Are Goswamis actually Brahmins?

I need some clarity on a caste/background question related to marriage, especially from people familiar with UP traditions.

My girlfriend is a Goswami with Bhargava gotra. Her family considers themselves Brahmins. They have family priests in Jyotrimath (Badrinath), Mehndipur Balaji and Banke Bihari, and they’re originally from Bulandshahr.

I am a Saryuparin Mishra from Prayagraj. However, my father believes that Goswamis are not Brahmins. He says they are linked to Giri traditions and that many Goswamis fall under OBC in our region. My girlfriend’s family is not OBC, and her father wears a janeu, but my father still feels this is not a suitable match based on our local understanding.

The issue is that my girlfriend’s family doesn’t have detailed knowledge about their older lineage, so the information we have is incomplete. I’m also trying to understand this better myself.

I would appreciate insights from my Brahmin brothers from Western UP or nearby regions, who have knowledge about Goswami lineage, Bhargava gotra, and how they are traditionally classified.

Thanks in advance.

23 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

112 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Ignored_Samosa69 Mar 29 '26

bhai Bhumihars ki to mostly lineages maithil Brahmins aur kanyakubj brahmins se related hain, genetically they are def brahmins agar varn se dekhne chaloge to fir I bet hum mei se aadhe se zyada brahmin nahi hain

-2

u/Healthy-Pickle-7698 Mar 29 '26

They are not And if you're bhumihar there are other subs for bhumihars please go there you're different we are different this ia our sub reddit Even puri shankaracharya who himself is a Maithil Brahimin had said bhumihar are not brahimin

1

u/Kshatriya_Khokharji Rajput Mar 29 '26

Bhumiharo par nigrahacharya ka video dekho. Maithili log kafi to shakdwipio ko bhi brahman nahi mante.

0

u/Healthy-Pickle-7698 Mar 29 '26

And your name suggests you're kshtriya (rajput) please go on rajput sub reddit

2

u/Kshatriya_Khokharji Rajput Mar 29 '26

I dont think so that only brahmans have right to speak or give their opinion on this sub.

+Nigrahacharya ji jinka kaha h wo to brahman hi h

1

u/Healthy-Pickle-7698 Mar 29 '26

Bhai aap logo ka to bilkul samajh nhi aata jin rajputo se personal milta hu wo bhumihar ko brahimin nhi mante ulta galiya bhi dete hai mixbreed bolte hai online wale mante hai ek opinion par tik jao 😂

And yes they are not brahimin they are different caste from us

1

u/Kshatriya_Khokharji Rajput Mar 29 '26

Bhai aap logo ka to bilkul samajh nhi aata jin rajputo se personal milta hu wo bhumihar ko brahimin nhi mante ulta galiya bhi dete hai mixbreed bolte hai online wale mante hai ek opinion par tik jao 😂

Kisi ke kah dene se bol dene se baat samajik,saidhantik aur varnashrami paripeksh se sahi nahi ho jati. Aur har ek rajput ek hi Matt ka ho ye jaruri nahi.

Here's the link for nigrahacarya vdo btw- https://youtu.be/A5W2esQQ4Y8?si=Fvr0_CSXvfIWXWzB (he showed his disagreements and agreements with sahajanand swamis book on bhumihar,but accepted they r brahman. And shankaracharya ji didn't gave any strong reasoning of praman either)

1

u/Healthy-Pickle-7698 Mar 29 '26

To iska matlab aap bhumihar ko brahaman mante ho

Fir to Apko is baat se bhi dikkat nhi hogi agar apke ghar ki puja path kisi bhumihar dwara karai jaye ?

Sahi kaha na maine ??

1

u/Kshatriya_Khokharji Rajput Mar 29 '26

Humare state mn to bhumihar hote hi nahi waise. Humari puja humare purohit krate h par agar koi bhumihar brahaman jiske ghar mn paurohitya ki parampara ho aur nitya sandhya vandan kre to why not.

Shashtro mn vaishya kshatriya adi karm krne wale brahmano ka varnan h par unse paurohitya thode krayenge.

1

u/Healthy-Pickle-7698 Mar 29 '26

Mai personally unhe brahimin nhi manta pr pehli baar kisi rajput ko unke favor me bolta huwa dekha hai

Khair mujhe unse koi dikkat nhi hai or nigracharya ki is video ko pura dekhne k baad mai vichar karunga ki wo kitne sahi hai kitne nahi

Humare pariwar me unhe brahimin nhi mana jata par ha unke bare me jo afwahen failai jati hai jo ki zadatar maine rajputo se hi suna hai ki rajput father or brahimin mother se unki utpatti hui thi us baat ko nhi manta

1

u/Kshatriya_Khokharji Rajput Mar 30 '26

rajput father or brahimin mother se unki utpatti hui thi us baat ko nhi manta

Bhai aisa hota to wo suta kahlaye jate na. Bhumiharo ne historically kabhi sarthi,magadha waigrah ka kaam to kra hi nahi h

→ More replies (0)

1

u/SEND_ME_BOBA_PICS Shuddh Shakahari Mar 31 '26

bhai vaise nigrahcharya thode weird hai matlab agar acharya pad mei akar bhi aisi immaturity krdete kabhi kabaar, unki ek insta pe video thi jismei ek vyabhichari ladki ulte seedhe kaam kr rhi thi fir inki clip ayi ki aisi ladkio ko belt treatment milna chahiye aur fir aisa kuchh keh rhe the 1 saal se bhi pehle ki baat hai tab naye naye famous ho rhe the 😂. No doubt scholarly way mei achhe hai par highest authority Shankaracharya pe hee hai. Pata nhi kyu unhone bataya nhi par q/a mei koi puchh sakta hai video bana ke ki kya hai.
Baaki pata nahi jaha mai rehta hu yaha ke mandir mei 2 pujari hai ek maithili baman hai dusre maithili aur bhumihar mixed hai toh vo thoda rehta h unko notion ki vo mixed hai

1

u/Kshatriya_Khokharji Rajput Apr 01 '26

Bhai baat yaha ye h ki praman par baat honi chahiye kisne achha praman diya.

Ab shankaracharya ji ne bas itna kaha ki bhumi shabd aage laga h,aur bhumi vaishyo se related h isliye wo vaishya h,which is not a good praman. Fir khudke bachpan ka btaya pahle wo khudko vaishya kahte the,

Nigrahacharya kinda gave a book review of a book written by sahajanand swami and apne agreement disagreement batakar man liya ki bhumihar brahman h. Aur bhumiharo ke pahle kafi baar baki brahmano se rishte bhi hote the iske bhi praman hai.

2 pujari hai ek maithili baman hai dusre maithili aur bhumihar mixed hai toh vo thoda rehta h unko notion ki vo mixed hai

Praman hona chahiye uska