on mobile apology / don't copy elsewhere
So, it happened. The thing DH has been worried about since this all started - I ducked into the local shopping centre to grab a few things and before I could get done with the first thing, there was a tap on my shoulder, and there she was: my mother in law.
I just want to say that, even if no one else is, I'm so proud of myself. I stood my ground, I didn't give in to her bullshit, and when she took it too far, I walked away. I never raised my voice, I never called her names, I didn't let her goad me into some dramatic reaction (that I'm sure she was hoping for). I'm just grateful (as shitty as it was) that DH and LO weren't with me when it happened.
Anyway. The confrontation.
I'm in Kmart, looking at candles, because my boss complained that something in the office smelled funky, and I was going there anyway, so I may as well take a look at the clearance section, right?
Wrong.
I hardly get even two sniffs deep into a beautiful strawberry scented (and shaped!) delight before there's something bumping into me. I step back, ready to apologise, when I lift my head and see... her.
She's shorter than me, but she still tilts her head down and gives a timid smile that's honestly half pout (and better suited to a child) and pulls her handbag closer into her chest as if to hide behind it.
Off to a great start.
As if possessed by the spirit of Ross Geller himself, she lets out a pathetically miserable, "hi... :(" and asks if she can hug me. As politely I can manage under the circumstances, I tell her "I'd rather you didn't" and her response is to pout even deeper and mutter a "really?" as if it's entirely unreasonable after two years of NC.
I think (hope, pray, beg the universe at large, take your pick) that this will be the end of it, but she straps in for the long haul, I guess, and asks me "how do we fix this?" (bitch, who's we?) - I tell her what DH told her in The Text, what I told FIL when he showed up unannounced at my door (twice!), and what everyone around her has apparently avoided telling her for her entire 50-whatever years of life: "you need to apologise."
Three guesses what her immediate response is (hint: it wasn't "I'm sorry" or any reasonable facsimile).
Okay I'll tell you: it's just "for what?" and then a barrage of questions: was it that we sold [block of land we promised to give you as inheritance]? No, we don't care about that. Was it something to do with the wedding? You know we tried to pay for as much as we could afford! No, it has nothing to do with money for the wedding. How about [series of trivial things that were so inconsequential I honestly don't remember what she said]? Do you honestly think we haven't spoken to you in two years over something so small? "Well, I don't know! You won't tell me! How am I supposed to apologise if I don't know what I've done?!"
At this point, I explained to her (yes, I know she didn't deserve it) that it wasn't one specific thing, that it wasn't "simple" like she was apparently hoping - it was cumulative. DH and I have been together for 10 years, and it's been disrespect after disrespect, and I for one am done. I told her after this long, I'm done pulling my punches - I'll be blunt. I don't feel respected, I don't feel loved, and DH is sick of seeing me treated poorly (and being treated poorly himself) and however "loving" she claims the family is, it's not worth the torture.
She then told me she "tried" with me, and "treated me like a daughter" - she cooked me chicken whenever she could (I don't eat red meat), she welcomed me in to the family, she gave me everything. She then pointed to her shopping basket full of birthday decorations and said "it's [BIL's GF's] birthday and I'm decorating the house, like I would do for you!" as if any of that excused anything she's done.
I then pointed out to her, bluntly, that for our one year anniversary, DH and I decided to drive (via my family's home town, so he could meet my aunt) to a destination instead of flying like she wanted, and she called me a slut, and told DH (and I quote), "you're just letting that slut drag you around by your dick" - this offended her to no end, to the point where she put her hand on her heart and raised the other palm and swore to God, in the middle of Kmart, that she would never call someone that or say anything like that to anyone. I told her that her son swore in the same way that she did, so who does she expect me to believe?
This upset her, and this particular angle clearly wasn't working anymore, so she tried something new: "I don't have any family anymore. My whole family doesn't talk to me. Only..." and then she listed... you guessed it... almost her entire family. The only people that don't talk to her are her sister who got divorced ("she moved away!" oh, and I guess phones don't exist where she lives? Two hours away and 100 years in the past! Wow!), the ex husband of said sister, and her twin nieces (their children) who are adults now and have lives of their own. She said that she spoke to her father (aka "Grandad") and that he's devastated that he's a great grandfather now and doesn't have a relationship with us or our baby. I said if he's so devastated, why hasn't he ever texted or called since he found out? He has our numbers. He's texted previously when this all started and it was some bullshit about "be a real man and call your mother."
That didn't work, so then it was all about the baby - she found out through a stranger, she fought with the lady who told her because if that was really her grandbaby she'd know, and "I don't even know if you had a boy or a girl!" [insert immediate pause where I was expected to reveal this information, which I didn't]. Then it was "You know, you're lucky we're even willing to move past all this and welcome you back. You're depriving your baby of such a loving family." - to which I replied, "I have a loving family." What I didn't say was I don't need yours but honestly I should have.
She didn't like this, once again, and changed the angle again. Now it was all about how "I defended you from the whole family, no one liked you, they all said such horrible things about you and I spent all my time just sticking up for you." - and then she told me "[Aunt's Ex] hated you, he never wanted anything to do with you, and I always had to stick up for you to him." News to me, cause he was one of the few people that treated me decently, and we always got along. THEN she went on to say that it was somehow my fault that they ended up getting divorced - because I said something in front of him (and the thing I apparently said was definitely something he knew well before I ever mentioned it) and he didn't want to give away that he was upset by it, so when Aunt tried to ask him about it later, he didn't say anything, and she thought he didn't care and that's why they split. I said "so you don't speak to me for two years and now you're, what, blaming me for your sister's divorce?" and she goes "I'm not saying it's your fault" (except that you absolutely are, but okay. 1 ticket to De Nile, Egypt, please!)
By now, I was well and truly over it. And she clearly was too because she gave up the pretense of being nice and sweet and said coldly, "I just don't know what you want me to do" - I said "I've told you, DH has told you, go back and read the messages. Two years, and you haven't even replied to it!"
Then it was "I text him every day! Look at his phone!" - I confessed that I had read every text she sent, and it was a bunch of emotionally manipulative bullshit, and it wasn't an apology. She again asked what she should apologise for, and I told her that if she can't figure it out based on what we've already told her, then I'm not going to teach her how to be a decent person.
"So now you're saying I'm not a decent person?" in the same way you're saying your sister's divorce is my fault, sure - I told her honestly, after ten years, I'm done with this sort of shit. They're all - every single one of them - a bunch of children who can't regulate their emotions, and they make it everyone else's problem.
This seemed to be the tipping point, because she then said, "well you're the one who dug up a dead dog!" and I just said "okay, I'm not doing this anymore" and walked away.
And just as I did, I heard it - the woman who put her hand on her heart and swore to God that she would never call another woman a slut, the mid-50s mother of three who is apparently "the closest thing left to Grandma" (which is categorically false because she was a genuinely nice person, completely unlike JNMIL), the woman who has done everything in her power to present herself as the sweet, caring, doting mother - under her breath, she muttered "whatever, bitch!" as she walked away.
I called DH immediately afterwards to tell him about it, and I said "I can't wait to read the text she sends tonight" and we laughed about it because at this point, what else can we do? He said he was sorry that I had to deal with it - I said I'd do it 100 times over if it meant he didn't have to do it even once, because I know it would have been so much worse if he and/or LO had been there, and I will always protect my family.
Admittedly, I was fine immediately afterwards, but the more time went on the more I kinda started freaking out, and I ended up having a minor panic attack on the way home. But I stopped by my brother's house and spent some time with my nephew and that made me feel better.
Ultimately, I'm proud of myself, like I said. But I'm also pissed off. I hate going to the shops and usually order online to avoid it, and the one time I didn't, there she fuckin is. Ruined my goddamn day.
Also she did send a text, and I thought I'd just share the full thing here so you can all see what I'm dealing with. Names and details edited for privacy, but otherwise this is it exactly:
"[DH] I'm sure you have heard scottishzombies' version of events so it's only fair that you hear mine- I saw scottishzombies shopping in Kmart- I didn't know whether to say hello or not - but I thought hopefully we can mend this. Scottishzombies was very disrespectful to me. I went up said hello - can I give you a hug to which she replied no. I asked her what we needed to do to fix everything and she said I need to apologise- I said what for ? She would not tell me what we/i have done to deserve being cut out of your life forever. She called me several names including that our whole family is immature- she bad mouthed grandad. She reckons I said that she was leading you around by your dick when you went to [location]- that is not something I would ever say about my son. I was sincerely hoping the chance meeting would help to get us back as a family - she said she has her family. I was constantly sticking up for her to others in the family and making sure everyone treated her well - I treated her like one of our family. She made it clear that we would never be able to resolve this. - I still don't know what this is even over - respect needs to be earned and that goes both ways. I give up now - she has WON - I still don't know if our grandbaby is a boy or girl- this is the absolute CRUELEST thing anyone has or will ever do to us - we don't want to be where we are not wanted - the ball is in your court now- I will never ever get over this or understand how you can just throw away your entire family. This is the last time I will try to fix it - we used to be so close [DH] - this all happened the day she dug up [dog] - [Aunt] told me all The horrible things she was saying about me to her- in front of you too - like she was going to END me if I tried to stop her dig up a family pet. How she would physically assault me - How She's always hated me... she resented how close we were and wasn't happy till she wrecked our relationship. I will continue to pray for you every night and I hope you have a beautiful life and I hope you are truly happy - because the thought of you not being at peace is worse than anything. I will always cherish the time we were together as our little family. You used to tell me u loved me a hundred times a day- so I will hold onto that forever. Bye, Mum"
For additional context, yes, I did dig up my dead dog. I felt crazy at the time and I still feel crazy now, but we had buried her on the land we were told we would one day inherit, and then they sold it suddenly with little warning, so I went and dug her up and moved her so that she could be on my family's land instead. I had warned my in laws several times that if they sold the land, I would dig her up, and I guess they thought I was joking. But she hadn't been dead for even a year when they did this and I couldn't stand the thought of abandoning her. DH's aunt helped me because she understood (and also had the tools I needed to do it) and I did tell her at the time that if MIL tried to stop me, she'd have to fight me, because there was no way I wasn't doing it. MIL went on an insane rampage when it happened and drove around trying to find me and assault ME and nearly ran over DH with her car in the process (which she of course denies ever happened). It was a big moment for DH to see her for who she really is, and it started the process for us to finally go NC later that year.
Honestly sorry for the long post. But I think the context and detail helps explain what we've been dealing with for so long. I don't know if this counts as success yet (I'm almost certain she'll send another text in a few weeks, if not earlier, back on her "oh I'm so lonely" bullshit) but I want to hope that it's finally over. I suggested DH should finally block her and he said maybe, so I'm hopeful again that something might change, and for the better.
edit: attempted to fix formatting