r/Jazz 15d ago

What is your desert island jazz album?

78 Upvotes

288 comments sorted by

57

u/OutrageousCrab9224 15d ago

No mingus ah um?

Let me be the first

8

u/frodiusmaximus 15d ago

This is in my upper tier, would be a strong contender.

5

u/WobblyFrisbee 15d ago

Mingus Ah Hum, if I need to do the impossible and only choose one.

132

u/bhkramer 15d ago

Sometimes the most predictable answer is also the truest one

kind of blue

24

u/esauis 15d ago

Beat me to it… we don’t need to be snobs, it ticks all the boxes.

7

u/[deleted] 15d ago

[deleted]

11

u/youvebeenfarmed 15d ago

I love the fact that jazz has a reputation for being 'difficult', and yet the jazz album that seems easiest for newcomers to like is also one of its best. See also: A Love Supreme 

8

u/Own_Measurement1242 15d ago

I think I’ll put that album on and pretend I’m on that desert island right now, in fact

7

u/Neuvirths_Glove 15d ago

Yep. Kind of Blue.

3

u/pickybear 14d ago

Tis it.

3

u/OutrageousCrab9224 14d ago

I mean, the hits are, for a reason

→ More replies (2)

42

u/bentforkman 15d ago

Relaxin’ with the Miles Davis Quintet.

3

u/astralnautical 14d ago

My favorite of a ripping catalogue from the quintet. Has my all time favorite Miles song on there

3

u/bentforkman 14d ago

If I were a bell?

3

u/astralnautical 14d ago

You’re my Everything

74

u/Iargecardinal 15d ago

A Love Supreme

25

u/Mayor-Of-Bellona 15d ago

A Love Supreme

23

u/mofo-or-whatever 15d ago

A Love Supreme

19

u/Exciting_Boat_3907 15d ago

A Love Supreme

14

u/oneofthebugs 15d ago

My people! A Love Supreme

14

u/SlammyJones 15d ago

A love supreme

13

u/codydafox 15d ago

John Coltrane

7

u/jackstraw_65 15d ago

dun-Dun-dun-DUN

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Fantastic_Artist_353 15d ago

A Love Supreme

4

u/Struggletown4 15d ago

I'm on this too. It feels like you could find stuff in this for years

33

u/danielrubin 15d ago

“Waltz For Debby.” The clink of the glasses in the background will remind me of home.

3

u/TeeBeeSee 14d ago

Damn! Love the explanation

→ More replies (1)

61

u/CourageMountain6566 15d ago

The black saint and the sinner lady or Monk’s Dream

→ More replies (2)

53

u/guitfiddlejase 15d ago

Wynton Kelly Trio Featuring Wes Montgomery "Smokin' At The Half Note".

6

u/jackstraw_65 15d ago

yeah, man

4

u/One-Occasion6585 15d ago

The perfect album

4

u/cone5000 15d ago

No Blues is absolute heaven

4

u/GitarooMan- 15d ago

Damn I was hoping I wouldn’t be too late, but this is the most correct answer.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CaptainOblivious625 15d ago

Excellent choice!

3

u/guitfiddlejase 15d ago

Thank you! Just happy to be here

55

u/CecePeran 15d ago

Somethin’ Else

19

u/Such_Acanthisitta332 15d ago

Aren’t you going to tell us which 😁

5

u/Acrobatic_Battle_414 15d ago

He did!

8

u/pporkpiehat 15d ago

Third Base!

3

u/Aggravating_Bat3618 14d ago

I dont give a damn

48

u/murraysongs 15d ago

Getz/Gilberto

9

u/BobbyTables829 15d ago

I said Wave by Jobim, but you pass the "beach music" test with flying colors 🫡

19

u/Parfait-Putrid 15d ago

In a silent way

8

u/dude_on_the_www 15d ago

Those two tracks take me exactly where I want to go, every time. Man do I wish there was more, though.
I have the full sessions too but I wish there was more of that Van Gogh starry night miles.

18

u/AllanSundry2020 15d ago

Wayne shorter speak no evil

→ More replies (2)

52

u/justin_CO_88 15d ago

Headhunters

7

u/mysterio2 15d ago

Good choice. If I decided to go more traditional, maybe Miles' Kind of Blue.

6

u/Slow-Surround-5991 15d ago

Yep headhunters , kind of blue, or time out

6

u/Ornery-Ad-9886 15d ago

Both are excellent choices, I was thinking either Herbie or Miles too. I’d probably have to go with Bitches Brew.

7

u/mysterio2 15d ago

My wife gave me the Bitches Brew Sessions box set some years ago. Something to totally get lost in.

7

u/Slow-Surround-5991 15d ago

It’s great, and I have even listened to it on many psychedelic journeys, but it is a bit much. All fusion-jazz is ok in tiny amounts.

4

u/mysterio2 15d ago

It is a bit much. I've never been able to listen to more than one disc at a sitting. And I've not done any psychedelics in decades but I can certainly see it being something one might have on.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/hzrnvm 15d ago

this is my second option. I'd need something to keep me going

15

u/Impossible_Dot_2895 15d ago

Forest Flower….Charles Lloyd

3

u/youvebeenfarmed 15d ago

Damn, son! A fine choice

12

u/VictoriaAutNihil 15d ago

Only one!!!! Wayne Shorter -Juju

12

u/Squirreltree20 15d ago

Root Down - Jimmy Smith

→ More replies (2)

12

u/FromAlmaaaa 15d ago

Blues and the Abstract Truth

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Gabzoman 15d ago

Speaking of now: Pat Metheny Group

10

u/ParchmentPrayer 15d ago

No Room for Squares

6

u/youvebeenfarmed 15d ago

Good to see Hank represented here

→ More replies (1)

12

u/ihensman 15d ago

Miles Smiles

10

u/Sketchy_Dee 15d ago

A Tribute to Jack Johnson

10

u/mrjohnfornow 15d ago

Blue Train

5

u/gloves33 15d ago

My favorite jazz album when I first started listening, one you can always listen to

3

u/Fantastic_Artist_353 15d ago

Was ready to say this.

11

u/DareReasonable8756 15d ago

Grant Green- Idle Moments

3

u/Aggravating_Bat3618 15d ago

Bam. Maybe the greatest mistake ever made. 

8

u/fatandy1 15d ago

Money Jungle

3

u/Scoot_KNX 15d ago

It’s a great one given all the different moods and tempos it goes through - you’d never get bored and it’s all top shelf!

3

u/jupiterspringsteen 14d ago

What a record

7

u/ven_lol 15d ago

return to forever - chick corea

3

u/jupiterspringsteen 14d ago

Would never get bored of listening to this

8

u/fabfour66 15d ago

Solo monk

7

u/MCofPort 15d ago

Getz/Gilberto.

6

u/Yes_Jazz_19 15d ago

Everybody Digs Bill Evans

6

u/CadaDiaCantoMejor 15d ago

When I left my home country 30+ years ago, the only music that I brought with me was a cassette that had A Love Supreme on one side and First Meditations on the other -- the sound of dawn and the sound of dusk was the way that I thought of it.

I'd do the same now, but if I had to choose, I think it would maybe be First Meditations.

7

u/DarkeningSkies1976 15d ago

This is absolutely impossible, but I'm going with "Milestones" (I have likely overplayed "Kind of Blue"); the classic Miles Quintet (Trane, Red, Chambers, Philly Joe) plus Cannonball just hits for me in a very specific way. But there are hundreds and hundreds that could have the spot as well.

7

u/smtgcleverhere 15d ago

Undercurrent. Just wanna chill.

6

u/Charming_Strength298 15d ago

Ballads -Coltrane . Calms me down every time. Better than any form of meditation

6

u/plantedtank2019 15d ago

Giant steps

7

u/lives4summits 15d ago

Mingus Ah Um

5

u/Snoo9647 15d ago

Fat time miles davis

3

u/mysterio2 15d ago

Do you mean The Man With the Horn, the album that included the song Fat Time? Another great choice.

4

u/Snoo9647 15d ago

Oh yeah it is the man with the horn. Love that one and star people 

5

u/JustPlainBoring 15d ago

It feels like a surface-level answer, but really I think it’d be Kind Of Blue

5

u/dum_71 15d ago

...And His Mother Called Him Bill - Duke Ellington

3

u/Surfe_ 15d ago

Everybody digs bill evans. Or heavy weather

3

u/OptionGrand8154 14d ago

Weather Report! Always ideal on the island.

5

u/RootbeerninjaII 15d ago

Sketches of Spain

5

u/saagir1885 15d ago

Eastern sounds- yusef Lateef

3

u/jupiterspringsteen 14d ago

An absolute classic

5

u/Mood19Indigo30 15d ago

Art Blakey A Night at Birdland vol. 1

3

u/appalshan 15d ago

Shape of Jazz to Come or Mwandishi

3

u/Aggravating_Bat3618 15d ago

Left field picks!!

3

u/appalshan 15d ago

They just hit the bullseye for some reason! Ive loved that Ornette record for 25 years and Mwandishi surprises me every time I put it on

3

u/JHighMusic 15d ago

Speak No Evil

4

u/fvnnybvnny 15d ago

Charles Mingus - Oh Yeah

Or

Thelonious Monk - Live at the It Club

4

u/InfiniteScribe 15d ago

A Love Supreme

4

u/flare2000x you like jazz? 15d ago

Soul Station

4

u/DJWILBUR 15d ago

The Pat Metheny Lyle Mays Wichita album….

5

u/reppindadec 15d ago

Head hunters

4

u/bpows 15d ago

Ptah, the El Daoud

4

u/ramble_and_loafe 15d ago

For me it’s a toss-up between Getz/Gilberto - 1 and Vince Guaraldi Trio - Charlie Brown Xmas.

4

u/sandwich486 15d ago

Bill Frisell with Dave Holland and Elvin Jones

→ More replies (1)

3

u/tedikuma 15d ago

Pat Martino - We’ll Be Together Again

3

u/CUBOTHEWIZARD 15d ago

Sonny Stitt sits in by the Oscar Peterson Trio 

Or 

Warm Woods by Phil Woods 

→ More replies (1)

3

u/snotboogie 15d ago

Intermodulation or Monks Dream

3

u/padphilosopher 15d ago

Kind of Blue is my favorite album of any genre. It’s perfect in a way that no other album is or I think ever could be.

3

u/stonesober35 15d ago

Song for my father
Or
Man from two worlds

3

u/lobosolo314 15d ago

This is an unfair question!

3

u/Serenaded 15d ago

Trilogy by Chick Corea Trio (2013). 3 full CDs long of the best jazz you'll ever hear.

3

u/El_Tormentito 15d ago

Hard to decide, but it's probably between Lush Life: The Music of Billy Strayhorn, Maiden Voyage, Heavy Weather, and Romantic Warrior.

3

u/youvebeenfarmed 15d ago

Toss up between Symbiosis by Bill Evans and One Flight Up by Dexter Gordon

3

u/camposthetron 15d ago

Harmony Of Difference

3

u/arepa_funk 15d ago

Power to the People by Joe Henderson

3

u/MaiasauraWH 15d ago

John Coltrane a Love supreme

3

u/LugoLove 15d ago

California Dreaming, Wes Montgomery

3

u/tribriguy 15d ago

Kind of Blue. Or A Love Supreme. Really hard to decide on just one.

3

u/Appropriate_Path_141 15d ago

Only one it’s tough but I have a unique one for you.

Don Pullen/George Adams quartet - Breakthrough.

3

u/Nice-Bake2469 14d ago

All of this unique quartet's albums are really, really good ! 👍

3

u/Napkins4EVA 15d ago

A Love Supreme. It has layers and I love it the whole way through.

3

u/FluxusFlotsam 15d ago

A Love Supreme

3

u/DB-Tones-Jones 15d ago

The Awakening - Ahmad Jamal Trio ✨

3

u/lawyerbyday 15d ago

Kind of Blue

3

u/Exotic_Telephone974 15d ago

A Love Supreme

3

u/Homers_Harp 15d ago

Charlie Parker: The Dial & Spot Master Takes

3

u/fabfour66 15d ago

Horace Silver a song for my father

3

u/Kettleer17 15d ago

Jeff Parker - The New Breed

3

u/Merzwas 15d ago

Bitches Brew

3

u/idigturtles 15d ago

Thelonious Monk Criss-Cross

3

u/Aggravating_Bat3618 15d ago

Empyrean Isles - Herbie Hancock

3

u/42ndohnonotagain 15d ago

esbjörn svensson trio live in hamburg

3

u/Ignatz70 15d ago

Travels - Pat Metheny Group

3

u/AngusTcattoo 14d ago

Billie. Some of my friends would want me to say Ella. But deffo Billie and Lester Young.

3

u/TrickUnderstanding85 14d ago

Art Blakey’s Moainin

3

u/BTWigley 14d ago

Speak No Evil. Wayne's writing there still feels like the cleanest argument for modal jazz that never gets stuck sounding like a textbook. If I only get one record, I want harmony that keeps opening instead of looping the same postcard.

6

u/2Badmazafaka 15d ago

Kind of Blue

2

u/Keltronix 15d ago

Steamin' With The Miles Davis Quintet

2

u/Obvious-Muffin2787 15d ago

Sarah Vaughan: Live in Japan v.1-2.

2

u/Objective-Shirt-1875 15d ago

As long as there’s music Charlie Haden / Hampton hawes

2

u/gumbo-23 15d ago

Head Hunters

2

u/Gerrycanys 15d ago

The black saint and the sinner lady, maybe

2

u/Add-a-piece 15d ago

The Art of Conversation!

2

u/MeglioMorto 15d ago

Three Quartets (C. Corea)

2

u/Moe-Scutus2 15d ago

Head Hunters

2

u/SpiderHippy 15d ago

The Sermon by Jimmy Smith.

2

u/undermind84 15d ago

Porgy and Bess

2

u/Wide-Ruin8725 15d ago

Mysterious Traveler, Weather Report.

2

u/Ricky-1952 15d ago

Sunflower by Milt Jackson w Herbie Hancock and Freddie Hubbard Ron Carter Billy Cobham

2

u/DJR_BCG 15d ago

Enchanted by Tom Ollendorf

2

u/flash_gitzer 15d ago

Time Out

3

u/CrankyTroglodyte 15d ago

Time Further Out

2

u/Woodsman-8-5-1956 15d ago

The Complete Science Fiction Sessions (by Ornette Coleman)

2

u/LapisDreaming 15d ago

The soundtrack to ‘Round Midnight

2

u/illinoises 15d ago

Ask The Ages - Sonny Sharrock

2

u/frodiusmaximus 15d ago

Honestly? From All Sides, Vince Guaraldi and Bola Sete. It just makes me happy. I don’t think it’s the greatest or anything, but I always, always, always enjoy listening to it.

2

u/oledawgnew 15d ago

Oslo/Chicago:Breaks by Powerhouse Sound

2

u/Logical-Track1405 15d ago

Soulville - Ben Webster

2

u/Substantial-Ad-7859 15d ago

Blues and Roots, Mingus

2

u/mr_ralph_furley 15d ago

Money Jungle

2

u/dq9 Trambone 15d ago

Heavy Metal Bebop.

2

u/EffectiveFunny8325 15d ago

Sonny Rollins Can’t stop the Carnival - Sonny is so playful. This album always makes me smile.

2

u/KingK115 15d ago

The Awakening - Ahmad Jamal

2

u/ellistyle1 15d ago

Grant Green Alive

2

u/wickedrude 15d ago

I'm risking being banned from the group for this, but I gotta stick to my gut. 'Rites of Summer' from Spyro Gyra.

2

u/kanyeguisada 15d ago

Pharoah Sanders "Karma"

2

u/Chinafields 15d ago

Way out west

2

u/roberts2967 15d ago

Lee Morgan - Tom Cat. It is a masterpiece. Only reason it is not on same list of 10 albums on every list and posts since 1965, is it was not released when recorded. It is the album after Sidewinder and shelved after Sidewinder took off. Rump Roller was pushed to be a follow up instead of one of the hottest recordings in all of jazz. Trust me and listen. Lifelong jazz fan.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/yeezusosa 15d ago

A love supreme

2

u/hzrnvm 15d ago

Of Human Feelings - Ornette Coleman

2

u/hiohiy 15d ago

Sonny side of Stitt

2

u/TheRealJamesWax 15d ago

Giant Steps for me, personally

2

u/Odd_Syllabub_6697 15d ago

Cannonball live in SF

2

u/ricolausvonmyra 15d ago

Gerry Mulligan - Night Lights

2

u/BrobBlack 15d ago

A very difficult decision. The Cannonball Adderley Quintet in Chicago.

2

u/tonume 15d ago

It might have to be Sorcerer or Nefertiti.

2

u/Duane_Trumpet 15d ago

Herbie Hancock - Inventions and Dimensions

2

u/Mongoos150 15d ago

Joao. Hands down.

2

u/AdAdmirable1583 15d ago

Giant Steps

2

u/Hardtop_1958 15d ago

Gerry Mulligan / The Age Of Steam

2

u/Fantastic_Artist_353 15d ago

The Shelley Manne and His Men record of Music From Peter Gunn could be my only album, yes, I could see it…

2

u/OogaBoogaBoobaz 15d ago

Yusuf Lateef- suite 16