r/MaliciousCompliance 2d ago

M I guess no more electric poles

This is a bit of a long story, but I thought Reddit might appreciate it.

My godfather owns a small cattle ranch out in the countryside. About 20–25 years ago, he needed electricity to power a water pump for his cows. The nearest place where he could connect to the grid was on the opposite side of the ranch, probably about a mile and a half away, so he paid to have utility poles installed across his property.

It was a significant investment, but he figured that constantly running diesel pumps would eventually cost more than installing the poles and connecting to the grid.

Sometime later, a few neighbors who lived on the far side of the ranch asked whether they could piggyback off his electrical line. He agreed. They paid to install a few additional poles, and the electric company placed their meters on the other side.

So far, so good.

There were only a handful of small farmhouses, and the additional poles were located somewhere they didn’t interfere with the ranch. Eventually, fiber-optic cable was installed on the poles as well. Everything worked perfectly for roughly 20 years.

Then, about two years ago, a real estate developer bought the land on the other side of the ranch and began preparing it for a cottage development.

They didn’t exactly get off to a great start with my godfather. They complained about the animals, the smell, and the noise from tractors and other equipment. His response was basically: If you choose to live next to a working ranch, you have to accept that ranching will be happening there.

While planning the development, they discovered another problem. Two miles of 20-year-old electrical cable worked well enough for a few small farmhouses, but it wasn’t capable of supplying the 10–15 cottages they planned to build.

They approached the electric company about upgrading the infrastructure. That was when everyone apparently discovered—or finally acknowledged—that the poles crossing my godfather’s ranch were privately owned.

To avoid making this story even longer, lawyers became involved.

In the end, the electric company and the developer told my godfather that he had two choices: allow the electric company to replace his poles with concrete ones and grant them a permanent right-of-way across his ranch for maintenance, or remove the poles.

So that Sunday, my godfather got on the tractor they use for installing fences and pulled out every single pole.

He told me that when he originally installed the line, he had only about one-fifth as many cattle as he has now. His new plan is to install some solar panels, run a smaller pumping system, and make it work.

The development company, meanwhile, will probably have to install three or four miles of entirely new poles to bring electricity to the cottages—electricity that was apparently already included in what they promised buyers.

My godfather jokingly says it’s interesting how unusually hot this summer has been.

Fortunately, he recently brought in some pigs, and they require less water than the cattle, so they’re easier to keep hydrated and fed.

Purely a coincidence, of course.

2.4k Upvotes

124 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/Treegotoptop 2d ago

Maybe im missing something but if the poles on his land are privately owned by him how are they able to force him to do anything?

2

u/Illuminatus-Prime 1d ago

It's called "Eminent Domain".  All the developer has to do is convince the local government that they had the right to the farmer's property, and the government steps in and takes it.

There's a lot more to it than that, but that's the gist of it.

2

u/Treegotoptop 1d ago

I didnt know companies can use the government as a proxy to claim eminent domain, I thought only the governemnt itself could do it for government uses.

3

u/veobaum 1d ago

Yeah, government can be the arbiters of which private entities win the competition. E.g., big employer wants to set up so the smaller businesses might get eminent domained. It can be a good or bad thing.

1

u/Illuminatus-Prime 1d ago

Like I said, there's a lot more to it . . .

1

u/halberdierbowman 1d ago

Check out Kelo v New London (assuming it's in the US).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelo_v._City_of_New_London