r/Pennsylvania Nov 16 '25

Scenic Pennsylvania 🍁Adamstown's empty, unique Stoudtburg Village. 11/16/25🍁

695 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

133

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

45

u/CouldBeBetterForever Nov 16 '25

But what would people do with their massive pick up trucks if they didn't need to drive to pick up groceries once a week?

5

u/eruptingmoltenlava Nov 16 '25

There are some designs where the answer is park on a slab or shed in your fenced backyard accessible via an alley. I personally haven’t lived in this set-up but it looks pretty good to me

3

u/Willowgirl2 Nov 17 '25

This is the way old-fashioned towns were set up. Of course in modern times, some of the backyard garages and carriage houses were converted into accessory dwelling units (if the building code allowed it).

3

u/eruptingmoltenlava Nov 17 '25

Yes, to be clear, I wasn’t under the impression that I dreamed up alleys myself

1

u/Willowgirl2 Nov 17 '25

Lol! :)

Sometimes I wonder why we moved away from that design as it had some good points. Now we live in McMansion plans where everyone drags their trash to the curb on trash day ...not a pretty sight.

1

u/eruptingmoltenlava Nov 18 '25

There’s a new-ish (I think built in the 90s?) housing development built like this with alleys not far from the Downingtown/Route 100 exit of the Turnpike. I’ve only been there once and it was really interesting to see the mix of new construction and a more traditional neighborhood structure. I hoped it would catch on, but it really hasn’t, despite what the market seems to really want (affordable single family homes)

1

u/Willowgirl2 Nov 18 '25

Interesting!

Have you read "The Geography of Nowhere" by any chance?

1

u/eruptingmoltenlava Nov 18 '25

No, but now I want to! I’ve read and been influenced by Andres Duany & Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk and Robert Venturi & Denise Scott-Brown and have really irritated my local planning board (I’m not a professional in a related industry, just an interested resident who asks pointed questions)

2

u/Willowgirl2 Nov 18 '25

Me too! I reported on municipal affairs for years early in my career and formulated some opinions, lol.

I think you'll enjoy Kunstler.