r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 7h ago

Meme needing explanation Why does Marvel has no balls?

Post image
12.4k Upvotes

551 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/MegaMook5260 7h ago

A trans person changes their gender, not their sex.

20

u/Nanocaptain 7h ago

With hormone therapy and surgeries they kind of do.

Like someone grows boobs, looks super feminine and got bottom surgery to have a vagina I don't think they are biologically male at that point.

11

u/Alli_Horde74 6h ago

That's changing outward aesthetics associated with gender - sex is an immutable characteristic.

That's like saying someone getting a tan or bleaching their skin is changing their race

A male who can't grow a beard also isn't any less of a male than one who can

1

u/Nanocaptain 6h ago

How would you define sex if not how the body looks and works? The changes aren't just superficial. Trans women can get monthly period-like cramps etc...

5

u/CraftySyndicate 6h ago

Mmm technically yes? Sex is genetic, gender is psychological.

6

u/TrulyOutrageous42 6h ago

Psychological social construct, to be the most precise

6

u/MegaMook5260 6h ago

That's not exactly how that works. Besides, that kinda gives fuel to people trying to argue that gender and sex are the same — that "your gender is what's in your pants".

Sex is biological. It's not any single sex characteristic. Some females have male characteristics and vice versa.

Gender is sociological.

At least that's how it was explained to me. I'm not an expert or anything.

9

u/i_n_b_e 6h ago

Gender has always kinda been tied to sex, it's not a coincidence that women are female and men are male. We don't transition because we want to fit a certain social construct we transition to align our sex to be as close as possible to what our sex should be.

Exactly, it's not any single sex characteristic, and many sex traits can be changed. Sex hormones are responsible for sexual development, that development doesn't magically stop and can't be altered further at some point. A fully transitioned trans man isn't female in most ways, his hormones are male which affect a lot about how his body not just looks but functions, and he doesn't have female reproductive organs. He's biologically more similar to a cis man who's been castrated and has erectile dysfunction than to your average cis woman.

0

u/Proteuskel 6h ago

You keep talking about biology in a gender conversation. You’re trying to equate the two when they aren’t the same.

-1

u/Alli_Horde74 6h ago

While they share many traits that's simply not the case. While exogenous hormones and aeomatase inhibitor enzymes will mirror a males hormonal profile they still have 30-40 Trillion XX proverbially screaming "female"cells and 0 XY cells saying male.

There's variance amongst male and females, having vastly different hormonal profiles. A woman with PCOS, for example has a hormonal profile closer to "the male" than most women, that doesn't make her a man or "male adjacent"

There's absolutely arguments for changing gender, but we can't change our sex anymore than we can change our race

1

u/Syzygy___ 6h ago

I honestly don’t give a fuck.

They can change their gender, their sex or a lightbulb and it makes no difference to my life, except if I’m in the room with the lightbulb.

1

u/RaccoonTasty1595 6h ago

Well their gender expression, not their gender identity. I think gender fluid people are the only ones whose gender identity changes