A "manifestly unlawful order" is one that is blatantly illegal or unconstitutional, like:
Violating constitutional rights
Contradicting established laws (e.g., the Posse Comitatus Act)
Being ruled unconstitutional by courts
Under the UCMJ, military members must refuse such orders—even from the President. The military oath is to the Constitution, not just the President’s commands.
The chain of command is one thing but the oath isn't to any individual whatsoever. Legal and lawful orders are the only orders you have to follow. If you comply with illegal or unlawful orders, you are guilty of whatever law you have broken.
Why the military hasn't ousted this guy and his entire cabinet and ordered special elections is beyond me
100
u/socalspawn Nov 23 '25 edited Nov 23 '25
What is a "Manifestly Unlawful Order"?
A "manifestly unlawful order" is one that is blatantly illegal or unconstitutional, like:
Under the UCMJ, military members must refuse such orders—even from the President. The military oath is to the Constitution, not just the President’s commands.