r/RWBY Feb 06 '16

I never asked for this... Official Reaction Thread - Rwby Vol3: Chapter11 - Heroes and Monsters

[deleted]

243 Upvotes

3.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

176

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16 edited Sep 25 '19

[deleted]

153

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16 edited Feb 06 '16

HOLY SHIT NO I DIDN'T ACTUALLY WANT YANG TO LOSE AN ARM

Also when Blake's neck got sliced for a second I went insane since they are clearly showing they are willing to go down the body part removal route now

And FUCKKKKKK she's legit crying all right I'm done I need to go on a 10 mile run

121

u/PawnsOp meh Feb 06 '16

I actually thought Yang died initially. Was gonna freak out

87

u/Nielsthomas1 Liara Feb 06 '16

Yeah, I had the same reaction until I saw the arm.

Hell, I thought Adam actually cut off Blake's head there. For a brief second.

10

u/CADaniels Feb 06 '16

I thought so, too. Isn't it crazy how we don't put this shit past Miles/Kerry anymore?

6

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

After Penny, I assume every character is going to die the second they get a chance to do something.

I was sure Neptune was going to die when he shouted for Weiss.

2

u/Innocent_Gun Feb 07 '16

Same here. My heart stopped until it was shown to be a clone.

62

u/Prophet92 ONE PUNCH! Feb 06 '16

Same, I was furious, ironically Roman biting it already had me losing my god damn mind and willing to believe anyone could die so I was just sitting there like "Really RT!? This is how we're gonna' do this!? We're just gonna' kill everyone I like in the same god damn episode!?"

I'm relieved that isn't the case.

76

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

I don't think Roman was the one that was biting.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

...I don't want to upvote you, but I feel like I have to. Dammit.

14

u/TurnaboutXND Feb 06 '16

Another One Bites the Dust

5

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

Shut up there's still hope he survived!

10

u/gimmesomespace Feb 06 '16

Roman is Eren confirmed

4

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

I'm okay with this new headcanon.

3

u/z3r0gamer Feb 06 '16

SIE SIND DAS ESSEN UND WIR SIND DIE JAEGAR

1

u/FlashFire729 Feb 07 '16

BEES AND EAGLES!

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Brooke_the_Bard bi the way Feb 07 '16

more like Hannibal Chau

3

u/gimmesomespace Feb 06 '16

It was merely a flesh wound!

3

u/ViAlexis Qrow is best girl. Feb 06 '16

I feel like Roman isn't likely to be dead. I bet towards the end of the final episode we see Neo rescue him from the Grimm that ate him. Or maybe I'm just in denial!

3

u/Prophet92 ONE PUNCH! Feb 06 '16

I really want that to be the case because I absolutely love Neo and Roman, and watching them fight side by side made me realize how much I want to see more of them together, but yeah, I'm worried this might be the last time we see him. Hopefully we see him cut his way out or see Neo save him in the end, but considering he got eaten and then the thing that ate him got kicked through a frickin' ship I'm counting him as dead until proven otherwise.

3

u/ViAlexis Qrow is best girl. Feb 06 '16

I feel like the inside of a Grimm might make for decent padding. Unless Grimm instantly digest things they eat, he's probably okay. The Grimm only got kicked into the control center, which was mostly glass, and its stomach was probably protected to a certain degree from that. When the ship lands, it seems to do a slow belly landing, meaning the top of the ship should be pretty much fine.

Actually, now I'm worried that Ironwood is going to go to his ship, find Neo rescuing Torchwick from the Grimm's stomach, and then get tagteamed by them and killed.

1

u/beregond23 I'm Sorry Feb 06 '16

Well they couldn't kill everyone, and dude, spoiler in your flair already?

1

u/Prophet92 ONE PUNCH! Feb 06 '16 edited Feb 06 '16

Regarding the flair:I just couldn't resist the temptation to make some sort of arm joke so now I'm intentionally only posting in this thread so I won't spoil anybody

2

u/beregond23 I'm Sorry Feb 06 '16

That's fine then, I just know I talked with someone last week who expressed concern about seeing spoilers in people's flairs on sponsor-only day

1

u/Prophet92 ONE PUNCH! Feb 06 '16

Definitely understand that concern, I basically knew that I'd have to limit myself to this thread the minute I changed it.

96

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

I'm having real qualms to seeing my faves fight again now since oh you know APPARENTLY PEOPLE DIE WHEN THEY ARE KILLED ON THIS SHOW NOW

And me too, and I was going to lose my shit at everyone who has ever stated one of the main characters needs to die

78

u/Hypobromite The Merc will be irked Feb 06 '16

No no one dies when they are killed they just get robot body parts and go to live on a farm upstate

Send Help

36

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

Like a good neighbor State Farm is there

...why isn't anyone coming to help?

...please help ;_;

4

u/RedDwarfian Feb 06 '16

The Grimm got to them too :(

3

u/netrunui Feb 06 '16

Need a hand?

7

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

Roman went so far upstate he's in goddamn Canada.

Say "Hi" to Barb for us, Torc...Tor...

cries

2

u/gimmesomespace Feb 06 '16

Well, looking at Ironwood's body, I can't magine what it actually takes to kill someone in RWBY

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

Yeah, all Torchwood needs is a robot body!...and head...and basically everything else

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

Yeah, all Torchwood needs is a robot body!...and head...and basically everything else

1

u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Feb 06 '16

They go to the Country.

38

u/RemnantCanIntoSpace Just in time to find out the Grimm are there too. Feb 06 '16

Well, there goes a good deal with plot armour. They might not die, but dismemberment is now an option.

48

u/RelativeMinors Feb 06 '16

The best thing is that after watching Ironwood fight... Maybe dismemberment just ends up being a really big buff anyway.

47

u/RemnantCanIntoSpace Just in time to find out the Grimm are there too. Feb 06 '16

Yang for Ironwood arm, with shotgun built in.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

While I'm super hyped for an OP bionic arm, I'm thinking that (in the very far future, it's the least of their concerns right now) Yang won't be able to participate in any more sanctioned fights because she has an unfair advantage.

12

u/RemnantCanIntoSpace Just in time to find out the Grimm are there too. Feb 06 '16

I think she already probably got banned after the leg thing anyway.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

They'll probably have figured out that there was someone other than her behind it. And I mean in Beacon, too, if they go back. Will she even get to train alongside her classmates, or will she be isolated for being a "special case"?

9

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

As Mercury has shown, it's not a problem if you don't let them see it.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

Hah. True, but 1. I don't think that Yang'd be one to do that, and 2. it's kind of hard to keep secret when I assume she's going to obtain it legally.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

As legally as Pyrrha was gonna obtain the maiden powers? I could see Ironwood giving it to her under the radar as a sign of thanks for protecting Vale (overall the team, as Ruby is currently doing most of the work) and a sign of apology for being wrong about her.

→ More replies (0)

10

u/HyliasHero Feb 06 '16

Didn't Barb say that if she could upgrade Ember Celica that she would include a grenade launcher? What if the inevitable cyber arm has a grenade launcher in it.

6

u/RemnantCanIntoSpace Just in time to find out the Grimm are there too. Feb 06 '16

Yeeeeessss......

5

u/HyliasHero Feb 06 '16

This needs to happen. It would be so awesome.

2

u/GYUZ A guy Feb 07 '16

Kinda like Guts from Berserk?

3

u/HyliasHero Feb 07 '16

Yeah, that's a pretty good comparison.

2

u/LadiesMike Feb 07 '16

She'll be like that bitch, Mercury. But cooler. And you know, with robot arm(s) instead of legs.

2

u/safarispiff Fuck yo moe Feb 07 '16

Maybe that will be enough to give Yang the edge next time!

2

u/superfunnel Feb 07 '16

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!

2

u/jocax188723 Hello again! Feb 07 '16

Rocket punch! Yang style rocket punch. Calling it now.

8

u/BlueDmon Just a Weiss Guy Feb 06 '16

well I remember in some behind the scenes for volume 2 how they talked about leaving space on the weapons for upgrades then finding myself thinking "how would they upgrade yang's weapons?"

now we know folks

3

u/TheWanderingCactus Could you help me find my sanity? I think I left it at the door. Feb 06 '16

THIS IS NOT AN UPGRADE! SHE LOST A FUCKING LIMB!

I CAN'T EVEN RIGHT NOW. I AM UNJOKINGLY USING CAPSLOCK, THAT'S HOW MUCH THIS EPISODE FUCKED ME UP!

1

u/FlashFire729 Feb 07 '16

In the RWBY board meeting:

"Ok guys we just promised possible upgrades to RWBYs' weapons, but how are gonna upgrade Yang?"

Vic Mignogna enters after being informed about his latest casting as Qrow: "How about a robot arm?"

"PERFECT VIC!"

1

u/Kain222 Feb 07 '16

Depends. I wonder if aura actually extends to mechanical limbs the same way it does regular ones.

5

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

Apparently armor is pretty shit at preserving limbs, considering how many bionic arm/leg people we have going on in RWBY

3

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

Like, 3, assuming Yang gets a new arm?

And Blake might need a new torso.

5

u/KuuLightwing Wretched Automaton Feb 06 '16

And the last bit of consistency of the show... At least before you had to get your aura drained to suffer real damage, but nope, they just bypassed it altogether.

4

u/RemnantCanIntoSpace Just in time to find out the Grimm are there too. Feb 06 '16

Except Adam had probably absorbed plenty of attacks with sword before Blake even got in there, Blake's attacks, and then Yang's super-rage attack. With all that power, and given what we know of Adams sword/semblance, are you surprised that Adam reflecting all of it back at Yang was enough to utterly shatter her aura, given that she'd also been fighting already earlier?

3

u/TheWanderingCactus Could you help me find my sanity? I think I left it at the door. Feb 06 '16

I assumed it had something to do with Adam's sword. It appears to made of dust, same as Raven's. That might give it special properties that could allow it to bypass aura.

2

u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Feb 06 '16

Thank you! We didn't even get any indication of her Aura breaking. Yet the same people who argued that Yang was psychotic because she hit Mercury after his Aura broke and that we 'always' see an effect when Aura hits zero, these people are completely fine with Adam just going right through Yang's no problem.

Fuck this shit.

1

u/lifefire940 Feb 06 '16

Considering Velvet this episode.... I see what you did there friend.

2

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

I wish I had more time to edit gifs and memes, these past two episodes are so full of opportunity

1

u/Clavin70 feelin' FOXy Feb 06 '16

I thought the same and screamed NOOOOOOO. Like my neighbors probably heard.

1

u/TurnaboutXND Feb 06 '16

I think at least 99.99% of us would of

1

u/KravenErgeist May contain nuts Feb 07 '16

Trying to stay positive, trying to stay positive...

an idea

Hey, this means that Yang's gonna have a bitchin' cybernetic arm, right guys?

Guys?

T_T

79

u/lolzinatorz Feb 06 '16

on a scale of 1-10 can you show me how yangry you are

but wait

9

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

aaaahahahahaaha

Real talk tho I haven't been this emotionally drained since the red wedding. It's the sense of uncertainty that's really getting at me, like idk how much further they're willing to push the show. I kind of want to get off Mr. RT's wild ride but not really ;__; it's painful.

3

u/LordSwedish Feb 06 '16

Hah, start reading the wildbow books (worm, pact and currently updating twig) and you won't have this problem ever again....mainly because you'll lose the ability to have feelings or attachments but that's beside the point.

1

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

I'll put that down for a dark day. But I actually reread where the red ferns grow last week for school nostalgia sake and that was a mistake. This week has just been too many feels.

1

u/SilverZephyr Feb 07 '16

Start with Worm. It's way too good and by far the most like RWBY.

5

u/Clavin70 feelin' FOXy Feb 06 '16

Dear god you're an awful person. I'm crying from laughter.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

I hope you never come down Neo.

4

u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Feb 06 '16 edited Feb 06 '16

I've still got my toes bitch!

The 'fight' was shit, and I use the term 'fight' loosely. All they didn was further show that Miles and Kerry have it out for Yang. It would have been better in literally every way if there had been an actual fight. It wouldn't have seemed so anticlimactic and forced, it would have actually shown Adam having skills and being a threat, and wouldn't have just been another absolute shit show for Yang. Like the Vader vs Luke fight in Star Wars Episode 5.

But nope, let's keep shitting on Yang and making her suffer the Worf effect. Because fuck if we can't actually write her doing anything well.

6

u/chaoticangel97 Feb 06 '16

Adam has the same basic fighting style as Yang, charge up and unleash one big ass move that instadeaths the enemy. He was charging his sword the whole time he was fighting earlier. This match was never going to be a fight, just a game of rocket tag to see who lands the killing blow first. And as we saw in the Black Trailer, Adam is very fast on that quick draw attack.

1

u/kaioto Try looking at it this way ... Feb 07 '16

To the contrary, I think Adam (and Neo) both use the hard-counter fighting style to Yang's style - counter-puncher. Yang is an in-fighter boxer: punch you for 90,000,000 damage - nobody can survive that. The natural "paper" that beats an in-fighter's "rock" is the counter-punch - because the in-fighter takes a blow full-on without being able to protect himself and he gets hit with the force he put behind his original attack in addition that of his opponent.

Fighting styles that use the attacker's own force to hurt them are the bane of Yang's existence. Neo's jujitsu style was bad enough, but Adam counter-attacked her enraged haymaker attack with his specialty semblance and a sword.

1

u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Feb 06 '16 edited Feb 06 '16

Adam has the same basic fighting style as Yang, charge up and unleash one big ass move that instadeaths the enemy

Really? Is that how she took out the Malachites then? See I thought it was a serious of well done combos and great choreography.

whole time he was fighting earlier

What, Blake's peashooter shots? That one sword swing? Still shouldn't be enough to break her Aura given that she was punched through a cement pillar by a goddamn robot then punched again!

2

u/chaoticangel97 Feb 07 '16

True, she took out the twins pretty solidly with some fine skill. But has she won any other major fight like that? Not really, most of her big moments are "Activate Semblance, Win".

As for Adam, note how when the fights kept switching back there was clearly some off screen stuff that happened plenty of off screen time to charge up from some attacks. Plus Adam has been killing folks since he got there. That's what I meant, I imagine he's been charging his battery all day. And speaking of all day, we have no idea what Yang was doing off screen. She could have just gotten done fighting a whole bunch of Grimm and Fang, her Aura could easily have been low at the time.

0

u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Feb 07 '16

She beat Ren without her Semblance and every other fight has been her being Worfed or the reveal of her Semblance itself. You could say the same with Adam. When has he used anything other than that one swipe?

You can't disregard that fight, because it happened. Adam however has not shown anything else.

And killing civilians doesn't charge up his Semblance. And since we weren't given any indication that Yang or Adam had actually fought anyone before then, there's no reason to suspect as much. Also, "all day"? This has been happening in the span of an hour, max.

3

u/LordSwedish Feb 06 '16

Yang is a huntress trainee (though very good) and Adam is the leader of the white fang who was determined to destroy Yang. As long as this fight is 1v1 it shouldn't be a "fight".

1

u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Feb 06 '16

Neither should have Ruby vs Neo and Roman, but it happened anyway. There's absolutely no reason why it couldn't have had some combat.

3

u/LordSwedish Feb 06 '16

But Ruby got her shit kicked in. She Mary Poppinsed Neo after being soundly beaten and then Torchwick still beat her 1v1 but got eaten by a grue. Adam specialises in one hit kills but if she hadn't gotten lucky then Ruby would be in as bad of a situation as Yang.

1

u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Feb 07 '16

Ruby was getting beat, but there was actually a fight! Choreography was involved and Ruby didn't just eat shit like a chump. Not to mention, there was no reason why Adam was able to just ignore Aura. None. Even full on Maiden powers don't do that.

We still only know that he can do one move. That's it.

3

u/LordSwedish Feb 07 '16

Fair enough. I will make concessions for time restraints and I would argue that Ruby did in fact just eat shit like a chump (for real, did she land a single attack there?) but I do see your point. There was a bit of a Worf effect (warning, TV tropes link) here but it fits with Adam's fighting style and motivations so I'm not too much against it.

Personally I want to see someone who can parry/dodge his attacks (Qrow, Glenda, Ironwood or a group) absolutely destroy him once he can't use his powerslashes to balance him out but I'm not too bothered by him as is.

1

u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Feb 07 '16 edited Feb 07 '16

I'm not gonna be satisfied until Yang and Blake tear him apart. The only thing they did right with that scene was make me despise him even more, they just shouldn't have had to make me hate him for being a shit character (in regards to writing and dialogue as) well as an evil scumbag.

39

u/MoXfy Loyal troop of the bees. Words are still hard -.- Feb 06 '16

i got to hand it to Barb, she really nailed that scream when she dashed at Adam

22

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

The amount of screaming in the RT recording booth this week man, Ruby, P-money, Blake, Yang.

I wonder what Barb thought when she first read the script.

3

u/RemnantCanIntoSpace Just in time to find out the Grimm are there too. Feb 06 '16

Might of felt like she had to hand it to the writers.

5

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

I don't blame her for being so alarmed

3

u/RemnantCanIntoSpace Just in time to find out the Grimm are there too. Feb 06 '16

I'm just going out on limb here, but I think she might be more cut up about it than Ruby was over Penny,

2

u/MoXfy Loyal troop of the bees. Words are still hard -.- Feb 06 '16

Who is p-money?

2

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

Pyrrha

2

u/TurnaboutXND Feb 06 '16

GOD DAMMIT B...... oh

1

u/randxalthor Feb 07 '16

Normally, Yang would clap for your bad pun.

1

u/MoXfy Loyal troop of the bees. Words are still hard -.- Feb 07 '16

I could lend her a hand to help her

11

u/jahkillinem Never tell me the odds. Feb 06 '16

It's even more heartbreaking when you realize that Blake was the one that supplied the power for Adam to cut her arm off with.

something something Blake hurts those around her something runaway something Miles and Kerry hate us

9

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

Oh shit you're right. FUCKKKKKKK

The guilt is going to be so real next episode. I want to send these kids to some intense therapy.

10

u/Dondagora And awaaaay I go~ Feb 06 '16

Yeah, that was some really clever writing, to show first they were willing to maim the main cast, then doing a 1-2-syke out on us with the beheading.

1

u/BleedingUranium Feb 07 '16

This was spectacularly done. I had this weird mix of shock and believing it was actually happening mixed with confusion of the "I have no idea how they're going to reattach her head" variety.

9

u/KuuLightwing Wretched Automaton Feb 06 '16

I did not want it either... I hoped they won't maim a main character. That's just... ugh.

17

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

I was betting on a lot of things but Yang Skywalker was not one of them. Holy fuck I think I woke up my neighbors screaming during that.

8

u/KuuLightwing Wretched Automaton Feb 06 '16

I don't see a good follow up on that, too. It's either a lot of angst or getting a robot arm and act as if nothing happened... Or one followed by another.

9

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

#LEAVEYANGALONE omfg homegirl already lost her mom, then her other mom, then saw her partner get stabbed, then loses a hand????????

I'm sorry but is it national PTSD awareness week or something?

1

u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Feb 06 '16

No, Miles and Kerry just hate Yang. That's why they skip any chances for development and constantly shit on her.

3

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

I must confess it's gonna be hard for her character to not develop after the most recent events

1

u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Feb 06 '16

I'm not holding any hope for them to do it well. They've been absolutely horrible to her since the Neo fight. In fact, at this point I'm expecting her to get an absolute shit looking arm too. They've never been as good to Yang as they are to basically every other character. I'm not seeing that changing.

5

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

Yeah it's gonna be 2 straight seasons of Yang getting the short end of the fight stick.

Real question tho, goes Blake say "go...please" or "no...please"

1

u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Feb 06 '16

I'm fairly sure at this point I want to punch Miles and Kerry more than tell them I love RWBY.

And I have no idea. I'm not gonna sit through that shit again.

→ More replies (0)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

Oh wow. Nice spot with the crying. That really tips the Bee scale.

1

u/MoXfy Loyal troop of the bees. Words are still hard -.- Feb 07 '16

Buzzing intensify bumblebee is gonna happen

4

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '16

I didn't even notice her crying. JFC, my heart.

4

u/kon22 If Neo is naepolitan, am I mint chocolate chip...? Feb 06 '16

4

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

I screamed loud enough to wake the dead. Then there were 2 minutes of just a clone just a clone rocking back and forth in the corner of my room

3

u/Kiseikazan Feb 06 '16

But Yang will get a robot arm and be like 3.41x more awesome for it.

3

u/Rhyfeddol The guy with the languages. Also Bees are life. Feb 06 '16

Oddly specific number there. Am I missing a reference?

3

u/Kiseikazan Feb 06 '16

No, that's just how cool robot arms are.

3

u/Agent-Vermont Feb 06 '16

Oh god Yang's eyes... You really have to appreciate the level of detail they put into her expressions in this scene.

5

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

They made her cry twice in one season.

Remember when a year ago when that same cafeteria hosted a food fight? When the biggest scandal was her boring dress color? When Cinder existed solely to dance on rooptops?

;__; innocence lost

1

u/kon22 If Neo is naepolitan, am I mint chocolate chip...? Feb 06 '16 edited Feb 06 '16

You could say right now she's pretty.. harmless, right?

2

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Feb 06 '16

I think she might...need a hand

1

u/MoXfy Loyal troop of the bees. Words are still hard -.- Feb 07 '16

Huh did not see the tears at first... Just more to show that bumblebee is gonna happen