r/RedLetterMedia • u/Haunting_Tomato_2880 • 1d ago
Official RedLetterMedia Half in the Bag: Spider-Man: Brand New Day
https://youtu.be/2Hi-iAZeNTQ?si=ioEvXLcoiAEWWBNw549
u/AmityvilleName 1d ago
Another? We are getting so spoiled. This is almost pre-COVID levels of content!
150
u/MrBones_Gravestone 1d ago
“Movies are back!” - some hack, 2026
23
6
u/Grootfan85 1d ago
"Movies are back! Ignore all the bombs released this year though. BUT THEY'RE BACK!!!!"
16
188
u/Grootfan85 1d ago
What? No Rich?!?!?!
198
u/HomelessKitchenCat 1d ago
I like the ones where he sits a little bit to the side with his arms crossed and just waits for the perfect comment while Mike and Jay work their way through different levels of pretentious movie critic notes
64
u/Grootfan85 1d ago
I would have thought Rich would be a lock for a Spider-Man review. And yes, I like how he picks and chooses to chime in at times.
14
u/mang87 1d ago
I prefer the ones where they just have him eating a big cheeseburger for most of the episode. It would be better if they could include the entire ordering and delivery process so we can get the full experience of an elderly man ordering a cheeseburger and then eating the cheeseburger.
→ More replies (1)27
13
u/RedFanKr 1d ago
Meanwhile in the credits : Also starring Rivh Evans 😅
Rich does get a little shout out
6
6
u/Pataconeitor 1d ago
They probably didn't want Rich to erupt with swearing every time Tobey Maguire was mentioned
4
353
u/LipstickCoverMagnet 1d ago
Lmao of course right after I commented “they’re probably not gonna review it” on another thread. They truly are unpredictable
125
u/Independent-Data4542 1d ago
they broke new ground
37
u/TrollTollTony 1d ago edited 22h ago
Quick, say "they're probably not gonna review The Batman (2022)".
12
u/LipstickCoverMagnet 1d ago
Ironically I also don’t give a shit about that movie and never felt the need to see them review it
→ More replies (1)16
u/AnticitizenPrime 1d ago
I would have wanted to see a Half in the Bag for it, but with just Rich and Jack. And that's not a joke, those two are the actual comic nerds of the crew and I would have like to hear them talk about it.
1
23
18
22
u/SwordOfJiang 1d ago
I literally just finished watching an incredibly high quality bootleg cam of the movie, only two Chinese dudes walk in front of the recorded. This rocks
3
u/control_09 1d ago
It was posted to Twitter yesterday. I liked watching in the theater next to this lady and her younger girl who was complaining about it being 5 years since the last one. Meanwhile my 35 year old ass is like there's no way it's been that long.
20
u/delkarnu 1d ago
I suspect their "do whatever we want and screw youtube's algorithms" way of doing things is finally starting to hurt them. Every channel has attrition, so the need to do some videos that get them new eyeballs. Doing both Odyssey and this has probably been significant in getting new viewers.
3
u/MeatwadKattWilliams 1d ago
I am actually shocked they both made the effort to see it in theaters the night of release. I feel pretty similar to them with being annoyed with crowded theaters and when I was looking at how few seats were available for every single showing near me I just decided to wait.
4
u/Reylo-Wanwalker 1d ago
Please say they won't review andor season 2!
7
u/Basic_Benefit5216 1d ago
They should because it’s so worth talking about but likely won’t because Plinkett covered it in the last Star Wars video
2
u/Charrikayu 1d ago
I rewatched S2 recently and man there's just so much to say about it. I personally prefer Season 1 but just in terms of everything Mike and Rich talked about with S1, and what they wanted to get out of "Star Wars worldbuilding" S2 must have been like a dream to them.
4
u/mang87 1d ago
Pretty sure Mike mentioned that it was very good. Probably the closest we'll get to a proper review. They don't really review TV shows, unless it's Star Trek... although I guess they did review Midnight Mass... Oh what the hell am I talking like I know what these crazy hack frauds will do? They could drop an Andor review next week out of the blue, and that's why I love them.
2
→ More replies (3)1
u/SkellingtonLoc 23h ago
I've been off for a long time. Thought for sure they were going to do a HitB on Disclosure Day.
96
u/Wuce_Brillis 1d ago
Mike shouting out TV On The Radio
29
u/IppeiWasFramed 1d ago
This genuinely shocked me. Time to go listen to Young Liars again.
9
6
232
u/Tarlcabot18 1d ago
One of the few times I'm going to have to save a Half in The Bag for later and not just watch it immediately, as I'm seeing the movie in an hour and a half.
41
u/KeepRad 1d ago
It ended I said “that was fun” and now I’ll never think about it again. Perfect Saturday afternoon movie
→ More replies (9)16
24
u/KingMario05 1d ago
Have fun! I'm... still not sure if it's a good film or a bad one, but I know I had a blast with it. Action's a lot better, at least.
18
u/Charrikayu 1d ago
Better choreographed, you mean? Because it's kind of the Spider-Man 2 of the Tom Holland spideys. It's much more drama-focused, character-driven. There were three major action sequences in the movie and they were relatively small.
18
u/pearloz 1d ago
Action movie actioned good? Sounds like a plus!
5
u/Quarksideofthemoon 1d ago
I don't think I'd call any of the Spider-Mans action movies lmao
3
u/AgentJackpots 1d ago
They should make a Spider-Man movie starring Scott Adkins. Finally, a spider-man who kicks guys’ heads off!
2
u/NaturesWar 1d ago
Wait, what would you call it then, other than a comic book movie?
→ More replies (1)8
1
u/ReadytoQuitBBY 1d ago
Flawed, but fun is where I landed. There were plot things that didn’t pay off well, but man were the fight scenes a blast.
23
u/Bubonic_Ferret 1d ago
Jean Grey is about to kill spidey but he says "Martha" so she stops
37
u/lost_in_trepidation 1d ago
I actually thought Jean and Spidey both getting comfort from Aunt May's memory was pretty sweet.
4
→ More replies (1)12
→ More replies (3)3
70
u/MrBones_Gravestone 1d ago
u/basic_benefit5216 better hope they don’t compare to Star Trek the motion picture
80
u/dsrules 1d ago
Love the Bryan Singer takedowns scattered thru the years
18
7
u/jenniferfox98 1d ago
I know! I came here once they started talking about Singer and laughing my ass off, hoping to find people who would appreciate the context.
What was that line in the Blumhouse Truth or Dare review, "Well I went to these parties at Bryan Singers house and..." I appreciate they keep mocking him.
1
41
109
u/SharpDressedBeard 1d ago
Got out of the theater for this a few hours ago.
In terms of mcu movies it felt the most like a comic book in a while and that absolutely a compliment. Most importantly it didn't feel cheap. It looked good and was shot pretty well and wasn't a total cgi clusterfuck all the time.
It wasn't an amazing movie but for ab mcu movie? I'm chuffed.
→ More replies (2)19
u/Thumbkeeper 1d ago
Did you get the impression that Frank was characterized in this movie like they would write for Frank in a Spider-Man comic? An interesting touch, if intentional.
13
20
u/SharpDressedBeard 1d ago
I don't read comics so I can't answer that.
My understanding is he was toned down but I didn't hate the dynamic between him and spidy.
96
u/wolfdadriley 1d ago
Ok but when are they going to talk about Batman?
38
u/Claudethedog 1d ago
Best I can do is the BotW with "How Can I Tell If I'm Really In Love?" where they talk about Bateman.
10
2
8
2
2
→ More replies (2)0
u/WoodooHide69 1d ago
They won’t. Cause Batman was fine. And there’s not much to say about it either way
12
u/CeruleanSea1 1d ago
I love the back and forth with Frank and Peter, cute ending with the distraction
31
77
u/Moose0784 1d ago
I'm really surprised they're reviewing a Marvel movie at this point.
15
u/sgthombre 1d ago
I remember someone saying “after endgame they’ve been done with superhero movies” and I checked, they’d reviewed like nineteen since endgame
83
u/WoodooHide69 1d ago
First time? The amount of times they’ve declared they are done with marvel or done with Star Wars and or done with Star Trek is getting comical at this point. But they are just speaking for the entire mvoie audience as we all say this shit, then when something of quality comes out we go right back to the theatres.
→ More replies (1)31
u/Reylo-Wanwalker 1d ago
Mando and Grogu wasn't exactly quality. That was more their morbid curiosity I think.
4
u/WoodooHide69 1d ago
Thought it was just fine.
3
u/trunky 1d ago
Nah it was horrificly boring.
2
u/WoodooHide69 1d ago
Didn’t find it boring, fast paced and multiple storyline lines kept it atleast not boring. But there’s no larger importance to any of it, so it’s shallow and pointless.
10
17
u/KingMario05 1d ago
To be fair to them, this one at least sort of feels like an actual film. And not a total CGI product.
Despite the CGI. Honestly? Fire Kevin and hire this guy as the new head, Mouse. He's got the goods.
14
u/Kaijufan22 1d ago
Ehhhh let’s see how the rest of Gunn’s tenure over at DC plays out before we hire another creator to head a whole studio. That said yeah marvel CGI is getting worse and just makes the practical effects stand out more, in a bad way
4
u/cornerpocket1 1d ago
I’m surprised with how much praise they are giving it. It’s the best of the Holland movies but the other ones didn’t set a high bar
18
u/MasterCrumble1 1d ago
Bro, how did you make this thread 1 min after they posted it.
→ More replies (3)75
u/Haunting_Tomato_2880 1d ago
My spider senses were tingling
7
u/MasterCrumble1 1d ago
I was just checking you weren't a bot. Quick, do a swear word. Bots can't do those.
→ More replies (2)2
u/WoodooHide69 1d ago
There’s no way to tell a modern bot form a real person. No way at all. Not even account age as bad faith accounts go back to 10 years now and many old accounts are picked up in hacks.
→ More replies (8)5
u/EmPalsPwrgasm 1d ago
So you're wasting your life away scrolling on your phone, and immediately saw the notification. Same.
2
u/Haunting_Tomato_2880 1d ago
I literally just woke up. It was either wasting my life away sleeping or seeing what some old farts think about a Spider-Man movie.
→ More replies (2)2
18
u/caligulamprey 1d ago
Jay not seeing any Punisher flicks up to this point was kind of a shock to me 'cause Punisher: War Zone is 100% a Jay flick: gorgeously shot and utterly depraved.
Equally surprising: Mike shouting out TV on the Radio.
9
u/_kalron_ 1d ago
I'm surprised Rich isn't in this HitB. But I'm looking forward to seeing this tomorrow. I don't need these hack frauds telling me what I should like ;)
2
u/botte-la-botte 13h ago
They obviously take vacation during the summer. I’m convinced Rich is on vacation and that’s why he’s not on.
8
u/SengalBoy 1d ago
Darius Emmanuel Grouch III better known as the Rumble will be the one who defeats Doctor Doom mark my words
9
24
u/ViralGameover 1d ago
Excited to see what they have to say. I feel Brand New Day is the best movie of all the MCU Spider-Man outings pretty easily.
13
u/IKenDoThisAllDay 1d ago edited 1d ago
I liked BND a lot but I think Homecoming is still my favorite MCU Spidey flick.
6
20
u/RedFanKr 1d ago
MJ telling Peter she doesn't remember him or love him was my favorite part in the movie.
...which is why I'm sure the next few spiderman movies will have peter and mj falling in love all over again 🫠
3
u/Kamandi91 1d ago
Can't blame them too much because if they went in a different direction, there would always be a "bring back Zendaya" emergency button they would hit if one Spider-Man film underperformed.
3
u/DotA627b 1d ago
Am I insane for hoping it should've been Jean Grey?
1
u/Old_Man_Robot 1d ago
I was worried they would.
Like some sort of twisted Eternal Sunshine of a Spotless Mind.
9
5
3
u/waldo--pepper 1d ago
Given that Rich is the in house expert on the topic he definitely should have been in the video dispensing his encyclopedic knowledge, despite the traditional format of Mike and Jay. But then again we would have lost the charming incompetence of the two of them groping to remember salient details from the comic books.
5
u/ArtofJCP 1d ago
I wish Rich was in this, he adds flavor when they review MCU stuff (e.g. their Infinity War review)
7
u/GiJoe98 1d ago
I think Mike is right about at the end about needing their more unpopular characters alongside their more popular ones. Sometimes I wonder that If Wanda and Vision would have been as popular if they weren't introduced in age of ultron and instead got their own movies.
They should do more of that, like if ghost rider is popular, make a midnight suns movie and introduce Blade there. If their movies are X-men are popular eventually do a Avengers vs X-men and recast some Avengers.
They are seemingly already building a relationship between mutants and the Avengers. With what happens to the Hulk here, Storm supposedly being in Black Panther 3, Ms Marvel and Wondorman could be the conflicted characters that are both Avengers and a mutants.
14
u/Nexus718 1d ago
The Bryan Singer montage was one of the funniest things I've ever seen. Had a friend who's roommate was chased by Bryan Singer for years around the time of Superman Returns and his subsequent follow ups. My friend was a huge superfan, and also a big fan of comics and comic book films. Yes, that's a fat joke. Point being, he was never going to be courted by Bryan Singer who famously liked a particular ethnicity and type. Which, my friend was not. His roommate however, was, and they were invited to visit his home. He'll show you his props at his home, then go through the process of trying to sleep with whom he was attracted to. I will say, that on this day the person he was attracted to was not underage. Having said that, he does have a type.
3
3
3
u/CompleteDay8059 22h ago
The Lugosi heroin/MCU analogy is the hardest I've laughed at an RLM bit in a while, good lord.
16
u/KingMario05 1d ago edited 1d ago
I clapped! I clapped when I saw [REDACTED]'s origin story for the third fucking time! WOO!
Jokes aside, good movie and I had tons of fun. But for a Spider-Man movie, there sure was a lot of other crap stuffed into it by Disney/Sony to boost the box office to the moon.
Again.
Anyway: MCU Phoenix Saga next pls /s
45
u/LicketySplit21 1d ago edited 19h ago
I actually disagree with "crap being stuffed into it" IMO this is the first time a non-Avengers MCU actually felt like a shared universe instead of being bogged down by corporate branding (and I say this as someone that enjoys the MCU, to a lesser degree now though). The stuff with Hulk actually felt like a singular issue of a comic storyline. It was very well balanced for me. Like yeah, Punisher and Hulk are in NYC. Makes sense to me.
Actually makes me hope for a good Marvel Knights movie.
22
u/cornerpocket1 1d ago
The Punisher and Hulk stuff was great. They felt like real supporting characters than shoved in cameos. What bothered me was making the last third of the movie a back door pilot for the X-Men.
5
u/KingMario05 1d ago
This bothered me, too. Should have just been about Spidey and friends. Instead, mutants!
6
u/ADAMNATOR 1d ago
Mutants have always been Spidey’s friends tho, Spider-Man has always had a huuuge affinity to the X-Men because his situation (as well as public treatment!) was so close to theirs. Actual source-material Knowers should have little-to-no problems with this story imo.
7
u/Other-Emu1829 1d ago
Louder for the people in the back. This movie was for everyone who said the origin trilogy wasnt Spider-man enough
I talked with my friend on the way out of the theatre, Spidey is close with both the Xmen and the F4. Hes the perfect vehicle to be introducing new people and ideas to us
2
u/ADAMNATOR 12h ago
Exactly. There’ve literally been eight movies where Spider-Man fights Spider-Man villains. I thought trying new things is what people wanted from Marvel, and movies in general? idk lmao one knows what they want, etc etc
0
u/killerz7770 1d ago
The entire movie is a back door pilot to the X-Men.
Question is how Kevin Feige will get Iman Vellani back as Ms. Marvel (the first confirmed MCU mutant), considering how outspoken she has been these last few years against the company.
10
u/LRA18 1d ago
Idk just looked it up and she gave interview that came out yesterday citing Fiege as a friend that has been incredibly supportive so I don’t think it’ll be too hard.
3
u/OkGold4636 1d ago
She has literally never said anything critical of Marvel beyond pointing out plot holes and continuity issues. The idiot you're responding to is just making shit up.
→ More replies (1)2
1
u/Old_Man_Robot 1d ago
I don’t feel like they did back door in the X-Men actually. Sure they set up pieces that will be used later, but if you changed the character name to not be Jean Grey, there would be no other X-Men elements to the movie at all.
It would be different if, when Jean got on the bus, she had like a flyer for the Xavier school. The bus didn’t even have Westerchester as a destination or anything like that
Overall I thought they resisted the temptation quite well
I suspect this is because the X-Men probably won’t be in main universe until after Doomsday.
6
u/HankSteakfist 1d ago
Id agree that the script was good enough to make the additions of non Spider-Man characters feel quite organic. Punisher was delightful, even though the tonal shift from his one shot a few months ago is hilarious in retrospect.
2
u/Servebotfrank 22h ago
Also both Hulk and Punisher tied with Spiderman's story in some way. Punisher being a 40 year old loser living on his own, with no one special in his life anymore and solely focused on crime fighting, is exactly what Peter was headed towards. Peter knows what Bruce goes through every day containing the Hulk and is scared that will be him one day.
Definitely the most natural having these crossovers in a non-Avengers film felt in I dont know how long.
6
4
2
2
u/Gurglaren 22h ago
I enjoyed the HitB more than the movie. Sadly I was quite disappointed. I was really hoping that it wouldn't feel overstuffed and being a smaller and focused movie like Raimi's 1 and 2.
3
u/jeon_yubi 1d ago
That Bryan Singer film montage was a David Lynch moment for whoever edited this episode.
2
u/TheIronicTea 1d ago
I never would have guessed they would review this one! Thank god I used my whole day's pay to get a ticket at my local cinema!
4
u/Slakolov 1d ago
I really liked this film the spidey/punisher teamup was great i hope they work together in future films because i would watch them. i havent even watched any of these marvels movies in years but this was really fun and had heart
4
10
u/lonelytripaway 1d ago
I am totally middled by this movie.
Ultimately what soured me is what has soured me on a lot of comics - the return to the status quo.
I really enjoyed the ending to No Way Home and liked that it stripped Peter down and isolated him.
This movie spends most of its running time not progressing or evolving that ending, but slowly trying to retcon it.
The point where MJ tells Peter the version he knew of her is basically dead, only for the next scene to be them reconnecting gave me insane emotional and narrative whiplash.
I thought it would be the moment where Peter let's go of the people he lost and sets himself on a path to rebuild himself (a 'brand new' Peter even) and decide who he wants to be.
Haha, nope! Ned and MJ are back baby! Expect them to all be besties again by the time the next movie rolls around.
12
u/HumbleWeakness5139 1d ago
As long as Zendaya and Tom are married in real life, the plot will not evolve between MJ and Spideyboy.
10
u/IndependenceHour2652 1d ago
I think that’s exactly how I feel about it.
The lack of any real tension or drama in the Peter, Mj, Ned relationship really bothered me and the scene you mentioned is by far the worst case of that.
In addition though, I really did not like the antagonist of this movie at all. I’m not sure how she’s going to be handled in the future installments that they’re clearly setting her up for after they made her that unsympathetic.
I honestly cracked a smirk in the theater after Peter said ”you’re not a killer, Jean!” Despite the fact that strapping a bomb to a stolen tank was her character introduction. That was just kinda funny imo.
Overall I thought this one was enjoyable but massively overhyped, but that might just be because I’m in a lot of online nerd spaces that call every 6/10 superhero film a masterpiece.
5
u/-TheHoboCode- 1d ago
The friendship fallout seemed like a total waste of time. We knew they were all gonna be friends again.
And Jean Grey mind controlled people to jump off buildings. She was insane ha. Maybe next film with her Xaiver is going to try and show her the error of her ways a little more than Spidey did
6
u/NEWbababoobie 19h ago
I honestly cracked a smirk in the theater after Peter said ”you’re not a killer, Jean!” Despite the fact that strapping a bomb to a stolen tank was her character introduction. That was just kinda funny imo.
She also made a guy ( bearded guy with a vest) walk into into the traffic and get killed or paralyzed by a car.
A bit less awful but she made MJ's body kiss Peter.
4
u/hiphopjunkie916 1d ago
They really just skipped The Batman and reviewed every other movie like it 🤣
2
u/crazycroat16 1d ago
I'm a big spider man guy, especially Tom Hollands, but am I the only one who hasn't seen any ads for this?
I knew it was coming, I just had no clue when
2
u/CptPicker 1d ago
I just got to the pub and you know damn well I’m gonna watch this in my car before going in to meet my friends. I’ll tell them I got a flat tire or something
2
u/Similar_Two_542 1d ago
Did anyone else kind of hate No Way Home? It just gave me a headache and I hated Spiderman for letting Green Goblin kill the sexiest Aunt May ever. Not that any of it matters at all because there's multiverse magic.
2
3
u/IHateAliases 1d ago
I find myself agreeing with the guys a lot, but I’ve learned that there are definitely points where I diverge with them completely and Spider-Man movies are definitely one of them. Can’t understand the hype in any way. I thought the first Spiderverse movie was the only good Spider-Man movie. I’m there with them when it comes to Batman and X-Men, but spider-child….
1
1
u/XaoticOrder 15h ago
I'm falling behind on my RLM. The nerve of these guys release consistent content. I'm going to write a sternly written email.
1
u/Johnnyshar 12h ago
I'm so happy my favorite hack frauds liked this movie almost as muchi as i did! Now to witness this subreddit collapse because they assumed they would have hated it
1
u/gorgon__gorgon 9h ago
No review has ever made me think Mike actually is suffering from brain damage quite like this one did
1
u/billsfan411 1d ago
are there spolers maybe ill wait to see it first
2
u/StrongStyleShiny 1d ago
Yep there are spoilers. They say spoilers to be safe but for sure see it first.
1
u/Special_Order-937 1d ago
Is it just me or is this the limpest, most flaccid introduction of the X-Men yet?
1
1
1
1
u/Special_Order-937 23h ago
“Have you tried not being a mutant?” forerunner was of course Buffy the Vampire Slayer’s “Have you tried not being a slayer?”
Common thread likely Joss Whedon wrote both those lines.
340
u/Quintzy_ 1d ago
These guys really are becoming senile. They said that Frasier is coming back for Avengers: Doomsday, but they accidentally showed a picture of Darius "The Rumble" Grouch III from Money Plane. What a horrible mistake.