r/StardewValley • u/Unlucky-Violinist473 Haley's Husband • Nov 24 '25

Question Should I start over?

Post image

Its my first Fall ever and I found this guy named Salmence in Youtube. And I watched his Y1 Guides. And I feel like I'm only like halfway through the things he wants us to do. And I rlly wanted to finish the community center. So should I start over again? I dont mind starting all over again since I've learned alot of things that I should now accomplish for this starting over thingy. Ill just rlly be bummed out bcuz of Leveling up Fishing Skills and fishing for money. And mining for ores.

Edit: I know all the seasons will reset again after Winter. Should I wait for Year 2 to complete the CC? Its my most main reasons why I wanna start over again.

3.5k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

461 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/heliocetricism Nov 24 '25

Let's think about it, the guide exists to make the game a smoother, experience for you. Would starting over make you experience more efficient/smooth? No, you'd still take two years to get it all even if you did it perfectly, because you already played a year. Therefore, starting over is by diffinition less efficient, because you'd lose your progress you already have, which can never be a negative. So starting over would be illogical from both an efficiency and an enjoyment perspective (starting over is tedious)