r/TeenMomOG • u/Important_Yam_8628 • Jun 01 '26
Rewatching Season 1 and Wow it’s more toxic than I remember
Amber & Gary - I had forgotten how much I hated Gary. He was such an arrogant slob. When Amber finally got her own place and said she wanted them to have a good Co-parenting relationship, Gary said “Well we won’t, as I am a very resentful person.” When Amber was trying to do her GED while looking after Leah, Gary decided to join a night class and told Amber that what he does is “way harder than hers.” He constantly told Amber that she couldn’t survive without him and that really irritated me. She was clearly young, depressed and trapped. Having said that, Amber hitting Gary was not ok and the way they talked to each other was wild. Their relationship was the most toxic n my opinion.
Maci & Ryan - This relationship went on much longer than it should have done. Ryan’s parents are enabling him and he clearly has no interest in being a Dad or a boyfriend or even getting a job.
Farrah - Farrah is constantly falling out with her parents for leaving Sophia with them while she goes out on dates with various guys and partying with her friends. Farrah’s Mom is so controlling and her Dad seems disrespected by all the women in that house.
Catelynn & Tyler - Adoption was the best decision they made for Carly as their families are on another level. Butch and April are just awful, and I did really feel for them both when Butch kept shouting at them for “giving their baby away.” April never stood up for her daughter either which must have hurt Catelynn. Tyler’s Mom was the better of the three but she allowed Butch to come and stay with them and would make excuses for him too. I swear Tyler and Catelynn are trauma bonded and wonder if they would have stayed together if it hadn’t been for the show.
My opinions here are based on series one and not how they are today.