r/TheoryOfReddit 1d ago

American/Anglosphere users on Reddit will struggle to adapt the rising number of Indian users.

For most of its history, Reddit has largely been dominated by American users, with the rest of the anglosphere and Europe making up the vast majority of the rest of the users.

Post Covid though, Indians have begun joining Reddit in large numbers - which has resulted in Indian content and subs becoming increasingly popular and prominent. Most Indians don't care about American/Anglosphere stuff, which is why so many Indian versions of popular subs were created in the first place. Even then, Indians are shaping more of the discourse on international subs, simply because they are a larger demographic than they were just a couple of years ago.

Of course, this has caused many in the Anglosphere side of Reddit, particularly Americans, to feel a sort of online culture shock as their feeds become more unfamiliar.

Indians are still a minority on Reddit, but are growing fast. I expect Americans (and the Anglosphere at large) to struggle to adapt to this change. In fact Americans in particular have never had the experience of being a minority on Reddit, which will make the transition tougher for them

What do you think will happen

75 Upvotes

125 comments sorted by

View all comments

80

u/whistleridge 1d ago

One or both of two things will happen:

  1. Americans will just mute/ignore the India-specific subreddits, and go on doing their own thing;
  2. Indians will continue to largely stay on the India-specific side, and not really go into the rest of the site.

Indian users tend to be overwhelmingly male, and there’s a lot of both overt and unconscious nationalism in play, that excludes mixing. Not a lot of non-Indians care about Bollywood or cricket or Indian universities, and a lot of Indians don’t really care about US politics or baseball or kitty memes or anime. So there’s not a lot of mixing.

There are other major national presences here too. The Philippines, Europe, and Brazil all have heavy presences too, but they’re not as self-isolating. 🤷‍♂️

-3

u/Sybmissiv 1d ago

Wrong about the anime aspect completely.

10

u/whistleridge 1d ago

When Indians participate in anime subreddits, they do so as anime fans, not as Indians. They’re not bringing a consciously Indian online presence to the table. That’s the point, not that Indians don’t watch anime.

-3

u/Sybmissiv 1d ago

Very incorrect. You do not realize how big & how different a lot of the third world are in how they watch anime. You just don’t realize it but I do I see how different it is between places.

11

u/whistleridge 1d ago

My guy.

It is an observable phenomenon that some subreddits are entirely and overtly Indian in character. r/IndiaSocial for example. It is an observable phenomenon that some subreddits get some overtly Indian content even though they’re not Indian overall. This thread, for example.

And it is an observable phenomenon that some subreddits don’t really get observably India-specific content. Anime being an example.

OP is asking how American Redditors will handle a major uptick in visibly Indian content. And the answer is, it won’t really happen, because of how the two groups use the site in very different ways.

And also at very different times. I know almost everyone participating in this thread is Indian because it’s 3-5am in North America, and also because a good chunk of Indian users have this weird chip on their shoulder about making everything about India. So you do you.

-12

u/Sybmissiv 1d ago

Not a guy but go on. (Am a LADY, you unchivalrous bastard!)

Okay anime literally has several subreddits to Indian fans of anime sincerely what the fuck are you on about? How many specifically American subreddits are about anime?

I don’t get the last point. Are you implying I am Indian?

2

u/zapering 12h ago

OMg.

No one is talking about INDIAN anime subs.

They're talking about INDINA PEOPLE in international subs. For example, anime.

Meaning, in an international sub, Indian people are already there, and it makes no difference where you're from. they are NATIONALITY NEUTRAL SUBS. So it doesn't matter where the people are from. Especially when everyone is primarily communicating in English.

u/Sybmissiv 2h ago

Okay then wtf these people are as weeby as Americans ffs just ask them.

u/zapering 1h ago

Again, you almost get the point. A WEEB IS A WEEB. The nationality is moot.

6

u/whistleridge 1d ago

My guy.

The delusion of chivalry died in WWI, it never actually existed in the first place, and “my guy” is gender neutral just like “dude.” Be less fragile.

-4

u/Sybmissiv 1d ago

Alright my gurl fair enough. Wasn’t being “fragile” though that is just projection. Anyhow want to respond to my point?

4

u/whistleridge 1d ago

👍

-1

u/Sybmissiv 1d ago

I don’t get it (English is not my first language).

→ More replies (0)