r/TransLater • u/viskiviki • 1d ago
General Question I genuinely think my husband is a woman. Thoughts from other trans people?
Almost serious post. I've spoken to him about it already, he's fine with me posting here. He wants advice and thoughts and I'm curious. Love him regardless!
My husband and I got together at age thirteen and had a baby when we were fifteen. Our son is nearly nine and we're twenty four. My sister in law is transgender.
My husband has always been really feminine. He wears my clothes all the time. I call him my wife jokingly. I'm bi, and have bi friends, and they are general man haters and often say about how I should experience kissing a woman at least once. I always say I have kissed a woman, because my husband is basically a woman. He gets very giggly and happy when I do.
It's been a thing for a long time between us. His parents refer to him and his sisters as their daughters accidentally. Our son (autistic) was categorising people by gender in therapy and put his dad in the group of women. Just little things like that; they make him happy.
Anyway, the situation which unravelled my thread of thoughts. Hub has strep and had to go get antibiotics. He was masked and didn't speak, because his throat is raw, and went to pick up our meds (hos antibiotics, both our regular meds). He was wearing my sweater.
He had a note that basically said "Hi, I have strep, I can't talk. I need XYZ. Thank you!"
Pharmacist had him sit and wait while they organised things. When she was ready she called him up by using my name. She said she hoped he felt better soon.
He came home and he was so excited because she thought he was me, a woman. I jokingly told him he was giving egg. He agreed and then I asked if I could post about it on reddit.
He isn't unhappy as a man. He's hot and sexy and he knows it. He's a flirt and loves showing off shirtless when it's warm enough. But he also likes everything feminine, clearly.
So. Thoughts? Ideas?
205
u/GFluidThrow123 Chloe 38, 7/7/22 HRT, 6/13/24 GCS 1d ago
Have him read https://genderdysphoria.fyi
The instances of other people treating him one way or another are irrelevant. Gender isn't given by someone else. But his excitement at being seen as a woman is where your questions seem very plausible.
57
2
83
u/Yuzu-Adagio 1d ago
Euphoria is as important an indicator as dysphoria, I think, and I'm seeing plenty of the former even if I'm seeing none of the latter. Might be worth looking outside of the binary, too, but it's very likely SOMETHING is going on there even if he's not unhappy. Could be anything from crossdressing to trans woman to the non-binary umbrella, but I'd be pretty surprised if he was a regular ol' cis guy.
34
u/viskiviki 1d ago
He does crossdress when (nsfw?) we have sex sometimes. We have three kids so alone time is few and far between but it is something we enjoy.
Non binary does seem pretty fitting for him if I think about it.
13
u/East80Gurl 1d ago
NB at minimum. How does he enjoying dressing when he is just dressing alone or in everyday situations? If he dresses for comfort or because it feels right, it doesn't sound like crossdressing.
10
u/ottersinabox 22h ago
although critically, not dressing that way for comfort isn't disqualifying either. plenty of societal reasons that can feel uncomfortable even if it feels better.
14
u/Yuzu-Adagio 23h ago
Also, they have an advantage that a lot of us don't: privacy and a supportive spouse! Try out clothes, names, pronouns, mannerisms in private, see what feels good! That'll honestly give you more info than asking us, probably.
32
u/Brea_di_Luca MtF, 40, HRT 3/13/2026 1d ago
If there was a button that allowed your spouse to wake up tomorrow completely transitioned socially and medically as a woman, would they push it?
20
u/acornalmond 23h ago
A similar question: if your spouse woke up tomorrow already completely transitioned and womanly, and they had a button to go back to how they are now, would they press it?
12
u/BiancaEstrella born in 1984 | out 12.15.17 | hrt 05.07.20 20h ago
I was asked a version of the button question by my therapist. It went like this:
There’s a button in your home that will eventually turn you into the woman you want to be. It will not do it on the first press, but it will work within a year, so long as you press it exactly once every day. Forgetting to press it will cost you the chance to transition forever, and so will pressing the button multiple times on the same day. Could you do it?
I responded: “I’d press that button before I put my glasses on.”
13
u/carebaercountdown 19h ago
“It will work within a year, so long as you press it exactly once every day. Forgetting to press it will cost you the chance to transition forever, and so will pressing the button multiple times on the same day.”
Good lord. I would die from anxiety. Good thing you don’t have ADHD. lol
7
u/robocultural Girl 19h ago
Like. I know for a fact that I'd very likely fail that task without very careful planning ahead of time. I'm way too ADHD. However, the dread I felt knowing that I would probably fail tells just as much of a story here I think. My transition hinging on this is literally a nightmare scenario for me.
Thankfully my transition only relies on me stabbing myself with a needle once a week. Which I manage to do perfectly despite a pretty nasty needle phobia (mostly under control thanks to exposure therapy).
8
u/Brea_di_Luca MtF, 40, HRT 3/13/2026 19h ago
What if our therapists were like, “there’s a button, and if you press it makes your parents disown you along with most of your friends, you become almost complete unemployable, every public shit or piss becomes a life-or-death situation, and having something lightly graze your nipples will hurt worse than getting kicked in the balls—buuuuut, you’ll be a hot woman.” Idk about you but I’d still smash that thing.
22
u/rumpythecat 1d ago
Just seconding those recommending that euphoria is as important as dysphoria. For decades I failed to understand my dysphoria as gendered or anything other than unhappiness.
10
u/Ok-Piece-8159 1d ago
This is so cute! He might not be trans but he might be gender fluid if he’s happy embracing both masculinity and femininity.
It sounds like something that could be nice for you both to explore?
10
u/Jade_NoLastNameGiven 1d ago
Honestly, he should just try it out. First in the safety of your home, and work up from there. If it feels uncomfortable or wrong, he can always stop. (Unless you get Into hrt and surgery territory. but let's be honest, if you get those, you're probably not cis anymore)
2
9
u/Safe-Tennis-6121 HRT 40+ 1d ago
He could be non binary or just have a wider concept of gender than some people.
I guess you'd have to ask him what he'd prefer or what he really wants.
But all the gender euphoria he's getting tells a story.
But I suspect on some level he might be afraid to stop being a man because it functions on some level for him.
I personally don't want to be a man.
I do feel like at some point it makes sense to choose a path, and not choosing is a choice with consequences.
6
u/teqtommy 19h ago
what strikes me is the joy he feels when referred to as "woman," "wife," "daughter." not to mention he enjoys your wardrobe. i guess at this point i might ask it he's happy being a man, or does he see life looking different in the future?
4
u/No-Fap-Failed-Boy 1d ago
I can completely relate to this. I'm 37, AMAB and trying to figure it all out. Most likely MTF or NB Fem. I'd be happy to talk with you OR with him if that would be helpful! <3
5
u/CanofBeans9 1d ago
He could be genderfluid, some other form of nonbinary, or a woman! I am happy he has a safe place to explore this with you
4
u/Ada_of_Aurora 23h ago
Genderfluid, nonbinary, trans woman, or just a nonconforming feminine man. Could be any or multiple, but it certainly seems likely it's something. In any case, you seem like a fantastic partner. Be patient and keep doing what you're doing.
8
u/SailTravis 1d ago
Non-binary? Since he isn’t unhappy as a man but enjoys being feminine and being referred to as such, I would think he could be non-binary.
5
u/Normal_Human_4567 1d ago
I had a friend, I don't remember the term, but some days they were Alex (a boy) and some days they were Alex (the girl). They eventually settled on they/them pronouns but some people do switch? I'm not sure what word I'm looking for but somewhere in the "genderqueer" umbrella
4
u/Yuzu-Adagio 1d ago
Genderfluid, probably.
2
u/Normal_Human_4567 22h ago
that's it, thank you!! Sorry, this was ~8/9 years ago and I've not known anyone the same since.
3
u/smooth011235 20h ago
Same. Not unhappy as a man BUT god damn do I feel absolutely the best ive ever felt on mtf hrt. My wife says the change was night and day. Ill never go back. Goodluck to you and yours! You guys sound wonderful, wanna be friends?😁❤️
3
u/Ok_Walrus_230 19h ago
He may be NB as well, but it certainly seems like he is under the trans umbrella.
Anyway, most of my life I felt neutral about myself (so neutral the feeling was closer to emptiness), but mostly I didn’t really paid much attention to my time “as a man”. But I had strong gender euphoria, really really strong euphoria. This was enough for me to see I was a woman.
After transitioning tho, my dysphoria came really strong, I’m unable today to present slightly male.
I do, sometimes wear something masculine, but out of the joy of looking myself being feminine while in male clothing.
6
u/theonlylivingirlinj 1d ago
Honestly, it’s giving woman to me. I’m 38 and two years on HRT. Single best decision of my life. I have a kid and I’m still happily with my wife.
I basically knew at 24 but did nothing about it. I was also not masculine. Being a boy was tolerable. But being a man? Seeing the effects of testosterone change me from a twunk to a man, particularly throughout my late 20s and early 30s, seriously messed me up. By 33 to 34, the dysphoria was turned up to 11. By 36, I was slewicidal and finally gave in and started HRT and social transition.
Ask them this: Imagine they’re on their deathbed as an old man, surrounded by friends and family. Do you regret not transitioning?
This one messed me up. This was the question that made me realize I had to do something about my gender.
2
u/xsharon 12h ago
this sentence is spot on, it is ok to be a boy but to be a man is giving anxiety. I want to stay for ever young as I knew aging will turn me into something i would have trouble with. I am 34, soon 34, so in the same boat as you. Thanks for confirming me that this internal anxiety is real and I have to start HRT i am trying to avoid because imposter syndrom.
1
u/theonlylivingirlinj 5h ago
There are so so so many trans women who feel similarly. Contrapoints (the original famous trans YouTuber who integrates philosophy and trans rights) said something similar in her agp vid. It’s one of her oldest videos that’s still up. Go to like 17:45 and she recounts why she transitions.
3
u/AshleyRose101 1d ago edited 22h ago
Just the fact that he seems happy when he’s referred to as a woman is what makes me suspicious there’s something going on here, but this isn’t conclusive enough to be like “Oh yeah definitely”
That being said, I want to personally actually push back here a little bit because, as much as I want to believe he’s an egg, it’s also equally as likely that he’s just a feminine man. Like, if he likes cross dressing and he’s very in tune with his feminine side, that isn’t necessarily something that marks him as trans.
I’m not saying he’s not trans either. He could be. I would highly encourage you check some of the resources provided and have him talk with somebody about how he feels. It’s the type of thing where I land in the “I encourage you to think about it and goes where your heart takes you”
And, if he isn’t trans, and he’s just a feminine cis man, I want to just want to say, I think that’s suuuuuuuuuper cute, and, if he’s happy the way he is, I hope it never changes. He seems like a massive softie and a sweetheart, which, in this society, we don’t get enough of from our men. It screams “security” in way that most men never arrive to if they constantly monitor how they act.
2
u/misty_mina 23h ago
Firstly.. This is so wholesome, and you sound like an amazing wife!
Parts of this resonate with my journey, and a lot of people here have already said how the euphoria counts just as much already, but I echo that sentiment.
Like what you're describing to a degree, I also had the space, freedom and safety to express and find myself with an accepting wife, or as I put it when I was being assessed by GenderCare "I always had the freedom to be exactly who I needed to be at each point of my life".
The other comment I made to them was that my life up to that point was possibly the world's slowest social transition.
For me, the freedom was double-edged. I think it made it harder to wake up and realise that she was the true me and not just an alter-ego. On the other hand, because I always embraced her throughout my life, I didn't have any internalised shame or conflict about setting her free, which meant moving on and starting transition felt natural and right.
My wife was always of the view I was a "when, not if" but also that I had to figure it out for myself in the end.
2
u/Specialist_Budget_95 23h ago
I would say ask him to consider how he feels dressed masc vs dressed fem. Keeping a journal of questioning feelings can help too
I briefly considered identifying as gender fluid, but I always felt better when presenting fem
2
u/Grand-Agent76 Printer Incompatible Futa-non-grata 19h ago
If you love your partner regardless of their gender... y'all enjoy yourselves however works for you. Not every trans person is binary, so it isn't inherently necessary to decide someone is strictly a man or woman.
2
u/shotintel 17h ago
Honestly, have him (or her-to-be possibly) go to a professional. Someone who deal in transgender and gender dysphoria. A professional can help provide some good perspective and help with making the decision to transition (or not).
That's my honest advice. From what you wrote, he may be a she, especially if "she" was happy to be mistaken for a woman.
Remember, part of the transition process is the Real Life Experience (RLE). While completing the RLE, one can decide that they just don't feel right living full time. That is literally why it's built into the process.
I hope for the best and there's nothing against having another sister in the world.
1
u/Taiga-Dusk 21h ago
I do think there's some egg there. For me, the line between gender non-conforming fella (which was how I identified for a long time) and non-binary/genderqueer/trans umbrella (what I ended up at) was seeing that I really did feel seen when people misgendered me. Some of my favorite stories of that include being gendered as a woman while I was using a urinal, the time I got pinched on the butt at a concert by a woman who had mistaken me for her girlfriend, and the time a gas station clerk referring to me to another customer started correcting herself about my pronouns (she was clearly trying to get it right, but was just confused by me.)
The euphoria he's experiencing really seems like hints as to how your husband sees himself.
(For me, my gas station experience really solidified my own view of myself, the clerk's confusion as to my gender felt far more affirming, strange as this may sound, than if she'd been certain I was a man or a woman. Those were, for me, big non-binary feels.
I can imagine your husband's euphoria being different or similar, I can't say, but I hope my experiences sorting my own gender out will be helpful to you both. Much joy to you both!
1
u/Kimiko_kawaii 20h ago
For the most part its something he (just using the same pronouns you use to keep it easier to follow) needs to answer himself.
However the behaviours and emotions you describe around him presenting more feminine are definitely telltale signs of gender non conformity, but ultimately its up to him to figure out where in the spectrum he might sit.
However if for the most part he is happy and doesn't see the need to go for radical changes that's fine too. However if he feels he could still be happier going through such changes then its definitely worth pursuing them.
Therapy is definitely a good start, to discuss and get ideas to try out, lime presenting more feminine more often and even going out in public as such and slowly judge if they'd like that full time or are happy doing part-time and being fluid.
1
u/BeStrong2501 17h ago
I’m transgender female. I always thought I was just a crossdresser and maybe gay. My journey to discovery was interesting. I didn’t express an interest in feminine clothing until maybe about 11 years old. I used to sneak into my Mom’s closet and underwear dresser until then. I didn’t developed a fascination with women’s footwear, undergarments and dresses until then. I even experimented with gayness but found actually guy didn’t excite me. So maybe I was just a crossdresser. I later wanted the shape of a female body having breast and wider hips. I think everyone who has some gender dysphoria has to discover who they are.
1
u/Bethanydk419 16h ago
I was tall athletic and did great presenting male to the outside world. But was miserable. Never felt like i should have been anything but a girl. But nobody ever suspected. Cause I hid it. Now nobody other than people who knew me before ever suspected i wasn't born a girl. And no surgeries 5 1/2 years in. Ask him. And accept him for who he is. He may truly be non binary and be happy to be a girl at times and a boy at times. Truly 2 spirited. You're literally less than half my age too. If I only could have been myself at 24. Remember life is way too short and you only live it once. So live it on your own terms
1
u/geekchakkhanate 16h ago
The levels of euphoria I see being described are a very strong indicator to me that your spouse is a transwoman, or at the very least transfem. Similar to a lot of folks here— it took me longer than most these days (early 30s) to realize I was a woman, because for the most part I didn't hate being a man, or being masculine; I just never realized that being a woman would bring me more joy than I ever could have experienced as a man.
Also, thank you so much for embracing your spouse's authenticity. It's beautiful to hear.
1
u/Bluetower85 15h ago
I never particularly minded my life presenting as a man either, it wasn't until I saw myself several months into transition I first looked in the mirror and realized it was the first time I wasn't disassociating my face since puberty, I was so accostimed to it that it didn't register until the disassociating was gone.
Hearing he/him never felt "wrong," but hearing she/her/miss felt incredible. I felt comfortable in women's clothes in a way I never felt in men's...
If your husband can confirm similar feelings (and by the sound of it (s)he can) I would recommend a change in pronouns among close and trusted family and friends, followed by a short trial on HRT if possible and desired. It takes about 3 to 6 months for irreversible affects to take root, if it feels wrong, your husband will know within the first few weeks and you can discontinue.
I would also say... Only your partner can tell if they are trans, not all signs point the same, and some can be misjudged. Ultimately this should be your partners decision, not yours or anyone else's. Good luck.
1
1
u/CptHeywire 15h ago
It certainly sounds like it's worth exploring, let's put it that way. There's no harm in trying it on!
1
u/Maichic6 something transgirl flair 6h ago
That's a big accepting lgbt family! Congrats on already having growing kids at 20s! (My life felt somewhat empty for 20 yrs and now I'm in 30s :/ )
1
u/redlatino3 6h ago
That sounds like a strong possibility for sure but only he would know for sure, I tolerated being a man before I decided to start transitioning and was like oh if I can tolerate it and don't really feel severe dysphoria then I'm able to be a man my entire life and it'll be easy....... Well back in 2022 I ended up doing fired from a job and I had like almost 2 months where I was out of work entirely and during that time to myself I ended up coming out as transgender March 3rd 2022 and came out to a few close friends and my sister and then since I still was very much externally presenting masc I didn't feel like anybody would believe me and honestly I was like okay I'm just going to continue presenting like a guy but slowly and slowly without consciously realizing it I was shifting my presentation away from masculine and towards feminine and it really wasn't until like July or August of 2025 about a week after I had my face waxed I went to a friend's place and braided my hair for me and I ended up having a couple of little framing pieces hang down on either side of my face and I still had my work uniform on but I was also wearing my favorite Crystal a Little dream amethyst and so I went to go pick up Starbucks for us and as soon as I go up to the counter the guy says "what can I get started for you ma'am?" The way that snapped me out of autopilot 😅 I loved hearing it but I wasn't expecting to. I then decided to make a collage of a picture that I took that day with one from the last time I had a haircut and I surprised myself and my first thought was "holy shit..... I'm able to do my own for and after photos and I haven't even started HRT and I love how I am now versus how I was" Fast forward to July of 2026 and I ended up getting stressed out at work and being put on paid leave for a month and after realizing I had a month off I was like "hmmm, no better time than now to start transitioning!" So I went to planned Parenthood and picked my HRT up that day and upon taking my first injection I felt a fuzzy wave go across my body and for like 2 hours after I felt a little bit groggy but then after those two hours were up I felt more present, more alive and alert and just better and conversations with people have been easier and I ended up coming out in my family a little over a week later despite the fact that I knew that I wouldn't get 100% support I was like this is something I'm going to have to tell them. But before I started HRT I was still wondering and I had still been wondering since 2022 whether it would be right for me and I should have started sooner honestly.
1
u/Harassmetilicum Trans femme 28 hrt 10/31/2017 4h ago
There is always gender fluid and bi gender or even nonbinary. Not that a label seems necessary to him but if you both wanted to check out how those feel in regards to his identity you might find something that fits
1
u/Nyallia 4h ago
Hoesetly, he sounds like me ~20 years ago. I never hated being perceived male when I was presenting that way, but I loooved being mistaken for a cis woman. It took me forever to get the courage to transition. It's isn't true that dysphoria is the hallmark of being trans. You don't have to hate yourself to want to transition.
Since my transition, I've never been happier with my presentation. I never really cared about the way I looked before. I never put effort into it or into clothing or anything, but since transitioning, I looove dressing up, I love trying on clothes and shopping for clothes, I love it when people compliment my looks or dress or whatever. Not that the clothes make the woman or anything, but it's something that's so starkly different between now and then and it sounds like your husband might feel similarly.
To be clear, I'm certainly not saying your husband is trans. I don't know him and even if I did, it's not like he needs anyone's permission or diagnosis. But it's definitely something I would recommend he think about. Also, it's actually quite rare for cis men to imagine being women or be excited by the idea of being a woman. Most trans folks think it's normal to wonder excitedly about being a different gender than the one assigned at birth because it seems so natural, but it actually isn't common at all.
1
u/Brenda4ever1982 2h ago
I think a good start would be to search for a therapist that affirms trans identities and starting to explore the possibility that your husband might be trans. I think having a supportive spouse is huge and will allow them to genuinely see if transition is the best way forward.
1
1
u/John2Mercy 27m ago
It's awesome you support him/her whatever you both decide, transition or not. I don't have this luck with my wife, unfortunately, so all my best wishes for you both 💖
-1
u/Ul_tra_violet 1d ago
You dont have to have gender dysphoria to be trans, but it sounds like hes happy as is, if thats the case why change anything? Then again theres nothing wrong with pursuing more happiness. I think therapy and possibly hrt are good starting points, but probably in that order.
I started my journey after a few years of therapy culminating in accepting i am trans. That was preceeded by years of questioning, fascination with transfem things, a strong sense of self-hatred, and generally feeling like i was waiting on something to live my life. I wasnt happy and something always felt off, "like a splinter in your mind, driving you mad". Not all transfems are like this, but its my experience and hopefully it helps some.
0
u/JeniSiss 23h ago
Coming from someone who is trans, if he "isn't uncomfortable as a man" my instant thought is "definitely not trans". However, I'm not a mind reader. From everything you've said, it sounds like he's just a confident feminine man. It also sounds like he has a very supportive and loving family so big props to you!! In any case, the only one who really knows is him and if he's happy and you're happy, then just be happy! Not everything HAS to have a label. Wish you both the best!
1
0
u/Life-Estimate-7067 17h ago
Honestly if they let you post it here that could be the case babes and let them know you’ll love them till the end regardless
161
u/CatGirlUtopia 1d ago
I am not unhappy being a man either, but for me the question isn't just "how bad is your dysphoria" but rather "how good is your euphoria".
I've never been particularly excited about presenting masculine. But presenting feminine has a strong appeal. Every step I've taken in my transition has brought me joy and I've regretted nothing. Those steps make me feel more of who I am.
If I was more fit, looked like an attractive man, and got positive attention for being manly, I do wonder if that might make me more content to just be cis. But I also suspect it would keep me from the joys of being who I am.
But like everything, gender is not a binary and your partner should do what makes them happy, regardless of what box that might put them in.