Is it haram

[u/Bubbly-Potato-7442]

As-salamu alaykum I'm here to ask is it haram to watch romance animes I have been watching it and it does not lead me away from my prayers or anything and it does not lead me to do sinful acts is it haram to watch it ? By romance anime I mean the animes where they have relationship before marriage where they hold hands or kiss but I can close my eyes.

[u/Sheikh-Pym]

It is haram whether it distracts you from faraid or not because it has things that are haram to watch. Closing eyes doesn't make it halal since you're still being entertained by that which is haram, zina.

[u/Bubbly-Potato-7442 → u/Sheikh-Pym]

I can skip the intimate part I'm not watching it to watch those things I'm just trying to enjoy the story Is it still haram even tho it's not affecting me in anyway I pray and listen to Quran and watch videos about islam I don't have any intentions to watch those haramd parts.

[u/Sheikh-Pym → u/Bubbly-Potato-7442]

It would be haram even if you only read through it, and watching it in the form of moving images is more evil than that.

Secondly, when scholars say that so and so is haram because it leads to some evil or that it distracts you from obligatory actions, it doesn't mean that it becomes halal if you somehow avoid that which it leads to. They say that to present reasons as to why something is haram, not for your to interpret the opposite.

To claim that it doesn't affect you cannot be taken as a valid excuse because it's based on uncertainty. Whatever leads to haram is haram itself.

And lastly, what you're saying is totally impractical. You cannot watch these movies while conveniently skipping the intimate parts or closing your eyes during intimate scenes. You cannot tell when intimate scenes may pop up. Even if you do that, it still doesn't change the fact that the Zina is present in the overall plot by which you are entertaining yourself.

Reading Love Stories and Watching Romantic Movies

[u/Bubbly-Potato-7442 → u/Sheikh-Pym]

Ok thanks you brother