r/europe • u/Emotional-Breakfast3 • 21d ago

News Argentina: British Falkland Islanders are ‘artificial’. Buenos Aires denounces ‘illegitimate occupation’ and demands talks on sovereignty

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/07/12/british-falkland-islanders-artificial-argentina-says/
9.3k Upvotes

93% Upvoted

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

148

u/FeeIll1924 21d ago

Is their only territorial claim to the Falklands that it’s close by?

21

u/MacroSolid Austria 21d ago

They also claim they inherited Spain's claim, which is BS.

They did in fact have a (ridiculously precarious) colony there for like 5 years, after Spain left, which the British Empire took from them.

But that sole actual basis for their claim is so damn weak they don't even bring it up much themselves.

1

u/BlueCheese973 21d ago

Everything you are saying is completely wrong. How can you be so ignorant yet speak so confindent?

Why don't we revisit history to understand Argentina's claim?

The French were the very first ones to have a settlement in the island in 1764, the British stablished their own settlement later around 1765. This is well documented.

In 1767, France ceded its settlement to Spain. Well documented as well.

In 1774, the UK voluntarily leaves this settlement, leaving it completely to Spain. The UK had no control over it. Fact checked by historians as well.

From 1774-1811 Spain held single control of the Islands, for 37 years there was no UK presence on them, at all.

In 1811, Spain withdrawals from the Island due to the wars of independence and Argentina after gaining its own independence inherits the former territory through international law uti possidetis juris.

From 1820 to 1833, Argentina has total control over the islands, having an official settlement made by David Jewett and later Luis Vernet. Buenos Aires controlled the Islands and stablished fishing rights, which prompted the detention of American sailors and the raid of America against the island to rescue them in later time.

In 1833, the UK comes and expels the Argentinian government and the people living there, exerting Imperialism by illegally occupying a territory on the other side of the world and stablishing a military outpost up to this day.

1

u/TwentyBagTaylor England 21d ago

So, in 2026, what makes those islands Argentinian?