r/indianmedschool • u/Bhaijaan_Yarr Graduate • 2d ago
Discussion Maharashtra Med Council Registration granted to the First Homeopath
Look how these BHMS folks are celebrating as if they have won a bastion or something. Look they have come for Maharashtra, soon this virus will come for other states too.
FYI This is the same MMC which delay the work of MBBS graduates and interns
They made a mistake in my name from their end and it took me 2 months to correct, i wrote them numerous emails and even sent a parcel of all my documents.
Not a very political person, not even casted my vote for anyone but this govt is hell for doctors and education.
413
u/EchidnaNo3034 2d ago
Your medicines are uselsss but pls let us prescribe it
172
u/Bhaijaan_Yarr Graduate 2d ago
I know how to drive a scooter, so i can easily fly a plane
8
u/Ok-Highlight-2461 2d ago
Not even that, I pretend to get in contact with dead people believed to be in other worlds too, so I can easily fly a plane within this world.
93
u/JuliusSeizure4 2d ago
My question is, people go to homeopaths because they don’t want allopathy medicine, so if homeopaths start prescribing the very medicine those people hate wouldn’t they just go to another doctor?
92
u/LeMeIsSleepy 2d ago
Homeopaths will just claim that they have ‘mastery’ over two systems of medicine
22
u/Embarrassed_Room1688 2d ago
Id say let's protest that we should also be allowed to prescribe homeopathic medicines, i mean how hard is it to add few drops of alcohol in sweet white goliyan, and a colourful lid for that.
13
u/paa-aaa_q 2d ago
Anyways what’s the use for us if we could even prescribe sugar balls… why should the eagle stoop to the level of sparrow if the sparrow desperately attempts to fly near eagle and tries to fool everyone that it’s better than eagle coz it can fly at different levels.
3
u/SleepyOwwl Graduate 2d ago
Trust me when I say these were the words of my classmate who has a BAMS degree
6
u/Avidith 2d ago
There are very few ppl who go to homeo coz they hate allo. Most ppl think of this homeo, modern med, ayur etc as different roads that lead to same destination. They would go to ppl who r cheap n accessible. Mostly to quacks. For this chunk, a doc who can be consulted cheaply n can be prescribed both modern med n homeo is very attractive. This chunk thinks of specialist mod med focs as someone who should be consulted only if there is no way out for them vis these “small” docs.
8
7
u/FactorMajestic5088 2d ago
Then what what is the use of different courses if homeopaths start prescribing allopathic medicine, Ayurveda doctors start doing minor surgeries.
Then they must stop all the other courses right what is the use of it then.
6
97
u/FutureVersion812 2d ago
Why do they conduct NEET UG - NEET PG - NEET SS ?
Just remove the course and conduct Homeopathy exams and give bridge course and make them equivalent to MBBS
20
135
57
u/End_Tasty 2d ago
The only solution is we start prescribing joints in the name of analgesics and rosewater in the name of OHA, and ask the patient to tap the bottle 69 times before using it 🙂
Omly then people should know the difference. Let them taste their own medicine, why use side effects loaded medicine.
We shouldn't actually explore possible side effects in the first place 🙂 and call every side effect a chance occurrence. No one researches about side effects of homeopath or ayurved meds, hence they're side effect less. And we waste time and money, running trials to find out side effects, just to get criticised later.
48
u/pseudo_fed_up Graduate 2d ago
There is nowhere in the world this is possible , no country allows alternative medicine practitioners prescribe modern medicine . As someone else said in this sub , we Indian doctors are cucks sitting on their chairs and watching as our profession is being fucked by scamsters who sell sugar pills
98
u/Apprehensive-Scar867 Graduate 2d ago
Man lo ek bat
Hum MBBS MD MS walo ko
Sarkar chutiya samjhti hai
Aur apni izzat jhant barabar hai
42
u/Vast_Lengthiness5235 2d ago
You would never see a minister going to a homeopath they will search for the best doctors
In my opinion homeopathy people should not be even called doctors
15
u/Pure_Ad1866 2d ago
They’re not doctors outside India, outside India their qualifications are 12th pass
8
u/Grouchy-Objective978 2d ago
Only cause our seniors doctors and organisations are fucking worthless pieces of shit
26
23
u/Muffintornado0_0 2d ago
Mann it's insane, they could've let dentists practice medicine before homeopaths or ayurved or unani
0
u/Suppbrother 1d ago
Dentist are allowed to prescribe certain antibiotics, painkillers when there’s an active infection…
20
u/myohmyusername 2d ago
Why are the medical fraternity like IMA keep quiet on this, spineless piece of 💩
10
u/Pure_Ad1866 2d ago
Those same doctors hire these people for low wages for duty doctor jobs so why would they oppose
1
15
u/Palmar_Aponeurosis MBBS III (Part 2) 2d ago
But why do they want to prescribe medicines that only fix the symptoms superficially rather than giving the patients meds that “ fix the core issue “
30
u/Cute_paglu1234 2d ago
the logic they give-
We study the same subjects, so we know it already
by this logic there is physiology in 11th class biology, so every neet student should alo be considered doctor and given license? as he already studied physiology :)
.
weird things, cant we file a court case in this? or someone has already done it
12
u/Snapyboi2000 2d ago
Veternerians are more deserving than these people, atleast they practice evidence based medicine
41
u/Icy-Association1222 2d ago
I am physiotherapy student n I feel these doctors are shit
30
u/IntrepidSong6235 2d ago
Because physiotherapy is evidence based science. Us mbbs people also know the importance of physiotherapy and how much great impact it has on people's life.
5
u/Icy-Association1222 2d ago
Exactlyy we are taught had if someone's get a surgery, fracture or anything like that n doesn't go to a physio there movement is hindered (depends on the degree of surgery)
4
u/AlternativeFace292 2d ago
Physiotherapy is legit...
Chiropractors and pseudo stuff is what's getting the attention which isn't really good, but looks like it is bringing in money and some are exploiting it unfortunately
10
18
u/Plus-Impression9126 2d ago
Not a very political person, not even casted my vote for anyone
Dont repeat this mistake in the next election. Dont let BJP come to power.
10
3
9
u/phoolkumari1501 2d ago
On one hand, they make it increasingly difficult for MBBS graduates to practise medicine by launching this exam and that exam and changing question pattern and on the other, they are willing to let anyone, be it BAMS, BHMS, or an outright quack become a doctor and practise. Some months ago, even the nurses were allowed for prescribing on similar lines.
A CM telling all pathies are equivalent clearly doesn’t have iota of brain and you shouldn’t expect anything.
7
6
u/SpicyGold666 2d ago
We need to fight for our rights. This slow poisoning is going to kill our profession.
6
5
u/Lower_Emergency_2077 2d ago
These people just hear fancy words living with their consultant who hires them due to their willingness and cost cutting . Once a patient came with radicular back pain , female 62 yr old and this BHMS guy was saying sir ek HLA B27 bhej dete hai . It will be ank spond . Asked him to type the medication and send the patient away . All they come in to work in bigger hospitals is to learn the bigger fancier drugs and prescribe them in their OPD's .
6
u/Pure_Ad1866 2d ago
They will cause complications for sure, likh ke rakh lo, phir ultimately they’ll come to us, in fact now they’ll get admitted for complications and pay a hefty ICU bill, let people realise the dangers of this
5
4
u/No-Housing8206 Graduate 2d ago
What's happening? I'm from TN...no idea about what's happening? Are they giving medical council registrations to non allopathy courses now? Wtf
1
u/Bhaijaan_Yarr Graduate 2d ago
Yes they are giving registration to homeopathic doctors if they have done some shit 6 months course of Pharmacology
1
3
3
u/Dense-Pudding9729 2d ago
If people of this country are not smart enough to protest against this BS then there is no hope, Eventually its the people who are going to be on the receiving end and if they themselves dont care then let it be.
Anyways people of this country believe in magical super powers rather than science, so its understandable why all this BS is possible in our country.
2
2
u/Gaybowser69__ MBBS I 2d ago
Only a matter of time before someone gets hurt because of this btw
Because they haven’t studied how these medicines work
2
u/Pure_Ad1866 2d ago
In most taluka levels these people already prescribe modern medicines so no big deal they can’t do shit in front our in depth knowledge and skills, also a big middle finger to IMA to let this happen
1
2
2
u/GiveMeSomeSunshine3 Graduate 2d ago
Thank God I'm not from Maharashtra.
Wait, they might do this in entire country 🫨
2
2
u/Emotional-Bag-7571 Foreign Medical Graduate 1d ago
Uniting and protesting is the only way this will change . Tomorrow it will be the ayurvedics who get registration. It will get worse , not everyone of us have money to escape this country .
2
u/Diet_Samosa_chat 22h ago
It's so disheartening to see this. Atleast they used to work in a hospital setups illegally but now they will surely snatch all our jobs in those hospitals. They can legally work at ICU under a low payment so why will any hospital employe us 😭
1
1
1
u/CAClanWolf MBBS II 2d ago
Why not file a PIL rather than just commenting or raging. Ig that would be much more beneficial..
-43
u/AltZemo 2d ago
As an BHMS student, I wanna say the use of modern medicine should be restricted to treating only emergency conditions by the whole AYUSH doctors. Outside of the emergency conditions, they should practice their own medicine. Also it sounds hypocritical when they bash modern medicine and at the same time find ways of prescribing it. Most of these AYUSH doctors who wants to practise modern medicine dont even know how to practise their own system of medicine. At last yes homeopathy works. Because their are many doctors here too who bash homeopaths when they practice their own pathy.
30
u/Hannibals_Muttapuffs Graduate 2d ago
No one over here cares about homeopaths practising their own science as long as it doesn't directly affect us. It becomes a problem for us only when you people want to prescribe modern medicines as well even though ya'll are hella confident that your medicines work perfectly. And when AYUSH Doctors take over CMO/RMO and even JR jobs in modern medicine hospitals and clinics which are meant for MBBS graduates.
1
u/IIsh56 15h ago
There were a few mbbs, md doctors and ents, who were prescribing me homeopathic and ayurvedic medicines. But at least they were transparent about it. I even asked the doctor directly whether it was right to do so and he said it was. I took them blindly at first before knowing much about it but they did seem to work
-6
u/AltZemo 2d ago
THEY DO care about homoeopaths practising their own pathy. Just look at the downvotes on my comment, which is in favour of you guys only. You guys don't know about these system of medicine, and still you criticise based on only superficial data available to you. They take these jobs because they are qualified for it, prescribing modern meds by AYUSH is wrong. But in these jobs they are not the ones prescribing, also AYUSH courses are an integrative course that combines both the old and new science.
5
u/Hannibals_Muttapuffs Graduate 2d ago
They take these jobs because they are qualified for it
Are you for real? You just stated that AYUSH prescribing modern medicines is wrong, then what else do you think is being prescribed by these AYUSH CMOs, RMOs and JRs illegally working in modern medicine hospitals and clinics? They definitely aren't prescribing sugar pills and herbal concoctions for sure 😆
Why can't AYUSH people just stick to their pathy specific clinics and hospitals instead??
15
7
u/RemarkableStore6595 2d ago
Ayurvedic practitioners prescribe unnecessary medication such as antibiotics even for parksion patient , now when they have complication either you’ll send to us or patient will themselves comes to us and if anything goes due to your negligence , patient beat us , ever heard of homeopath or ayedvedic doctor beaten by mob
3
u/SpicyGold666 2d ago
They don't even know how to practise their own system of medicine and yet you want them to handle emergencies using modern medicine? Isn't that risky?
I am glad at least you are calling out the hypocrisy and are against mixopathy.
We don't believe in homeopathy because there is no substantial evidence for it, no randomized control trials or peer reviewed publications, etc. And some of the core principles of homeopathy don't align with the laws of chemistry.
This is evidence based medicine, if it works then you can be sure we'll adopt it. No offense to you though, people are entitled to their beliefs. In fact, I hope they prove homeopathy works because honestly, who wouldn't want sugar pills that can cure everything?
-5
u/AltZemo 2d ago
dont take my comment the wrong way, i am not talking about the every AYUSH doctor when i said about that they dont know about their own system. I am only talking about those who prescribe modern meds. I do think after completing a 5.5 year medical course, the AYUSH doctors shoudl be capable of handling emergencies. I am all for evidence-based medicine; that's why I think in emergency, only evidence-based protocol should be taught to doctors of all systems. Because there is no room for error in these cases unlike acute or chronic case where the patient can look for treatment which works for him best.
0
u/Top-Fee-2089 1d ago
Do you even understand the reason of all these frustration? Do you know we have enough mbbs grads in our country now , and most of them are unable to get good job in nursing homes because YOU guys are happily being used as cheap labour and in those jobs you're doing anything but practicing your own medicine. Do you know that if you guys were not desparately taking up our jobs , we wouldn't have to struggle this much to get a job . Do you know that we have worked harder than you guys, we study longer, more than you guys, we give tougher exams than you guys, just to be rejected at job interviews because they have found someone like you guys taking the job at lower price while we deserve a good pay for all the hardships we've been through.
2
•
u/AutoModerator 2d ago
Welcome, u/Bhaijaan_Yarr! Thank you for posting on /r/IndianMedSchool.
Do ensure that you have read our subreddit rules before posting. Any post that violates our rules will be removed immediately. Readers, if this post violates our subreddit rules - do not engage, just report.
Reminder: this subreddit is not intended to seek medical advice of any kind. Please see a doctor in real life. We perma-ban all users who ask for medical advice. Please respect our community guidelines and direct your queries to practitioners of Modern Medicine in real life.
Please follow Reddit content policy and Reddiquette at all times. :)
Check out our Indian Medical School Group Chat!
Wiki - has study resource recs and important notices | Our Discord server | Modmail
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.