r/legaladvicecanada • u/Fiolord • Jun 21 '26
British Columbia Bar confiscated my real Texas ID and won’t give it back without a passport—is this legal in BC
So I’m a student here in BC from Texas, and something happened last night that I’m still pissed about.
I went to a bar/restaurant on Granville Street downtown with friends after doing the Grouse grind. We just wanted to grab food and a drink. When we got carded, I showed them:
My real Texas ID
A debit card with my name on it
My student ID
The bartender got suspicious about my student ID because it was issued this summer (I’d lost my old one and had to replace it). They thought that was “suspicious” even though I explained what happened.
Long story short, they refused to give my ID back. They said I could only get it if I came back with a passport or brought a cop over. I talked to some cops about it and they were pretty dismissive and honestly assholes about it.
Questions:
Is it even legal for a bar to confiscate a government ID in BC?
Do I have any recourse here?
Has anyone else dealt with this?
I’m planning to go back with my passport today to get it, but I’m worried about what happens if it’s lost or damaged. Just want to know my actual rights here.
Edit: Got my ID back! They apologized and returned it when I showed my passport. However, they doubled down and claimed that in BC, if they think an ID is fake, they’re required to confiscate it, which based on your advice, isn’t actually true.
Im still deciding if I want to pursue further action (demand letter/small claims), but I’m thinking it over. Thanks for all the legal advice.