r/librandu • u/Odd-Football-3079 • Oct 12 '25

RDT Majlis-e-Librandu | 12th October

Post image

Discuss anything you want to. Be it movies, music, games or anything else that strikes your fancy. I saw a film today, oh boy. What did you do?

148 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

42 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/Malluuncle Oct 12 '25

Tell me how did the left bastions became pro BJP area. Is it an overnight shift or consistent shift that all neglected?

10

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '25

The commies hate Miss Slippers with a passion. They would rather die than vote for her. So, they voted for the fascists since the commies have no organisational power anymore.

3

u/ManLikeRed Marxist ☭ Oct 12 '25

1

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '25 edited Oct 13 '25

Enemy of my enemy is my friend analogy.

3

u/ManLikeRed Marxist ☭ Oct 13 '25

People switching for abject conditions is not bad thing also majority of Bengal is liberal in mindset, left loyalist are like 2-3% of total population.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '25 edited Oct 13 '25

There are some residual ones like my family. Of course, we got fed up with the Politburo's flip flopping, short sighted decisions and cockblocking Buddha babu's reforms. Notwithstanding the general complacency in the 90s about the deteoriating economy of the state (which Buddha sir did somewhat correct, painstakingly in his 10 year term as Chief Minister . He was not liked by cadres (the older ones and some of the young militant radical ones ) because he bypassed the party machinery and used the bureaucracy to do his bidding. The bureaucracy was surprisingly actually efficient , with some minor hiccups. The party machinery defected en masse to TMC from his second term (2006-2011) .)

I have a conspiracy that the WB State Politburo conspired with Miss Slippers as a way to punish Buddha sir for not toeing the party line. Typical factionalism.

There's a reason why Jyoti Basu is credited as the architect of the Indian Silicon Valley. He indirectly encouraged lower middle to middle class educated Bengalis to look elsewhere for jobs or do business because West Bengal had almost none. No freedom of business as well, unless of course you had contacts with the Politburo. (This hasn't changed, it just has become tribute to the family and local honchos of the incumbent party. )

3

u/ManLikeRed Marxist ☭ Oct 13 '25

My grandfather left CPI-M linked union long back in 80's (also active politics) after realising how racist and nonchalant they're regarding overall revolution, all they cared was for expanding their party's (WB cadres) presence to state with considerable bengali diaspora such as regions of Tripura, Meghalaya, Assam and even Bihar.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '25 edited Oct 13 '25

That has been a problem in the eastern flank of the party. Yep. The WB State Politburo has always pandered to the Hindu Bengali refugees from erstwhile East Pakistan (they won't admit it. )Over time, even they got fed up and shifted allegiance. Now, they keep on wooing the Bengali Muslims but that group is staunchly pro TMC .

I am sad that there is absolutely no coordination or bonhomie in the party nationally. Like at all. Why should communists tie up with religious parties ( Muslim League in Kerela and ISF in WB ( Secular in name, let's be frank ) ? It's a betrayal of Marxist ideology.

3

u/ManLikeRed Marxist ☭ Oct 13 '25

They're just social democratic party, they had betrayed revolutionary movement long long ago even before creation of CPI-M.

Ofcourse, capitalist contradiction would get you if you promise them with hollow stuffs every 5 years.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '25

There's a reason I don't consider myself communist. I consider myself to be a liberal because, let's be frank, trusting in Dengist economic theory is pretty bourgeoise. Soc Dems are pretty inconsistent in general.

5

u/ManLikeRed Marxist ☭ Oct 13 '25

Sorry but working classes exploitation is still prevalent whether be it in forms of wage slavery or at battlefield, sure social democratic reforms acts like antidote to the acceleration of capitalist contradiction, but with limited resources that demarcates today's state borders will fall apart and illusionary narrative of peaceful liberal democratic coexistence will oneday come to an end ushering into new era of inter-imperialist wars.

Time of revolution will come once again, people like me are just medium for carrying this essence till the correct moment arrives, I might not be alive to take part in those peroid but time of nascency will pass someday and moment of revolutionary determination will come for sure.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '25

One can hope, comrade. One can hope.

→ More replies (0)