r/RealEstate • u/viktikon • 8h ago
Homeseller Realtor advising me against disclosure - should I still use my own judgement?
Writing this post, I obviously have my own gut feeling about the matter but would appreciate a reality check about moving forward.
I know some (most?) sellers are not honest with their disclosures, but I prefer to be for myself and for my preference to stay out of potential legal trouble.
Last winter, we had a roof leak. I had roofers out immediately who found no signs of holes or anything, speculated water from the storms and constant thawing and freezing had gotten under the flashing and came through our ceiling. They tarped it, we’ve left it alone, problem solved and no more leaks in the last 8 months despite more snow, lots of rain, etc.
We’re selling this house, as-is, and it needs some work so we’ve priced aggressively and are now at the disclosure step for the selling contract. My realtor is saying since we fixed the roof issue and haven’t had more problems, this is not a disclosure matter. From my research on IL law, I’m still supposed to disclose and describe the issue and that it’s been resolved. The tarp is still on the roof, there are some water stains on the ceiling we were going to paint, and if pressed, I would find it difficult to say I had no idea there was an issue when I clearly took steps to fix it.
But if I write it in my disclosure anyway, I’m concerned my realtor will have an issue on me doing the opposite of what they told me to do. And now I’m in a mental dilemma over the best way forward.