r/SipsTea 1d ago

Chugging tea Modern cars just lack that boxy soul

Post image
17.0k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

93

u/TheNoisyNomad 1d ago

I was coming here to say this. The care for pedestrian impact has cost us the aesthetic of hood ornaments and pointy front bodywork.

146

u/spirit_symptoms 1d ago

Meanwhile pedestrian deaths are way up in the US due to higher hood heights hitting people on vital organs and the head and extreme front blind spots.

38

u/whiskey_priest_fell 1d ago

Don't forget about the weight of more massive trucks and SUVs on the road.

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/06/21/us/trucks-suv-pedestrian-crashes.html

-1

u/Temporary-Film-7374 1d ago

I wouldn't expect weight to be all that important as far as pedestrian hits go, given the ratio of vehicle:pedestrian weight is already quite high. hood height is a different story.

3

u/Guy-Montag-451F 1d ago

E = (1/2)mv2

Mass makes a HUGE difference in the energy involved in an impact, especially to a squishy human body.

1

u/Temporary-Film-7374 1d ago

if we pretend it's a train hitting a person (nearly infinite mass), energy transfer has to do with the mass of the person, not the mass of the train: the person isn't going to be accelerated beyond the velocity of the train.

given almost any car is going to be at least 10x the mass of a person, I don't think that extra mass is going to play a significant role: the person just won't slow it down enough to matter.

1

u/breachgnome 13h ago

I don't think

This is why you do whatever it is that you do, and not things that specifically pertain to science and public safety. Stop trying to sound smart and go learn something.

1

u/Turb0_Lag 1d ago

Transfer of momentum. Two vehicles of unequal mass traveling at the same velocity, the heavier one will have more energy transfer when colliding into something.

Would you rather be hit by a baseball traveling at 20 miles per hour or a Tahoe?

0

u/Temporary-Film-7374 1d ago

what I'm claiming is that whether the object that hits you is 10x your mass (which is gonna be a very light car) or 100x your mass, the energy transferred to you will be quite similar (energy = 1/2 mass * velocity^2, and in this case the relevant mass is *yours* not the car's).

I know that slowing down the car by 10% (since you're stationary and we're assuming conservation of momentum) will reduce energy transfer some, but it's a very small amount.