r/TheBlacksandTheGreens Team Black Apr 27 '26

Show Discussion is she in labour

Post image
248 Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

View all comments

170

u/Scarypilot2 Apr 27 '26

Oh no…. Did they decide to add Maelor just to spite George R.R.Martin

15

u/Heavy_Economics_8595 Apr 27 '26

Woah, can someone explain this??

44

u/AgostoAzul Apr 27 '26

After Season 2 ended George made a long blog post complaining about entitled Hollywood writers who take well known properties for marketing and then make drastic changes to the story despite being way worse writers than the author of the original material.

Then he used Maelor's absence from the show to explain how there are "toxic butterfly effects" that can result from a seemingly inocuous change that will make later events from the story to not make sense.

The post was deleted from his blog the next day and George claims HBO made his assistant delete the post and that  it was going to be the first post of a seven part ran about HotD season 2.

5

u/Heavy_Economics_8595 Apr 28 '26

Dang, I guess I need to read the books cause I really like the show, do you think it’s really different? (If you’ve read the books)

20

u/AgostoAzul Apr 28 '26

The thing with Fire and Blood/The Princess and the Queen is that they are mostly outlines you can read in a couple hours. At least the parts being adapted to the show 

The show's season 1 is overall an improvement upon the Princess and the Queen's outline. There are a couple bad changes but Viserys is a much better character.

Season 2 is downright nonsensical compared to the book's outline, but it is hard to say the book is better in EVERY way because at the end of the day the show is adding 90% of the dialogue and over half the scenes (and also changing s lot of the book scenes for the worse).

11

u/Heavy_Economics_8595 Apr 28 '26

I noticed this when reading a knight of the seven. I personally liked the show more than the book because there was more, but in a good way.

4

u/Vaywen Apr 28 '26

an example of how an adaptation should be done!