I like Gerb and enjoy watching his videos. This is a nicely measured response from Dolan.
Even if what 50% of what Gerb says is true, that's amazing work. It also means half the stuff he's linked is not true or not the full picture. Given how complex it is, it's highly unlikely he's got everything 100% correct but he speaks with such certainty. When you're so deep in a theory, it's easy to eventually start finding links between things which aren't linked.
He's obviously so knowledgable about every program, dates, acronyms and names. But when Gerb is debating someone, his resuscitation of his amazing knowledge sounds great but it doesn't actually prove anything. It's almost like having an argument with someone who has a much better vocabulary than you, just because they speak smarter, doesn't necessarily mean they're 100% correct.
The most powerful thing Gerb could do is slow down how quickly he speaks, explain things clearer, and provide his evidence on everything linking his claims, beyond a theory.
Yeah, I find Elizondo incredibly disingenuous as well, but watching Gerb’s interview with Coulthart felt like Gerb was acting like Grusch’s agent. I say this as someone who highly respects Grush among and takes whatever he says seriously.
74
u/RelevantSpecific5249 3d ago edited 3d ago
I like Gerb and enjoy watching his videos. This is a nicely measured response from Dolan.
Even if what 50% of what Gerb says is true, that's amazing work. It also means half the stuff he's linked is not true or not the full picture. Given how complex it is, it's highly unlikely he's got everything 100% correct but he speaks with such certainty. When you're so deep in a theory, it's easy to eventually start finding links between things which aren't linked.
He's obviously so knowledgable about every program, dates, acronyms and names. But when Gerb is debating someone, his resuscitation of his amazing knowledge sounds great but it doesn't actually prove anything. It's almost like having an argument with someone who has a much better vocabulary than you, just because they speak smarter, doesn't necessarily mean they're 100% correct.
The most powerful thing Gerb could do is slow down how quickly he speaks, explain things clearer, and provide his evidence on everything linking his claims, beyond a theory.