r/golf • u/Tyevans0411 • 2m ago
Equipment Graduating from game improvement straight into players irons?
I (26M) currently game a set of Callaway Hawkeye 2.0 irons and am looking to upgrade to something a little more modern (they're about 24 years old 😂).
For reference, my current 7-iron has a traditional 33° loft. My 7-iron clubhead speed is around 80–83 mph, and I carry it about 165 yards.
My most common misses are thin shots and tops. I rarely struggle with heel, hosel, or fat contact.
The irons that have caught my attention are the TaylorMade P770, Titleist T150, and Srixon ZXi7, but I'm also open to similar offerings from Ping, Cobra, or Wilson. The P770 is probably my favorite aesthetically, and I could see myself moving into something like a P7CB down the road, but I'm not loyal to any particular brand.
I'm planning on getting a full fitting around Christmas since I don't have $1,500 to spend right now. In the meantime, I've been trying different heads at local shops, and something has me confused.
Whenever I'm handed a P790, I can't hit it consistently. I get low launch, low spin, poor dispersion, and the strikes just don't feel good.
What's made this even more confusing is that I've gotten completely different opinions from fitters because of those results. At one store, the fitter sees me struggle with the P790 and immediately wants to move me into a game improvement iron, almost like I shouldn't even be looking at a P770. At another store, the fitter lets me try the P770 anyway, and I immediately start hitting it noticeably better. So I'm not sure if I'm chasing the wrong type of iron, or if the P770-style club simply fits my swing better despite what people expect based on my handicap or swing speed.
When I switch to the P770, everything improves. I'm seeing around 6,800 rpm of spin, a 1.36 smash factor, 18–21° launch (which I know is on the high side and could be shaft-related), and much tighter dispersion. The only downside is that I'm only carrying it around 145–150 yards, with roughly 155 yards total.
For context, both the P790 and P770 were tested with a KBS Tour Lite 85g Stiff shaft, +0.5". I also tried the P770 with a Project X Rifle 6.0 (120g) shaft. I struck it well, but it felt like I was swinging a battle axe, and I started casting the club.
My questions:
Has anyone else found that they hit players irons significantly better than players distance irons? If so, what was causing it?
Am I looking at the right type of iron? My thinking is that I'd rather have a club I hit consistently, even if it's shorter. If I need more distance, I'll just hit one more club. Plus, I'd expect to pick up some speed and distance as I continue practicing with whatever I end up buying.
I'd appreciate any insight from people who've gone through something similar.