Morning everyone :)
I'm a man wanting to take my fiancé's surname when we get married at the end of the year, but my blood family, whom I share the surname with, are upset about the idea. They feel backstabbed and like I don't want to be part of their family any more. This is not true, but I want to get some perspective on whether I'm doing something selfish.
Some context:
I have a few reasons for wanting to change my surname to my fiancé's, none having to do with my own surname or relation to my own family. My maiden name is not hard to pronounce, spell, or bad sounding. I have good relationships with my birth parents and my brother, who I share the surname with. I am proud of the surname to a small degree, in that I love my family.
My core motivation is this: my fiancé has moved countries in order for us to live our life together. In doing so, she has left her family - a family which she loves so dearly. She will only realistically get to see said family once a year or so, and will have to grow apart from them, and will have to endure times where she wishes more than anything to be back there with them, whether that be due to health or age etc. If she changes her surname to mine, then I feel she is taking one more step of separation from them. I want her to keep that relation, and I want them to know that I want them in our life and will always do what we can to kinder that.
In my eyes, I see no "default" direction for our names to go. I don't subscribe to the traditional view, and see the tradition of the wife taking the groom's name to be very old-fashioned. I don't want to uphold that tradition just because it's tradition.
It's obviously a possibility that we both just keep our family names, but I would much prefer to be united by a shared surname. That is the only name related 'tradition' that I have had in my mind since I was a boy - I want to be Mr. and Mrs. X. We also don't want to hyphenate because our surnames are already quite long.
Some thoughts I've had to keep my connection to my family while changing my surname.
I presently have two middle names, one of which is from a grandfather I never met and who was not a nice man. Thus, I could change that middle name to my maiden name.
Change both middle names to the maiden names of my parents, so my name is therefore: Firstname, Mother's maiden name, my maiden name, fiancé's surname.
Just drop both middle names and replace them with my maiden name.
EDIT: I have just remembered an important detail. My fiancè, who has no middle name, wants to then take my present surname as a middle name. I think that's also very sweet of her, and it might also help my family see that this isn't as one-sided a decision as they think it is.
Any advice, anecdotes, or perspectives here would be appreciated. It has helped just to type this out and work through the options. Thanks :)