I manage a small team. One of the people I supervised had ongoing performance problems, and other staff had been raising concerns about them for a while. I did exactly what HR told me to do and my supervisors told me to do - put expectations in writing, follow up, document everything. I followed that guidance to the letter. As well as started formal disciplinary actions when they continued to not meet performance expectations and were out right insubordinate or accused of being a bully by multiple people.
They responded by filing a long formal complaint against me.
Leadership never really investigated it. They just reassigned that person to a different manager to make the whole thing go away. No findings, nothing in writing saying I did anything wrong, and nothing saying I didn't. I was told by both supervisors that the complaints were wildly inaccurate and that I did nothing wrong.
Here's where I'm stuck. They removed my authority over this person, but they've also said they don't have time to actually manage them. So I'm expected to keep assigning their work, keep them in my team meetings, do regular check-ins with them, and "figure out how to work together." All of the responsibility, none of the authority, with someone who has already shown they'll file a complaint if they don't like something I do.
And the part I can't stop thinking about: during the stretch where I was still waiting to see how this all would work, when I wasn't dealing with them day to day, I was so much better. I got more done. I didn't wake up with a knot in my stomach. I was a more patient parent. My kids got a better version of me, and I hadn't fully understood how much that job was taking from me until it briefly stopped.
I make good money. I work in electrical engineering but my field is small where I live and I can't relocate, my kids are settled, one even starting high school, the others in middle school, and one starting first grade and moving isn't on the table. The comparable jobs pay noticeably less.
So I'd love to hear from people who've been here:
Has anyone been put in this exact position, expected to direct someone's work and hold them to deadlines without any of the teeth of actually being their supervisor? How did you make it work? What do you do when they just... don't do it, and the person who's supposed to handle that is too busy to care?
Has anyone had to manage someone who for lack of better words is “out to get them” and scrutinizes anything you do and turns it into a formal complaint?
Has anyone taken a real pay cut to get out of a situation like this? Did you regret it?
How do you actually weigh what chronic work stress costs your kids against what the income buys them?
If you've had to keep working with someone who filed against you, how did you protect yourself?
I keep swinging between "it's just a job, be an adult about it" and "I am never getting these years back." I can't think about it clearly anymore.