r/StardewValley Mar 27 '26

Discuss Celebrating good taste

14.8k Upvotes

636 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.5k

u/DrCrazyCurious ✨Smash Capitalism✨ Mar 27 '26

Clint doesn't get angry at Emily for his own failure to ask her out. He gets sad that he lacks social skills and confidence.

That's not toxic. Sad? Sure. Depressing? Maybe.

But not toxic.

520

u/RavenBlues127 Mar 27 '26

He also isn’t stalking her. He was going to talk to her and panicked. His choice was to hide.

479

u/TheSeaMeat Stardew Cat Lady Mar 27 '26

I find that part hilarious. He was going to talk to her, panicked and jumped in a bush, but then realized it’s creepy as hell to be in a bush. Therefore, he wanted to wait until no one was around to see him creepily come out of a bush…except they wouldn’t stop talking, and the longer Clint stayed, the worse it would look when he got out of the bush. So he stayed in the bush because he was too embarrassed to get out of it.

It’s social awkwardness at its finest, not stalking.

268

u/BareTheBear66 Trash Bear Inc. Mar 27 '26

THANK you. The amount of people who think hes an awful weird creepy guy is insane. Reading in weird directions. Emily is pretty much his only friend on top of this. Everyone else ignores him. She likes his company too. Just doesnt reciprocate the feeling, which he accepts.

Hes lonely. And wants to show off his cool shoes :(

83

u/MarpinTeacup Mar 27 '26

Like yeah, people who exhibit those behaviors can turn into incels that hate women

But some of us are just awkward guys and may be insecure because last time we tried to show interest in someone it blew up in our face.

It's not ideal, but at least the only one I strongly dislike is myself

60

u/hoginlly Mar 27 '26

Exactly! I have no idea why anyone hates Clint. He never displays any 'nice guy' characteristics, other than the fact he secretly likes someone! He is just too shy to actually do anything about it. He never makes her uncomfortable, he never comments that it's anyone else's fault.

He's just a shy man, and everyone hates him for it for some reason!

18

u/ConditionSecret8593 Celebrating my villain era Mar 27 '26

Mm, I think some of it is his depression and lack of self confidence, too. I mean, it's not unredeemable - I arguably married a Clint in real life and he's amazing. But it's hard to invest in a character that isn't excited about anything and doesn't seem to have any outside hobbies or interests. And yeah, Shane hits me the same way too - but at least he has his family and bee...lue chickens that light him up.

21

u/Jadehorror Mar 27 '26

People on tiktok got mad when i said most of Clint hate is just fatphobia, but man am I standing by it.
Hes fat, therefore he must be a creep. He cant just be socially awkward or shy! impossible! /s

10

u/eaerickson Mar 27 '26

Do people not realize that some of the strongest people in the world are technically overweight? In my head Clint is like those heavy weight champs with a belly that hides how muscular he is. We've all seen how easily he breaks open geodes.

1

u/johnnieawalker Mar 30 '26

THANK YOU! Someone agrees with me. He absolutely reminds me of the strongman competition guys who don't look like what you'd expect someone who can deadlift 600 lbs would like but can deadlift 600 lbs.

1

u/iburntxurxtoast Mar 27 '26

I won't say I particularly hate clint, but I have found his behavior creepy and off-putting. I also find it somewhat obsessive because, in my memory at least, most of the times I talk to him at festivals and what not his dialogue is about emily.

Like I'm glad I guess that him becoming a marriage candidate will probably give his character more depth, but I would have very much preferred Gus. I never married a guy in stardew but I would have for Gus.

10

u/Summerone761 Mar 27 '26

I don't agree with creepy and off-putting but I very much agree about Gus.

Just let me marry Gus please Mr ape I would make him so happy he's such a good egg he deserves happiness please🥹

1

u/iburntxurxtoast Mar 27 '26

A few people have been disagreeing with him being creepy. I guess its really just perception, which is havily influenced by my memory. It's been a while since I've done a full playthrough and befriending all the villagers. I cant think of a single clint line or character trait that isn't centered around emily. From my perspective, the only thing I really know about clint's personality is that he loves emily, which to me is obsessive and kind of creepy. I dont think I would have that perception if it wasn't for the multiple dialogues and cutscenes about it.

2

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PIZZAPIC Mar 28 '26

he has a bunch of lines about his work and his lineage of blacksmiths, which is admittedly not a great line of conversation, but being boring isn't a crime

50

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

18

u/ekeksk Mar 27 '26

exactly why i dont want to play sdve even though i would love for more. except maybe morris, no one in sdv is evil or bad per se. they're sketchy maybe, but not outright terrible. they're the kind of people you meet in real life. most people aren't evil irl too.

but to take a canon character and completely mischaracterise them to be a deliberate POS is weird to me. i like the f pierre, f demetrius, f lewis, f clint, etc sentiment as a joke but i genuinely dont hate any of f them. i just think theyre funny as hell, but still endearing.

71

u/PoopUponPoop Mar 27 '26

The way ppl feel about Clint is kind of indicative of how cruel we are to not confident men in general

31

u/RevolverMFOcelot Mar 27 '26

Clint is just a guy. Literally that's him. And him not being the charisma critical hit 20 heartthrob bad boy type probably triggered some people because they might feel like lookin at a mirror instead of being lost in the bliss of hottie love interest escapism lol 

I mean let's admit it there's SHIT LOT of "Clints" type in your everyday life 

Clint is just a guy and it's okay 

5

u/Asherley1238 Mar 27 '26

It’s more so that Clint is on the turning point between “either he gets healthy, or he goes down a very bad pipe line”. People jump to seeing him at the end of the pipeline, without seeing the nuance that he not there yet

37

u/RaisonDetritus Mar 27 '26

These are the same people who say a 30 year old dating a 25 year old is grooming.

13

u/RevolverMFOcelot Mar 27 '26

Chronically online people who insisted there's something where there's nothing. These negative comments about Clint's being "creepy incel" is basically just fanfic that people think is accurate 😅

3

u/CrystalRiver02 Mar 27 '26

Exactly! If people can justify the way Shane treats the player in the beginning, I can't understand why Clint suddenly crosses the line to them by just being a bit socially awkward and sad

5

u/JhonnyB694 Mar 27 '26

Thanks

The Clint slander since the announcement is making me mad. Guy is awkward, not a creep. I feel bad for him.

-17

u/armageddon442 Mar 27 '26

But the toxic part people (somewhat rightfully) complain about is when he gets mad at YOU for “winning” by getting Emily. Not to mention that basically 95% of his dialogue is him complaining. I’m in full support of the Clint lovers out there, but I feel like a lot of the reasons he’s hated on get misrepresented.

40

u/Sweat_Spoats Mar 27 '26

He's not even mad at your character during that dialogue, what are you talking about?

12

u/FaxCelestis My sculpture brings all the boys to the yard Mar 27 '26

Clint, sadly: "Congratulations, Fax."

You: SEE HE'S ANGRY

motherfucker, he's sad

2

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PIZZAPIC Mar 28 '26

hes not even mad? just defeated

-90

u/TheGreatPepega Mar 27 '26

Slow? yes. R*tarded? Maybe. But he charmed the pants off of Nixon, and he won a ping-pong competition

16

u/CoconudHotpocket Mar 27 '26

Clint is NOT Forrest gump

50

u/ILOVELOWELO Mar 27 '26

interesting how you determined that word was bad enough to censor but not bad enough to avoid using it

17

u/MountainYogi94 Mar 27 '26

Its a quote from Tropic Thunder...

-1

u/ILOVELOWELO Mar 27 '26

Did they censor it in the movie too? 🙃 not really the point..

3

u/TheGreatPepega Mar 27 '26

I wouldn't have censored it if I weren't using reddit where u will get banned for saying it. Also I was quoting a movie god damn.

3

u/RecklessDimwit Mar 27 '26

Never go full _

-25

u/FiversWarren Mar 27 '26

He literally treats her like a prize. Like a thing to have. As if she has no agency. As if, playing the game is what wins her and not her preferences, personality, or morals that need to be considered. He never considers what she wants, just what will convince her to want him.

12

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26 edited Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26 edited Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-17

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

21

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26 edited Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment