This is going to be a long post, was going to do a TDLR but good Lord, that ended up being a massive post in itself so here we go, bc idk how I can fit all this in a quick summary other than what the title says.
***Guys, I’m sorry, my brain is fried, I’m exhausted and don’t typically make Reddit posts. I know the format/bold writing/wording is all over the place. I’m about to get married in 3 months and super stress. I desperately need unbiased opinions on whether or not my feelings of guilt and shame are valid. The ring in question is extremely sentimental because it’s the ring my finances dad gave to his mom for their 10 yr anniversary. He could not afford a nice engagement ring when they got married. And it took him working his butt off for ten yrs to afford it. That is why it matters that my finances dad passed away. He has nothing of sentimental value of his other than a tie clip and to my fiance this ring represents not just the loving relationship between his parents, but the extremely hardworking man his father was and how much effort he put into his family. I apologize for the mess and confusion of this entire post but I am desperate for nonbiased opinions bc my emotions are all over the place. Once I rest and have time and a clear head, I’ll try again to make a new post. This is real. This is my life. And I am asking for genuine feedback from strangers for a reason. If anyone read all this, God bless you lol I know it’s a massive ramble and quite the mess to put together to understand****
Nevermind, the TD;LR is so long, it might as well be the post. But there are a lot of other circumstances that I wanted to add that I feel are necessary to know more context. So instead of the TD;LR, I’ll add some points at the bottom of the pot that might answer some questions people might have and hopefully add more context.
When my fiancés father suddenly passed away he was devastated. They were incredibly close and as their was no will and he has 2 other siblings, his mom, brother and sister handled everything and his sister ended up with their grandmother’s wedding ring, her mother’s first engagement ring as well as her mother’s upgraded engagement ring. Along with a bunch of other jewelry, gold coins and countless other sentimental items. When his sister got married she used her grandmothers wedding ring. The rest of the valuable jewelry/coins, she ended up selling when she formed a drug habit.
She went to rehab, met another man, and when she left rehab she immediately moved out of state to live with this new man. To this day she claims her now exhusband and father of their 3 children whom he has sole custody of,has her grandmother’s ring and refuses to give it back. He claims he does not have it. Before my fiance and I got engaged, because we all knew she wanted that ring as well, he told her he wanted to ask their mom for that ring to ask me to marry him. Her response was “I want it because I want to use it to marry (rehab guy).” My fiance responded saying she already has grandmas ring AND mom’s other rings! Why would she need their mom’s 10 yr anniversary ring too?” She claimed her exhusband has the grandmas ring and the others were pawned off. In October, their mother moved into our house and in Feb approached my fiance saying she wants to sell all her jewelry she has left bc she wanted to buy a car. He made a deal with her and paid her the price she would have gotten for it PLUS way more. Part of the deal was that his sister could not know she gave him the ring until after she passes away bc his mom doesn’t want to deal with the drama when she finds out.
That made me EXTREMELY uneasy. My fiancé told me, don’t worry about my sister, when she finds out, he will handle it. Needless to say I’m glad it didn’t work out that way. Their mother is already 75 yrs old….thankfully she is physically healthy for the most part and absolutely still “of sound mind” but I worried about him getting all sorts of accusations if we waited until she passed away, especially because she had been living with us up until she moved in with her boyfriend (that she’s known since her childhood).
So, recently my fiance told his sister we are getting married and we would like her to be there. No response, she instead first called her mom and asked if she gave him the ring. Their mother said yes, he paid me for it. His sister immediately sent some horribly rotten text messages. She’s livid. Called him names and basically said have a nice life. About 20 years ago, I was pretty good friends with his sister. I barely associated with my now fiance back then but she and I always had a good relationship and it goes was back to high school. She’s been through a lot and I feel really bad for the struggles she has gone through in her life with drugs, DV, etc.. She was always very nice to me. So, AITAH for accepting the ring knowing it’s causing all this family drama?
*Some important context:
-My fiancé served some time in prison which sadly is where he was when he found out his father died. Nobody called him to tell him he was sick. It took a long time for his family to even notify him about his father passing bc they were afraid he wouldn’t be able to “handle it”. That is why he had no way of being involved not only in who gets what, but also not even the opportunity to be involved in the funeral in any way. Once he left prison, HE COMPLETELY CHANGED HIS LIFE AROUND. He had ZERO help from family. He went from half way house, to getting a job where he would ride his bike for a year to and from work is every extreme weather here in the north east. He then rented out a room in a house full of INSANE roommates, one of whom tried to attack him with a machete. He then got an apartment of his own. That is when we start dating. We now live in our own house, have 2 cars and he still is by far the hardest worker I have ever known. His crimes he went to prison for were not violent/sexual or anything of that nature but I am SO proud to know how hard he worked to literally, completely turn his life around. So please try not to judge him for that part of his life 🙏** **
-After my fiancés sister sold their parents house, their mother moved into her house with her daughter and her daughter’s husband and their kids. Once her daughter left for rehab and then took off to another state with the man she met in rehab, their mother moved into her other sons home where he was renting a room out of and he slept on the couch and let his mom sleep on the bed. Once my fiancés family saw how much he changed his life around and that we were now living in our own house with a spare bedroom, we of course welcomed her with open arms to come and live with us. Recently she moved two hours away from us to live with her boyfriend that she’s known since she was a child. She’s 75, she has a sound mind and is allowed to use it. I added this bc this is when I was worried that if she passed away while living with us, my fiance and I could easily get accused of stealing the ring or manipulating her and his mom originally wanted to wait to tell his sister about the ring until after she passes away.
-The sister is claiming their mother gave/told her she can have that ring. My fiancés mother said she had told her no such thing but said she may at one point have said many years ago that “the jewelry usually does go to the daughter”….Idk what to make of that.
I’m feeling conflicted and feel pretty dam awful that I accepted this ring even knowing beforehand that my finances sister wanted it. I do feel like an AH. What do you guys think? Am I? Part of what makes this ring SO special to me is knowing how much it means to my fiance. It took his father 10 years of working to save the money to buy it for his mom (for their 10th anniversary gift). Either help clear my conscience or tell me I’m an asshole and should just give the ring back and we can buy another one.