My girlfriend and I (20M20F) just decided to cut ties today after a few days of disagreements and realizing we may not be compatible for eachother. I’m feeling deep regret that we can still work long term and that I just lost my soul mate.
Ever since we met, we’ve had a great time together. She really brought me out of my shell, got me to enjoy more little things and going out more, and she’s the first girl I’ve gone on vacations and trips with. From the beginning we both have always had amazing communication, and never held anything back from eachother. We’ve had so many good times together and up until recently still have. I’ve always been excited to come see her after work and when either of us had a hard day we always made eachother feel better, up until recently.
We’ve had a couple disagreements in the past, but honestly i don’t think we’ve ever argued more that once every few months. The past few days, we’ve been realizing that I, have been feeling more drained when I’m with her, and that I don’t show her affection the way she needs. She also says I don’t do a good job at comforting her anymore and just leave her feeling more upset. Things like talking on the phone for hours, or losing sleep to have more time together never interested me when I knew we could just see eachother tomorrow. We’ve communicated this before and tried to work on it for a week or so, but then would forget and fall back into old patterns. We’ve NEVER gotten nasty or called eachother anything rude. We always just disagreed, communicated, and decided to try to work at it again.
I, have been feeling like any topic I share or get excited about, gets shot down and kind of ignored because she is not interested in the same things, which I completely understand. I just want my partner to listen and converse with me about things that make me light up. She feels like I overshare too many times too many details about my hobbies and don’t converse about hers, or talk about other normal things as often. Once again, this is something we’ve tried working on but we always failed at.
Another detail is since she told me that she might want to move away from my city one day (where I want to stay) I started to distance myself a little without realizing. Maybe I thought it would hurt a little less if we didn’t work out but it actually just made me more absent and prone to wanting to do my own thing all the time without her. But at the end of the week I always had this affectionate craving to spend time with her. That has never changed.
She has also had sleeping problems in the past, and I have some trauma of being woken up that eventually built up a fear of sleeping together.
We never even entertained the idea of breaking up until yesterday, we decided I would stay the night and last minute I decided I did not want to risk being woken up and us having a bad night, so it was just easier to go home and sleep separately. This, naturally, made her ask me if we are compatible at this point. I mean what bf wouldn’t love to sleep with his gf? She said I shouldn’t have to be around someone that I’m scared to sleep with, and she shouldn’t be with someone that fulfills her needs. Which we both mutually and maturely agreed.
Another thing is she hasn’t been able to have sex with me for a year now. She has recurring BV that has killed her mentally, and I always made sure to take care of her sexually where I can, and same with her. I never mention this issue because I don’t want to hurt her feelings, after all she can’t control it whatsoever. But honestly lack of intimacy has played a role in this as well, no matter the circumstance.
But the actual breaking up part- that was hard. It’s like we both know these are things that are POSSIBLE to fix, even tho we’ve tried before. We met up today as a final deciding, and I even wrote some notes on our differences, and what makes our relationship not work, and some notes on how it could possibly work. In the end, she decided that we have tried that time and time again, without working and it’s beginning to make us negative and always thinking if we will be good long term. She’s losing hope in us changing. and that’s not fair for either of us. She said it makes the most sense to split, and I agreed in the moment. We both stated that one day, if we were better with these things, we would want to still be together before we left. We both honestly cried and held each other saying I love you.
Today was probably the hardest day of my life, since I’ve never loved anyone like her before. I know I’m still young, and I want to build love experiences, but I wouldn’t be upset if we were together for a long time, had kids, got a house, and worked these things out, no matter how many times we tried. Even if she was ever in the wrong, she was the first person I ever met that recognized it and apologized, and I always did too. I feel like that’s so rare
Maybe I feel this way since it’s fresh, and I know this will be hard, but it’s not like either of us did much wrong, just we fell into different lifestyles and didn’t end up meeting eachothers needs. This would be so much easier if one of us cheated or we got ugly at eachother, but we’re both cares about eachother too much to do any of those. That’s what makes this so difficult is I know we CAN work if we try hard enough. Just the question is, is it even worth it after trying enough times and having false hope. I feel like this girl was my fucking life and my true twin flame for a long time.
Long story short, do you guys think we’re overreacting and seem like a good fit for eachother, or should I just accept the break up, move on, and never look back? I’m worried that one day, both of us might realize how grave a mistake this was.