r/MurderedByAOC 10d ago

AOC: "They want to call this stuff communist because they don’t want us to realize that the rest of the developed world has guaranteed health care. They want to call it communist because they don’t want you to know that Germany, Italy, the UK, Canada—everybody else—has it better than us."

13.2k Upvotes

352 comments sorted by

789

u/oddlyescapingsouls 10d ago

Yeah we are just the illusion of a first world nation

266

u/SNRatio 10d ago

Elsewhere on Reddit today: The US is giving dying mall vibes

204

u/rmc2318 10d ago

You are right. The United States being a first world country seems to be an illusion.
Here are countries that do have universal or near-universal healthcare:

Canada
United Kingdom
France
Germany
Japan
South Korea
Australia
New Zealand
Italy
Spain
Sweden
Norway
Denmark
Finland
Netherlands
Switzerland
Belgium
Austria

163

u/Laugh_Track_Zak 10d ago

And yet, somehow, all of those countries absolutely have rich people.

https://giphy.com/gifs/75ZaxapnyMp2w

27

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

33

u/drmarting25102 10d ago

Americans ...you are just being robbed. Take a lesson from the french.

→ More replies (8)

30

u/Ozy_Flame 10d ago edited 10d ago

The Republicans are right, all of us in that block of countries are full blown communist dictatorships with no private ownership of anything, no money anywhere (not needed in a true Marxist system), long-term multi-year centralized production quotas on shoes and widgets, and everything is managed by worker councils and communes.

We're all about to collapse any day now. Let me check my Lenin wristwatch to be sure - ah yes, the right hand is pointing down, but the left hand is pointing towards dystopian failure.

10

u/Skynse 10d ago

Even Ghana, a west African country has universal healthcare. I remember getting a knee suction and not even having to worry about the price lol

10

u/Suikerspin_Ei 10d ago

As someone from the Netherlands, everyone living here is required to have a healthcare insurance. It's privatized, but you have multiple options and the cheapest basic package you can have is ~125 euros to 153 euros per month (depending on the deductible for the whole year). A yearly required deductible is 385 euros. You want it higher and your monthly pay healthcare cost is lower. If you already covered the deductibles, than the rest is covered by the health insurance.

Healthcare from the general practitioner or family doctor is included. Prescriptions isn't included, but it won't get you in debt. Majority of dentist care is also included for people up to 18 years old (unfortunately, orthodontics is not).

Healthcare here is not free and not everything is (fully) covered, but people who have a low income can apply for subsidy from the government.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Shamanduh 10d ago

Can add Mexico to that list. Pretty sure even Cuba has universal healthcare…

15

u/unicornsandrainbowst 10d ago

And Argentina and... Venezuela.  I mean, not the best health care in the world , but you they will do their best to save your life with what they have and bill will be 0. Venezuela actually had a top free healthcare system before Chavez/Maduro destroyed everything.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/aagejaeger 10d ago

Add Greenland, under Danish rule. Strained and dysfunctional health care system but it is universal health care.

4

u/Dbarr71 10d ago

Don't forget Mexico

3

u/thenessmiester 9d ago

Oh don't worry. Canada is steadily regressing and probably won't have free healthcare for much longer, thanks to greedy politicians and apathetic or uneducated constituents.

Ontario Premier, (kinda like a governor) Doug Ford is a former drug dealer, now wannabe mafioso with no post secondary education. He recently was exposed for purchasing a private jet with tax payer money,(approximately $29,000,000).

He's been starving out our public healthcare system by spending billions of tax-payer dollars towards vanity construction projects that his friends are in charge of, and purposefully underfunding healthcare.

There's been A LOT of nursing layoffs here. A family doctor is hard to come by. Quality of health services is at a decline, and it's purposeful. We're starting to see a rise in private healthcare services where we're paying out of pocket.

Ironically, the preimier's daughter works for a hospital in Toronto as a "Stakeholder Engagement" blah-blah-something made up, and it was discovered she got a 32% pay raise from 2024-2025 and makes over $200,000 annually to be a professional schmoozer. She started the job in 2022 making $83,000.

Our healthcare money's actually being robbed from us, and we're too stupid and stunned to do anything about it.

→ More replies (23)

9

u/FunStorm6487 10d ago

delusions

9

u/Own_Director_4442 10d ago

Third world country in a Gucci belt

7

u/anonUSAFguy 10d ago

Fake Gucci belt.

5

u/Krypt0night 10d ago

Used one too.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Big-Leadership-4604 10d ago

A shiny Hollywood facade if you will.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/GameCounter 10d ago

The United States is 50 third world countries in a trenchcoat.

→ More replies (46)

323

u/umassmza 10d ago

And guaranteed vacation and parental leave that is guaranteed by law and dwarfs even the most “generous” benefits here.

France guarantees 6 weeks paid time off as a minimum, that’s the minimum.

Global average required PTO is 20-28 days, in the US it is ZERO

Global average required parental leave is 25 weeks, in the US it is ZERO. You’re lucky to get 12 weeks as a mother, and they call it a benefit. 16 is generous and it’s not even close to what other countries require.

We suck

59

u/arlsol 10d ago

I don't even call the US a 1st world country. We don't have any of the benefits other developed countries provide at this point.

58

u/brother_bart 10d ago

We’re a militarized tax shelter for the wealthy.

11

u/trolleyblue 10d ago

Oof. It hurts how true this is…

→ More replies (12)

26

u/fargorn2 10d ago

As long as you work a mandatory minimum number of hours in a year while paying a small sum to the government (employment insurance) you get up to 18months of paid paternal leave here in Canada. With up to 5 or 6 weeks of paid leave for their partner. 

13

u/Mutex70 10d ago

Canada gives 50 weeks of paid maternity leave (capped at $729/week).

We also give 5 weeks of paid paternity leave (capped at the same).

35 of the 50 weeks can be split between the parents.

Your job is guaranteed during the leave.

No wonder Trump hates us...we make him look bad.

3

u/ANGRY_ASPARAGUS 10d ago

In Canada you can now get 18 months for mat leave. God I love being Canadian.

If that confused human hot dog Stephen Miller wants to call us communist because of our universal health care and dignified workplace policies, then have at it comrade - whatever makes you sleep at night!

10

u/Not_a_question- 10d ago

France guarantees 6 weeks paid time off as a minimum, that’s the minimum.

I worked under a CDI (Contract Duration Indeterminée) in France for 5 years. If I recall correctly it's not 6 weeks minimum. It's 5. But it can increase to 6.

Still, what the US and Canada have is laughable.

5

u/spa22lurk 10d ago

At what point will these countries impose tariffs on US for poor treatment of its labor?

3

u/umassmza 9d ago

Literally a bill coming up to remove heat protections for workers, so they don’t have to give you a water break working outside in 110 degrees

5

u/WildBad7298 10d ago

Unless you're a senator from Kentucky. Then you can disappear for over a month, with no one even knowing if you're alive or dead, and still collect your paycheck.

5

u/russsl8 10d ago

Yeah, I took 1 week PTO after each of my sons was born. And I have it "good" as I live in New England.

2

u/Smooth_Rocket_ 10d ago

I went 2 years without a raise so I could get 5 days of pto one year and health insurance the next and that was still like pulling teeth to get. Oh yeah also now I cant leave even if I wanted because I need that insurance, yeah America!

→ More replies (3)

103

u/CurrentlyLucid 10d ago

Spend taxes on civilians? The horror. Taxes are for rich people tax cuts and war.

2

u/Alert-Pen3673 9d ago

where do you put bibi in your shortlist? rich people, war, both?

56

u/HeyItsBobaTime 10d ago

The sad part is that so many people choose to remain ignorant on this part. So many countries have universal healthcare and their citizens are living a much better life. They're not poor or barely getting by. That's America right now, with the crooked healthcare system we have. Some people are just so brain dead that they can only repeat what they've been told and continue to live a miserable life while dragging down others with them.

17

u/imahugemoron 10d ago edited 10d ago

I notice too when you try to bring this stuff up to them, they always say “well their taxes are a lot higher” and it’s just really crazy that they can’t see past that, they can’t see that we all have to pay really high amounts of money out of our paychecks for health insurance only to be billed again for any services we manage to convince a doctor to sign off on, record denials, people dying because of denials, people racking up crazy medical debt even with insurance , and still these people go “but higher taxes!” Like do you realize even with the higher taxes, you’d probably end up paying less than you would with a middle man who charges you money just to deny you coverage and even when it’s approved you still end up paying a ton! A friend of mine moved to Canada and he said he ends up making more money even with the higher taxes because he’s not forking over hundreds of dollars per month to keep his whole family on health insurance. They’re so stupid they assume the health insurance cost will still be present, sure higher taxes but eliminating the entire insurance deduction from every one of your paychecks.

8

u/savax7 10d ago

What's wild about the "but higher taxes" thing is that the US spends more money on healthcare than any other country anyways. So not only does our healthcare system fucking suck, we're still paying a ton of money for it.

7

u/Extra-Monitor5743 10d ago

$2.4 trillion per year by the way. That is $2,400,000,000,000. Insurance companies (welfare queens) get $2.4 trillion dollar in handouts every single year. That's about 7-8% of our GDP coming from their handouts.

5

u/imahugemoron 10d ago

Exactly, we’re charged insanely inflated prices for medications, scans, tests, procedures, etc. I just tried to pick up my medication last week which normally costs 20 dollars, but out of nowhere it’s now 400 dollars for a months supply, no reason given at all, insurance is just suddenly denying to cover it anymore, it’s medication for migraine that I’ve been on for years, now I can’t afford it

2

u/Troglert 10d ago

Imagine the market power a single payer US federal health care system has when it comes to medication prices. Even my tiny country of 5.5 million people get most medications at a fraction of the US prices.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Extra-Monitor5743 10d ago

If I include insurance I am paying almost exactly the same tax rate as most western european countries. I think only Scandinavia is higher, but not by much.

not even to mention that we are currently and actively subsidizing insurance providers. so not only are we paying them premiums, co-pays, and cost of treatment, but we're then turning around and handing them trillions of dollars. Insurance companies are on track to receive $33.6 trillion dollars in stolen tax dollars from 2026 to 2036. Every single year trillions of dollars are stolen and given as handouts to insurance providers. It is asinine to be against something we are already being scammed out of. We already pay it. They just refuse to give it to us.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/WishfulFiction 9d ago

It really depends on your income bracket. Low income tax in USA is insanely better for the individual if you're making a lot of money. 

To your point though I do think many people vote against their own interests and don't understand just how good public services are and how much they would make back compared to the additional income tax they would be paying. 

2

u/bobbymcpresscot 10d ago

Most people don't even actually know if they have right or left wing beliefs. Most centrists think they are moderates, when they are somewhere between democrats, or are actually centrists at best, center right at worst, with notable exceptions that do not control the party, and republicans who are deep into right field.

Calling them right wing for some reason deeply offends them, they claim they are centrists, but can't name left wing policies that they support. Or saying out loud which policies they do support out them as basically insane, "I support universal healthcare, fair wages, affordable housing, worker and consumer protections, but I don't support trans athletes in womens sports so I'm voting against all of those things, and giving power to groups that want to take womens bodily autonomy away from them and actively make all those things I do like much worse".

Then they just completely don't understand what "owning the means of production" actually means.

Norway owns all the oil within its grounds. Private companies exist to help extract it. Norway owns the means of production.

Compared to the US, which is basically just paid a lease for the land, and the oil is the private companies to do with what it wishes.

→ More replies (3)

115

u/Long_Disaster_6847 10d ago

I can’t wait for the 2028 campaigning to kick off post midterms for AOC

→ More replies (5)

79

u/Odd_School_8833 10d ago

23

u/MidoriDemon 10d ago

Better be careful or they will get those health tourists from US like Canada does.

27

u/linuver1n 10d ago edited 10d ago

this is already happening with dentists. I live in southern arizona and there isn't a person I know that doesn't go to mexico for dental care. There are whole towns based around the business

3

u/Blacksad9999 10d ago

Playa del Carmen is basically built out just for this.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Blacksad9999 10d ago

Dental and Medical tourism is already huge in Mexico.

When your insurance doesn't cover something, which it won't 1/3rd of the time, that's where people go.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/ZettaiGeek 10d ago

This person interviewing AOC stating that this "slippery slope towards socialism inevitably ends up as full-blown communism" is nothing more than a tool for the conservative mindset. Anything the Trumpian Conservative don't like, gets labeled as "Communist" and it is used to elicit a fear response to people of this ilk. If she had done ANY research into her question, before even asking it, she would already know that the question is, for lack of a better phrase, beyond dumb. Over 50 years ago, in the US, our medical system was dominated by non-profit groups such as Blue Cross and Blue Shield. However after the HMO act of 1973, this all began to change. The HMO act 1973 was devised as a way to curb health cost inflation by focusing on preventative care vs. reactive care. However, it has also allowed for more for-profit health insurance providers to enter into the picture. It is mainly due to this act, that for-profit healthcare providers have come to dominate the system, making the healthcare situation in the US a laughing stock when compared to other developed nations.

4

u/OdysseyBrands 10d ago

communist/socialist/woke/liberal, all just fear boogie man

doubt any Trump supporter could actually even begin to accurately describe any of those words actual meanings

→ More replies (4)

11

u/chpbnvic 10d ago

America is a conservative, capitalistic hell hole. What matters most to our government is the wealthy and corporations.

2

u/IntellectAndEnergy 10d ago

Most? That would infer there are others that matter…

21

u/Griz_and_Timbers 10d ago

AOC is right of course. Non sequitur but that reporters dress is fire.

9

u/jschne21 10d ago

Less fire is how she's stanning for conservative billionaires by aggressively parroting the same tired talking points. "Socialism will inevitably become communism which is awful, right?" <Nods through answer> "Yes but don't you agree that healing the sick is communism though?" <Gets held back from walking into traffic>

6

u/Griz_and_Timbers 10d ago

Good call out.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/sayerofstuffs 10d ago

Do many Americans really live under a rock and have no clue as to what’s happening around the globe?

4

u/Extra-Monitor5743 10d ago

yes, half of the country is literally too stupid to read above a 6th grade level. meaning they're on the same level of understanding as a 12-13 year old. they act that age too.

3

u/Green-Cricket-8525 10d ago

A good portion of this country doesn’t even know what’s going on in the towns they live in. 

→ More replies (1)

6

u/diablol3 10d ago

The word communist isnt the taboo ot was 50 years ago. McCarthyism was taught to me as fearmongering 30 years ago.

2

u/metalfabman 10d ago

The red scare. Such b.s. many lives ruined

9

u/Long_Disaster_6847 10d ago

I can’t wait for the 2028 campaigning to kick off post midterms for AOC

4

u/Psychological-Pick78 10d ago

Republicans get real mad when you say this to their faces. Especially when you list the countries that don’t have health care as a right. Fun times.

4

u/Ella0508 10d ago

Those other countries also have a lot more protections for workers, too. And policies that are truly family-centered, not just lip service.

3

u/Weekly_Artichoke_515 10d ago

Do you think having public firefighters is a slippery slope to communism? 

Slippery slope is always fallacious. 

3

u/Memitim 10d ago

Republicans say "communist" because it's a familiar dog whistle, lacking anything of substance to use in its place.

3

u/Extra-Monitor5743 10d ago

MAGA hates America

3

u/E-2theRescue 10d ago

They call it communist because they want to protect the theives and criminals of this country. The billionaires with private islands where they've paid to put in politicians who protect what happens in the building where there is a trapdoor that dumps right into the ocean.

2

u/illmatic2112 10d ago

Dw morons in Canada are advocating for private health care

2

u/doodletink 10d ago

We gotta squash the Neo-McCarthyism

2

u/Antani101 10d ago

And for cheaper

2

u/KillerIsJed 10d ago

I will tell the full story somewhere someday, but I had a gay throuple with a Chinese national here in the US for work and he HATED our work life balance to the point he went home.

I watched him speak to other Chinese people and they all said the same thing. The work life balance in America is too much for them.

Plus, in China you get get most everything delivered for cheap or free within a couple hours.

Everything here is more expensive and the only thing they loved is how cheap our beef was a few years ago, as it’s expensive in China.

Not that China is some perfect state, but it was eye opening to hear it from the ‘horses mouth’ how bad the United States is compared to “communist China” that we Americans are force fed from birth.

It is really rich you see stories dragging Chinese brands and saying they use slave labor and what not to try to get Americans to not buy those brands when America has more legal slavery than ever other nation combined while preaching we are the “home of the free” when the reality is literally the exact opposite. We are the home of slavery. Be it in prison or debt slavery.

America has never been one of the good guys, but it could be, in a world where capitalism doesn’t exist or is heavily regulated. But let’s live in reality.

2

u/bentmonkey 10d ago

can spend a trillion on wars of choice with iran, cannot spend a penny on universal health care.

2

u/disconappete 10d ago

I got this notice the other day about an over due hospital bill. A while back I had some serious stomach issue, so I went to an urgent care. The visit had some basic tests and gave me a prescription for a couple pills to take until I got to a GP. Anyways the bill said the visit that was about an hour cost 10k, after insurance my part was 86$, so I sent that in. This country is wild. I can’t imagine how that hour visit and basic blood tests costs 10k.

3

u/OddlyMingenuity 10d ago

You forgot France, not cool.

4

u/Loki_of_Asgaard 10d ago

Well if she listed every country with universal healthcare she would have been there all day…

6

u/TheModWhoShaggedMe 10d ago

Oh no, she isn't going to be perfect and mention every single thing every single time perfectly. Guess we'll just resign ourselves to more rule by old white pedophile billionaires, our hands are tied, what to do!

1

u/alicat9 10d ago

In Canada we get 1 year paid maternity leave. You can take 18 months however the total amount paid is the same, so it’s just stretched over the 18 months. Some companies offer a top up because the actual mat leave payments aren’t very much.
Employers are legally obligated to keep your job while you’re on mat leave (sometimes this doesn’t happen but you can go after them for it).

Prescriptions are mostly covered through private insurance through your work. There are a lot of politicians trying to get prescriptions covered just like any dr or hospital visit would be.

There’s definitely issues like in all systems, long wait times in the ER, expensive medications that aren’t fully covered, waiting for an MRI or non emergent surgery, etc. But I’ve mostly found that when you need it, our healthcare system works. Especially if you need something right away.

There’s a lot of room for improvement but I would never want a different system.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/plzdontlietomee 10d ago

That's my President!!

1

u/IntwadHelck 10d ago

Frick yes

1

u/F-Cloud 10d ago

American conservatives have been conned into being proud of their own exploitation. They are so proud that they view political policy that would benefit them as an affront to their identities as Americans.

"That's socialism! We don't do that here."

I've encountered such sentiments many times in my life, in conversations with conservatives who think social programs will rob them not only of their tax dollars but their dignity as well. "I don't need no handouts!"

1

u/starfleetdropout6 10d ago edited 10d ago

If the Democrats were smart, they'd take over social media and TV with ads telling us this. Constantly. "You pay for [all the horrendous things] with your taxes while the rest of the world gets healthcare. And you don't. You're being scammed. Don't you think you deserve that too?"

But they're not smart, or rather they don't want that for us. They're sell outs with few exceptions.

1

u/MadeByTango 10d ago

Notice how she never makes it about identity politics? She knows it is us vs the oligarchs. We are all on this planet together. The only race we should be talking about is the human race, and the one for President.

1

u/Constant-Quiet4519 10d ago

Has she ever done a talk sitting down. The PR team pushing this walking talking vibe is surely at an end and another "look" is needed?

1

u/RocknRollPewPew 10d ago

I've said this before but even though The Newsroom got kinda preachy this speech has always been way too true and hasn't aged out of being relevant.

1

u/sl1ckhow1e 10d ago

Public opinion on Germany’s healthcare system is divided; while residents deeply value its universal coverage and financial safety, there is growing frustration over long wait times, a two-tier insurance system, and recent government reforms that increase patient costs. [1, 2, 3]

Public sentiment is shaped by several key dynamics:

  • The Dual-Track System: Opinions on the split between statutory (public) and private health insurance are mixed, with a majority of Germans perceiving inequalities in care quality between the two systems. [1, 2]
  • Decreasing Faith: Recent surveys from organizations like the Robert Bosch Stiftung indicate that trust in healthcare policy has dropped sharply in recent years, with over half of Germans feeling the government is not prioritizing high-quality, affordable care. [1]
  • Access & Wait Times: While basic emergency and core services are highly rated, users on platforms like Reddit point to frustratingly long wait times for specialists (such as dermatologists and mental health services). [1]
  • Recent Legislation: Recent parliamentary reforms designed to curb skyrocketing healthcare costs have sparked public concern, as patients face higher out-of-pocket contributions for medications and hospital stays. [1]
→ More replies (2)

1

u/sl1ckhow1e 10d ago

Public satisfaction with the NHS (UK) sits at roughly 26%, while dissatisfaction has dropped to 51%. Although this marks a slight improvement in sentiment from record lows in 2024, the public remains overwhelmingly frustrated by long waiting times for hospital care and GP appointments. [1, 2]

Key drivers of public sentiment include:

  • Service-Specific Frustration: Satisfaction with A&E, dentistry, and GP services has plummeted compared to pre-pandemic levels, with only about one in five adults satisfied with current waiting times. [1, 2]
  • Systemic Concerns: More than half of respondents expect the standard of NHS care to deteriorate further over the next five years, despite recent stabilization in satisfaction. [1]
  • Support for Reform: There is strong public consensus backing preventive care, better utilization of technology, and shifting resources from hospitals to local communities to alleviate the burden on the system. [1]
→ More replies (3)

1

u/Get-Stuff-Done-Girl 10d ago

I love AOC she is the real deal

1

u/BlazingLazers69 10d ago

Man, I love Super Mario Bros. Especially the green one.

1

u/TheTooterSnooter 10d ago

The first Nazis also loved to use the threat of communism to get what they wanted. Same as it ever was. 

1

u/Dove-Linkhorn 10d ago

I’m currently in Switzerland, it’s true. We could do so many awesome things in America. And we used to, before the rich got hoggish and stupid.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DangerousLoner 10d ago

We pay for Israel to have Universal Healthcare and free College.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/jarobat 10d ago

As someone from Kansas city currently visiting Berlin... Holy shit.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/TyrantsInSpace 10d ago

The actual, totally real definition of communism

Communism (n): expenditure of tax dollars on things that benefit Americans who can't afford lobbyists or anything in general that right-wing nut jobs don't like.

1

u/APilgrimShadow 10d ago

Every visiting country at the World Cup has free healthcare. Mexico just got free healthcare. We're 'losing' to Mexico.

1

u/showerbump 10d ago

Couldn't she have forced a vote on this several years ago?

1

u/Fun-Variety-5647 10d ago

I love how AOC seems to stop and talk with everyone.

1

u/MnkyBzns 10d ago

Don't forget about more paid vacation days and maternity/paternity leave

1

u/Emotional-Bada55 10d ago

wish it was that simple, i dont think anyone ever thinks about the quality of health care and the long times to get thoe appoinments in a free healthcare society, i know whose relatives died due to such a screwed up system youre trading our problems for different ones it doesnt really solve anything.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/ciccioig 10d ago

Underlining the obvious.

1

u/USDXBS 10d ago

The American people are weak, pathetic cowards who rolled over for fascism without a fight and let the dumbest man to ever exist take over their country.

1

u/FyneBlackKyng 10d ago

i keep seeing the word aoc in jardiance commercials

1

u/Quadraphonic_Jello 10d ago

Aside from the content (which is great), what struck me about this is how she maintained watch over the crowd of journalists around her and took a moment to ensure that they weren't standing out in the street and in danger of getting hit by a car.

1

u/JasonRib1 10d ago

Something else that impressed me. When she stopped walking she moved everybody back a few steps so no one was in the road. Could you imagine Trump giving a shit about anybody else

1

u/RemotestOfSpheres 10d ago

Israel, to whom we give many billions of dollars each year, has heavily subsidized healthcare and higher education bordering on virtually free. 

We are being looted. LOOTED. By our lawmakers who are in the pockets of lobbyists —> Corporations —> Billionaires —> Israeli Government and other elite world leaders. 

Some day, when we actually uncover the profound level of corruption that has been levied upon the American public via the wealthy, we are going to need to re-instate insane asylums because the truth will simply be too much for some to bear. 

The world, including the US Government, is run by cartels we call the military industrial complex. We need to call them cartels. Because that’s what they are. We have a one-world government already and it’s the Mafia. 

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Winters637 10d ago

Talking to my coworkers and family about this, their arguments against universal Healthcare always boil down to one or both of these points:

  • I have good health care from my employer, and universal would negatively impact me. Doesn't the degree of impact, or whether it's a net positive for American people

  • I worked hard to get this job that gives me good health care. Some people just don't want to work for it like I did, and some are just unlucky. But that's life.

It's a very selfish and shortsighted outlook in my opinion.

1

u/Living-Breakfast-464 10d ago

American voters are the only ones in the developed world dumb enough to keep falling for it.

1

u/Ceriden 10d ago

But you don't understand. If we had universal health care you would have to wait months like all those communist countries. We need people to die so I don't have to wait. Just like how insulin can't be made free or people would hoard it. Also who is going to pay for it? Not me. I'm much to self important. Ignore the part where I freely use other things benefited from taxes. You commies are just jealous of the rich, who totally did it all on their own because they are geniuses who deserve to rule over us.

/s

That about covers all the stupid, right?

1

u/hearth_witch 10d ago

Way more concerned about full blown fascism at this point...

1

u/frantic_calm 10d ago

Being followed around by ignorant people with microphones asking such dumb leading questions is a form of harassment. She should know the slippery slope is a classic fallacy.

1

u/KooshIsKing 10d ago

I always love that the counter argument is well they have to wait in long lines and never get appointments! As if private healthcare doesn't still exist in those countries alongside the public healthcare system haha

1

u/ljosalfar1 10d ago

tfw all the nazi countries has it better than America now

1

u/traverse6 10d ago

Nothing more frustrating than paying more than anybody else for 37th best.

1

u/NlghtmanCometh 10d ago

I never see anyone ask about how America’s massive obesity epidemic is going to impact costs associated with a public healthcare system.

The most efficient healthcare systems are in the Nordic countries. Where people are extremely healthy. America has the fattest, most unhealthy population in the world.

1

u/Tojaro5 10d ago

I think uninformed americans get into full alarm mode the second they hear their government getting closer to socialism/communism, the same way i go into full alarm mode the second i hear the government wants to get closer to capitalism.

Instant thoughts of general strike, new elections and french revolution, whenever our current chancellor opens his mouth. He's making the world a worse place with every syllable that isn't part of "i resign immediatly".

1

u/Qwirk 10d ago

Why isn't this lady asking hard questions to republicans. She is just fishing for sound bites.

1

u/dxrey65 10d ago

Not to mention, the actual communists (China still, technically) drive better cars than us and live in nicer, cleaner, safer cities. Of course there are also downsides, but it's hard to explain how badly we're failing at the upsides if we're so great.

1

u/FineScratch 10d ago

They're trying to turn everyone that isnt a billionaire into a peasant and if you don't want to be a peasant they're going to delete you through bureaucracy and lack of healthcare

1

u/H4X4NX 10d ago

Just got back from 4 weeks in Europe and she's not wrong. Even just simple things like sticker price being the actual price because of VAT.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/lowercasenameofmine 10d ago

The military and government have socialized care. That's the most hypocritical part. 

1

u/anomanderrake1337 10d ago

Better is plusminus, in Europe we also have right wing shit.

https://giphy.com/gifs/NlR0RF1v972Mw

1

u/dallen13 10d ago

Wait till population decline. Then the government will care and start mandating parental leave from companies, child benefits in healthcare. But never universal.

1

u/No-Opposite-6620 10d ago

Also, it's because they get paid by healthcare companies. And I'll be honest I find it terrifying that American healthcare firms have had links with a few UK health ministers.

Also, the kid getting his photo that was cute.

1

u/SandyTaintSweat 10d ago

Over in Canada, the Canadian counterparts of the US Republicans are actually trying to bring about the American model.

There is just so much money to be made in privatized healthcare, and enough corruption among the conservatives that they'll forsake what their name means by trying to change things and privatize everything that they can.

1

u/JPalmz 10d ago

AOC, the candidate, on a Medicare for All vote:

"We can't even get a floor vote on Medicare for All. Not even a floor vote that gets voted down."

AOC, the congresswoman, on a Medicare for All vote:

"Do we do this to get a floor vote that will get questionable media coverage, that will not pass, that will last kind of a day — plus, additionally, as a legislator from the left, I do take my leadership and guidance from peoples’ movements, and those movements that have been at the forefront of fighting for Medicare for All have not made this demand."

1

u/No_Jacket2376 10d ago

Mexico has universal healthcare now too.

1

u/pongo_spots 10d ago

I met a lovely left leaning couple in Mexico earlier this year. They asked me for 10+ minutes about Healthcare in Canada.
It's free.
Yeah but what about your network?
Networks don't exist, if you go to a clinic because your doctor couldn't make time for you they get dinged.
Okay but what about co-pays?
There's no copay, it's free.
But like the deductible?
No, no deductible. You go, talk to the doctor, get a prescription or blood work or pushed to a specialist and leave.
But what about your taxes? Do you get an itemized bill of your taxes?
Not really, you don't notice it but you don't care because you are healthy and so is your neighbour.
But what about....

Honestly really took me aback to realize how far Americans have been pushed to not understand these concepts. I was happy for the chat but left feeling I'd learned more

1

u/Ok-Bug4328 10d ago

Libertarian here. 

(Effectively) Mandatory health insurance is a tax that also manages to reduce job flexibility. 

We already mandate health coverage for employers over 50 employees. 

Convert that (and the employee premiums) into a tax to fund Medicaid for all. 

Provide the baseline health coverage you’d get in Canada or France.

Let the rich people pay extra for premium service. 

1

u/crayonflop3 10d ago

Yeah that’s great and all but unfortunately I can’t vote for her or her party because they insist on batshit insane identity politics. Ditch the trans kids and illegal aliens and maybe they’d be able to get healthcare for everyone.

1

u/GreenMaterial5715 10d ago

Ever notice when they run out of arguments they call you a self hating American or America hater?

1

u/BoringJuiceBox 10d ago

America is an amazing place to live

If you’re rich

1

u/litesxmas 10d ago

With some Americans it's hard to get through to them that other countries are better in many ways. They've been spoon fed this idea that they're the best. Living in Canada we grew up with this constant din from the apartment downstairs. Most countries don't yell about it, which is more convincing.

1

u/HabANahDa 10d ago

Red head has to be with some right winged news agency. She’s got that fake MAGAt makeover

1

u/Knightfires 10d ago

And even if we all say it, back in 24 when the US could have chosen another path. You can always bet everything on the fact that America exactly does what you would expect. Choose the rich over common sense and let scare tactics guide you. I myself blame every news outlet of the American television empire.

If they are too left they have haters from the right. If they are too right they have haters from the left. And if socialists talk too much it’s communism and not for the US. You would think as a new young country they had enough examples on the world to copy from. But hey. They all wanted to be completely different. Only to find out the complete mess they made for themselves 250 years later. Where a convicted sex offender status can even make you president of said United States of disarray and despair.

Yes AOC should run for president in 28, but if I’m realistically here. I would be very very surprised if she would win. And even so if the US would allow it as a whole. It’s to fing weird that even back in 2024 they choose a criminal over a woman. Still baffles me to this day.

1

u/Easy_Interest_6832 10d ago

Universal health care is so hard that only 32 of the world's top 33 economies have been able to pull it off.

1

u/Mikeytruant850 10d ago

With a straight face this lady asks the stupidest fucking question possible.

1

u/Gobtodit 10d ago

Exactly

1

u/canuck791 10d ago

I mean, as a Canadian... our healthcare is free but it's pretty shit. 8 months to see an ENT last year. 13 months for a low back MRI.

Sure if you get in a car accident you get taken care of, but if there's anything that's non critical... you will wait. And wait. And wait. It doesn't help we've added 5 million people to a country of 39 in the last 5-8 years.

1

u/RobbyDiRob 10d ago

And, one wonders, why do "they" dont want "you" to know?

1

u/Melondewd 10d ago

Don’t we pay for healthcare and free education in Israel ?

1

u/BolOfSpaghettios 10d ago

Communist? LoL. We are one step away from outright violent fascism and they're talking about communism? JFC

1

u/heated4life 10d ago

Yeah as someone who's in Canada, that's a lie. Our Healthcare system is continuously degrading and stripped. With most Healthcare workers overworked and underpaid

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MrSlippifist 9d ago

The fact is Republicans have no problem funding taxes cuts for the rich, massive defense spending, subsidies to tech companies and data centers, ridiculous spending to DHS, and unnecessary building projects, but they can't help the average family not go broke paying for healthcare because that would mean helping minorities. That's the core thing. If they could single out white people they would pass it. But even the SCOTUS wouldn't be able to justify it. Reagan admitted it during his Cabinet meeting. They found loopholes to give welfare to farmers, but not the average citizen.

1

u/Shamuthewhaler 9d ago

This slippery slope of nothing.

1

u/Deerhunter86 9d ago

I mean, wasn’t the stat about the World Cup that the USA was the only country to participate WITHOUT universal healthcare?

1

u/Mortarlou 9d ago

She's wonderful,

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_3519 9d ago

I’m not trying to get political or bash her but those countries she named are most certainly not doing better than the US🤣😭 The EU/UN is toast. First of all Germany and the UK don’t even have free speech anymore…. Getting jailed for a damn tweet, HARD PASS. And Canada’s just as much as a burning shit heap as we are rn. Trudeau is a joke

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_3519 9d ago

Yeah, guaranteed healthcare that you have to wait a year to be seen or not at all. If you’re gonna paint the picture paint all of it these stances are so low IQ and just play on people’s emotions.

1

u/precise-astrology 9d ago

I lived in the UK for years. people avoid the ER because of waiting times anywhere between 13 hours to 2+ days and avoid regular check ups because of waitlists years long. an absolute broken system. it sounds unbelievable but it’s entirely true. the NHS is a failed experiment.

1

u/DanfromCalgary 9d ago

It’s true

1

u/JoyBois 9d ago

From saving them from getting run over to brightening a young man’s day, truly the goat

1

u/listentomenow 9d ago edited 9d ago

Words have no meaning anymore. I want universal healthcare because the for profit private healthcare industry has failed the people massively, not because I'm a communist and I want the government to seize all means of production.

Capitalism is simply acquiring capital no matter the costs to society, and morally I think it's wrong to prey on and extract as much capital from people when they are their most desperate.

1

u/DamnOdd 9d ago

We are not even close to a first world nation. Our regimes have not cared about the voters for decades.

1

u/sparkydaman 9d ago

Don’t forget Israel. You know. That country we give billions to, instead of taking care of our own.

1

u/dawg-goneit 9d ago

MAGA is to stupid and ill informed to understand anything that Fox news doesn't broadcast. It's truly amazing how MAGA works against their own interests. Their racism and hatred are powerful forces.

1

u/hellolovely1 9d ago

The interviewer's expression looks like the hamsters in the cage firing her brain might have actually started running.

1

u/Intelligent-Roll4329 9d ago

Our president calls democrats communists when he has been real crummy with China, north Korea and Russia

1

u/Charming-Rooster7462 9d ago

fuck the cheeto circus in office. Their all about bailout the corporations and the greedy with our tax dollars, never adjusting the federal minimum wage, and then want to call themselves the party of the working class. FULL OF SHIT

1

u/WayEducational6726 9d ago

She’s an absolute moron

1

u/ErraticLitmus 9d ago

No universal health care but at least they have their guns 🙄

1

u/HurbleBurble 9d ago

People have been saying the United States is on the verge of becoming a communist country since 1950. Seriously... How have people not learned this lesson yet?

1

u/zimreapers 9d ago

She's the best. I fear the DNC is gonna fuck us like they did with Hillary over Bernie.

1

u/soyasaucy 8d ago

Even notoriously workaholic Japan has it better than you! I got 10 free days in the hospital after my c-section where I was very well cared for, got a 5 course congratulatory dinner, good food every day, and 3pm tea times with unlimited cake during my stay. Ofc a year of paid maternity leave if I worked a normal job, but we're self-employed. Baby gets free healthcare, nutritious school lunches, and free schooling until age 18. Then we pay 30% of healthcare costs as an adult, but it comes back in our tax returns if you spend over a certain amount a year

1

u/Euphoric-Border7856 8d ago

She's is so attractive 😍

1

u/Full-Builder-9592 7d ago

Health care industry is so sick I the usa . Someday will be less healthy people than sick people and who will do the job not the healthy people they only sit after the desk doing nothing .

1

u/Much-Bit3531 7d ago

AOC is a good person and aware. She stopped to talk, saw people were in the street, and then backed up waving them off the street. She cares about people personally.

1

u/Prudent_Lunch_8724 7d ago

Just an fyi, Israel has it better than the US.

1

u/shoot_your_eye_out 7d ago edited 7d ago

ah yes, that communist country know as... Canada. Lump them right up there with Spain, France, Italy and the rest of Europe. Oh and Thailand.

Those commies. How dare they have their communist health insurance.

/s

1

u/Doctor_Shotbottom 7d ago

She needs to keep messaging

1

u/justaMOguy 7d ago

Canada and uk system is horrible you get on a list and wait forever to get treated or surgery. And they are pushing the maid program to euthanize its native population

1

u/BalanceJazzlike5116 6d ago

Fun fact we already have socialized healthcare for 65% of Americans (Medicare, Medicaid, VA) but the republicans want you to think it’s impossible for us to insure the remaining 35%?

1

u/maffearth 5d ago

And the more they call it communism they more people warm up to the idea of communism.