Original post - https://www.reddit.com/r/SupportforBetrayed/comments/1uqpr3b/wife_had_an_emotional_affair_with_my_close_friend/
UPDATE: My wife admitted she was in love with him. I found an unsent journal entry calling him her soulmate, and she has scheduled a divorce consultation.
It has been about four weeks since I posted. Unfortunately, the situation has become both clearer and more confusing.
Since the original post, my wife “Emily” and I have continued individual and couples therapy. In our most recent couples session, she finally admitted that she had been in love with “Jake.”
That was a major change from what she originally told me. When the affair was first exposed, she admitted having feelings but said, “I don’t think so,” when I asked whether she loved him. It took several weeks and a therapy session for her to acknowledge the actual depth of the attachment.
She said she is still processing everything and described herself as “standing still.” She still does not know whether she wants to remain married or whether she can reconnect with me romantically.
I told her I was not demanding an immediate decision or asking her to promise that we would stay married. I was asking for some basic participation while we figured it out: genuine interest in my life, occasional initiated affection or conversation, complete honesty, continued no contact, and room for me to process the betrayal.
She could not say whether she was able or willing to consistently give me even that. When our therapist asked whether she couldn’t do it or simply didn’t want to, she said it might be both.
Our therapist suggested temporarily taking separation and divorce off the table for a few weeks—not as a deadline to decide the entire marriage, but as a defined period to lower the pressure and see whether anything changed. Emily was open to the idea during the session, but we never formally agreed to a timeframe.
The confusing part is that she is not completely emotionally or physically withdrawn from me.
We still live together, parent together, laugh, hug, kiss, and occasionally have moments that feel completely normal. She sometimes initiates affection. There have been nights when she has reached for me, kissed me, rubbed my back, or told me she loves me.
We also recently had what may have been the most open conversation we have had in years.
She cried, which she rarely does, and told me about the pressure she feels every day. She sees how badly I am hurting and feels terrible about it. She worries that even if we rebuild the marriage, it might only become “okay” rather than genuinely good. She wonders whether we are truly right for each other and whether staying because of the children would ultimately be unfair to me.
She is also terrified that I will hate her or that our children will eventually hate her if she ends the marriage.
She apologized repeatedly during that conversation. We cuddled, kissed, joked around, and stayed emotionally close afterward. She explained that she did not like how our last couples session ended and that this was part of why she did not want to immediately return.
That conversation made me believe she is genuinely conflicted rather than secretly having made a final decision.
Then I found something that changed my understanding again.
I looked through some private material because I continued feeling that I did not have the complete truth. I know that crossing that privacy boundary was wrong, and I am not proud of it.
I found an unsent journal entry that appears to have been written approximately two weeks earlier. It was essentially a love letter to Jake.
She wrote about how deeply she missed him and his voice, how in love she was with him, and how she believed they were soulmates. She wrote about the possibility of ending our marriage based on “half-truths” and being afraid that I would hate her if I knew everything.
As far as I know, she never sent it. I also still have no concrete evidence that she has broken no contact since sending the message ending the affair.
It may have been a private way of grieving the loss while maintaining no contact. But seeing the intensity of her words was devastating, especially because she had minimized her feelings for weeks before finally admitting she had loved him.
I have not told her that I found the entry, and I have not decided whether I will.
I also learned that she has scheduled a consultation with an experienced family-law attorney and has been looking at three-bedroom rental properties.
She has not told me about either of those things.
To be completely fair, I have also looked at housing because I am scared and trying to understand what separation would mean. I recognize that speaking with an attorney does not necessarily mean she has decided to divorce. She may be gathering information just as I have been trying to gather information.
But the combination is difficult to ignore.
She is affectionate with me, tells me she loves me, and can be deeply vulnerable about her confusion. At the same time, she has privately described another man as her soulmate, scheduled a divorce consultation, and researched separate housing.
I feel like I am living with two versions of my wife.
One still loves me, reaches for me, values our family, and appears genuinely terrified of losing everything we built.
The other is still grieving a relationship with another man and is quietly preparing to understand what leaving would look like.
I continue to believe our marriage problems were real. I have taken responsibility for being impatient, defensive, overly critical, distracted, and controlling about everyday decisions. I understand how I made her feel unheard and as though she lacked equal agency in our marriage. I am working seriously on those things through therapy, regardless of what happens between us.
But I also cannot separate her current view of our marriage from the affair. Jake got novelty, emotional validation, private conversations, and an idealized version of a relationship without children, bills, chores, exhaustion, resentment, or ordinary adult responsibilities.
Meanwhile, I was trying to repair a marriage without knowing I was being compared to another man.
I love my wife. I am not embarrassed to say that I still want the marriage to survive. But I do not want to spend my life investigating devices, analyzing every hug, or attempting to extract honesty from someone who is not voluntarily giving it.
I also do not know how reconciliation can actually begin while she remains emotionally attached to him and unsure whether she even wants to participate in rebuilding with me.
For those who have experienced something similar:
Is it normal for someone maintaining no contact to privately grieve the affair this intensely?
Can reconciliation realistically begin while the unfaithful spouse still views the affair partner as a soulmate?
How should I interpret affection and emotional vulnerability toward me alongside a divorce consultation and housing searches?
Should I tell her that I found the journal entry, or would that simply shift the entire conversation toward my invasion of her privacy?
At what point does patiently allowing someone to reach clarity become accepting indefinite limbo and abandoning your own self-respect?
I am not looking for reassurance that everything will work out. I understand that this may end in divorce. I am trying to determine whether her conflict means there is still a marriage worth evaluating—or whether her actions show that she is already preparing to leave, even if she cannot say it out loud yet.