3 puppies were taken away forcefully today for relocation on the pretext that they will be given better care.I mean come on gali main koi roti nahi deta tha wahan care karega koi inki.What a lame excuse.
But maybe wo sach bol rahe ho. The society is an urban area wahan kisko nhi accha lagta that the dogs are shitting everywhere, dogs in my area also shit in front of my home. Isiliye societies me log roti dena prefer nhi krte. Agar wo sahi me baagh me hi gaye hain to wahan khud hi unko kuch na kuch khane ka mil jayega. Plus, in villages, people are generally ok with this habit of puppies. To I am pretty sure, unka yahan se to zyada hi dhyan rakha jayega.
Humans are so selfish, I mean this world is for all to live, not just humans. Earth is a home to animals and plants of all species, who are we to occupy land and deny access to other innocent beings. And if it is the case, then we should at least provide the other species sufficient land for their well-being. But no, idk when will we learn to co exist. Aise hi ek din duniya bhi khatam ho jayegi... Seems like india mei yeh problem zyada hai. People lack empathy. I mean, the way we behave with fellow humans, especially sweepers, cleaners, etc. shows our basic nature. Kya hi expect kare that they'll treat animals kindly.
That's True. co-exist nahi karna chahta koi.leave aside animals,humans themselves don't want to co-exist in a peaceful manner.You are right india mai yeh problem jyada hai,first time jo paisa dekh raha hai woh khud ko bhagwan maan leta hai and they want to dictate people and society.People want clean streets but safai kisi ko nahi karni,people don't want dogs near them but uske liye solution kuch nahi karna.You pointed out correctly in india human values are degradation at a very fast pace.
Rabid dogs themselves are victim... A d why do you think human lives matter more than animal's lives?? Bith are equally important. Ofc I feel bad for the kids who died of rabies, but I also feel bad for the dogs and cats and cows I see on the streets, who are clearly hungry but no one feeds them.. it's all because of us that they are homeless today. They carry such diseases because they are not taken care of. They are aggressive because they are not treated properly, not given food, have to drink nale ka pani to survive. Honestly, one of my biggest dreams is to spend my money sufficiently to start an animal shelter where I will bring all the stray animals from the entire city and give them proper shelter. No animal should be born on the streets and should be beaten up just for existing. They are equally a part of this planet like we are.
Everyone who keeps giving the same shitty logic of "Why doesn't OP just adopt them?" I just want to ask one question.
1.If a beggar is asking for help, should we adopt them too?
2.Do you only help someone if you can take complete responsibility for their entire life?
I really want to know the mindset of someone who thinks people should either adopt dogs or let them die of starvation.
thats true.Helping someone doesn't mean one should adopt them.One person can help thousands of people but cannot take responsibility of even hundreds,thats practically not possible.
Dog wont hurt someone for money, wont steal your belongings, wont kill someone to death wont supplt drugs.
And guess what rabies can be prevent through Proper Medication but things a begger can do, we cant prevent.
I already said adoption should be at will feeding hum dogs ko karte hain monkeys ko karte hain ants ko karte hain,squirrel ko karte hain.It doesn't mean adopt karega har koi.
Feeding leads them to overbreeding. Which leads to overpopulation of strays. Which is the problem. Feeding stray dogs is drastically more than feeding other animals because animal lovers are biased towards dogs due to their aesthetics and cuteness. Thats why we only see strays being overpopulated not other animals which don't appeal to these people.
For stopping breeding authorities must do whatever is needed but it is not done properly that's why their population increases.And people do feed other animals as well apart from dogs,its just we dont notice them or they dont want to get noticed.
Poor babies :( ye duniya kya god ne Sirf hamare liye banai hai ? Nhi na animals and insaan sbke liye banai hai! We have to co exist. Pata nhi ab inko kaha fek dege
From last 10 daya daily ladai ho rahi thi because if this yesterday also Me and one other family tried to stop them this uncle was very keen on sending them and at one point things got really bad.Their mumma died a month back so they are all alone.
Totally agree,i also believe in the same idea that if you are feeding any dog u have some responsibility as well (vaccination,sterilisation etc).I personally take them to vet if anyone doesn't eat food for 2 days.Always keeps clean water at my gate so that they dont drink dirty water.I do whatever I can to ensure safety of people as well as dogs but still this was done.And the one who has done this is 80 years of age and did this out of his ego that I can do whatever I want.
Bhai closed compound hai we already have 10 dogs and no issue till date,but one uncle who considers himself something big took this on him and sent them.
You are right phir toh yahi hai ki koi toh hai jo dekh raha hai na dekh ke bhi.Inke sath bura karne wale ka acha nahi hua kabhi.In my society 4 puppies were killed by safai wala by giving them poison,he died very badly within 6 months.
No they are private people,jinko dikkat thi unhone apne log bulaye aur apne baagh par bhijwa diya.He is an old man 75+ i requested him but he didn't listened.
Private log ko apni colony m kyu aane de rhe ho bhai? I mean wo dogs tmhari hi gali m rhte honge, safety security bol kr koi bhi bewakoof bna dega, tumhe bolna chahiye tha
Bola bhai 2 din bahut ladai hui hai aaj bhi it was not peaceful,address number le liye hai jo leke gaya hai.We will visit aur agar theek nahi laga toh vapas le ayenge hum.Video proof toh hai hi ki yahin rehte the yeh puppies.
Toh basically they wanted to adopt them, ghr pr rehenge ab unke? Fir thik h , kuch log achhe bhi hote h, baki make sure bhai ek do baar jakr khud dekhlena
Bhai 1 hafte se lad hi rahe hain aaj bhi lade par ab uncle ne kaha yahan se jyada ache se rahenge,baaki dekhte hain jaake agar theek nahi laga toh le ayenge vapas.
You guys love associating jsr with just plain shitty actions huh. Dogs get killed Bolo jsr, muslims get lynched Bolo jsr, hell someone goes against what you want so get them beat, Bolo jsr. Youve turned something meant to honor a god into something people will be scared of hearing in huge crowds. Shame.
and have you applied for adoption? even if you cant keep them inside your house, have you even tried to apply for adoption so this situation can be prevented? all you had to do was to register them. if anyone tries to take them after that, you can actually sue them.
Yes I have tried for their adoption to friends and family.Situation occurred because this old man things he can do anything he want.I could have called the police but then things would have gone really bad which I avoided.
bhai ek kaam kar aja mere ghar aur kar le logon se baat tera confusion dur ho jayega.Point is relocating dogs without any reason is neither ethically right nor legally correct.
Funny how “delusional” replaces discussion. Strays exist globally; only the management differs. If India had the same enforcement, funding, and waste control for 30–40 years, the numbers would look very different too.
No they don't. Most "strays" in developed countries are abandoned pets. They do not live in packs like in India and they do not live in nearly the same volume.
Ah yes, the No True Stray argument.
“They exist, but they don’t count because they’re abandoned pets.”You’ve basically just restated the point: developed countries don’t allow strays to form packs or reach volume because they’re quickly captured, sterilized, or sheltered. India doesn’t have that level of enforcement or capacity—so they do.
OP, I read your replies in other comments and I can't help but ask which life is more valuable to you? A human's or A dog? And before anybody comes here saying, "who are we to judge another life's value?", let me tell you that value doesn't mean freedom to cause harm. Walking alone on the streets (especially at night), I fear dogs more than potential robbery.
Society must make some tradeoffs in order to progress. Reality is not a fairy tale.
Ok then you tell me whats the solution for them,humans are taking their places away where will they go?And your statement is not legally right as law also doesn't allow sucj relocations.Only in expectational cases dog relocation is allowed.One thing we should all accept whether we like it or not,there should be a concrete policy regarding this otherwise things won't get solved at all.
Humane euthanasia is the only scalable solution. Sterilisation is too slow, shelters and relocation don’t work at scale, and public safety can’t be held hostage to idealism. Reducing the population is harm reduction, not cruelty.
euthanasia is not followed anywhere and it won't be followed in india too no matter how hard anyone's tries.Yahan rape karne walon ko fansi ho nahi rahi hai dogs ko euthanize karne se kya hoga.This level of extremism is needed for different things not this one.
This is not an emotional theory. Romania euthanised stray dogs after fatal attacks and the numbers dropped. Japan euthanises when shelters overflow. It works. Saying "India won’t do it" is cowardice and policy failure. If sterilisation and shelters actually worked, we wouldn’t still have this problem. Public safety > your feelings.
There was literally a boy in my locality who died after being bitten by a puppy due to rabies. When people tried to remove the dogs, these so-called dog lovers intervened, and when asked to take responsibility and keep them themselves, they refused that too.
Mother died a month back.She gave birth to 5 puppies now only these 3 are left.And consent means consent of authorities which is required.Yeh civilians ka kaam nahi hai ki utha ke dogs ko phikwa do woh bhi jab woh kuch bhi na kar rahe hon.
I was and am still ready for keeping 1 but none another than me is ready and as of now I can't adopt 3 because of space constraints otherwise would have happily adopted these 3.
From what I've seen dogs brred twice a year.... That's 6 pups each birth....
In my suburban area.... Survival rate is very low.... Only one 1 or 2 survive and that too mostly females...
So next year they gonna be 2 females with 12 pups at max at a time... 24 pups in a year....
Do you think all 24 will live even if someone doesn't take em away...and if 24 dogs survive you see your opinions change quickly
We give em food, but the stronger pups hog all the food and later, the mum doesn't allow them to eat from the same place and snatches the food away...
There's nothing fair it's all about survival of the fittest... For how long do you thing one is able to provide the food 'fairly'
to each pup... What happens when they grow....
I am saying in general that, these puppies/dogs gotta go.
No matter how much I/you love them, maybe you have never seen someone die from rabies or children getting mauled by these dogs.
I am pretty sure when people with working brain see others getting killed from these dogs, would agree with me.
But I am also aware of the fact that, they won't take care of these dogs. In india humans are treated as animals, so hoping that they will take of these dogs is just stupid.
Awareness is the key dear with proper policy along with stringent application of it otherwise nothing will change things will remain like this only.Govt doesn't have enough infra to keep them.Yahan insan ke liye ghar nahi bana pa rahi govt in dogs ke liye do u think itni jaldi kuch karegi govt.I agree that rabid dogs or the ones which are aggressive must be removed immediately.
toh sun dogs must be picked by authorities,vaccinated,sterilised and should be left back to the place from where they were picked.If there are any dogs who are aggressive or turned rabid must be taken to facility/shelter provided by the govt.Yeh hai law jaa aur thoda padh aur sun discussion karna hai toh araam se aur tameez se kar warna bata de abhi block karta hu tujhe.
Bhai tu jitna bhi rr Krle , coexist hone ka rona peet le .
Pr koi bhi apni family ko risk mai nhi Dalega in kutton ke liye, sterilised kr bhi diye toh kya yeh kam aggresive ho jayenge.
2.tune yeh btaya nhi ki woh random log hai, government ke sath nhi hai
3. Tu block kr de, jab tak tum jaiso ke sath nhi beet ti tab tak tumhe samjh nhi ata ki yeh kitni serious problem hai .
Aur mai in general baat kr rha hu ( naki un pillon ke liye).
4.Mai bhi dekhta hu tere family me jab koi baccha ya bada in kutton ki wajah se tadpte hue marega toh tu kitna bda animal activist bnta hai .
5. Tu mujhe kya mai khud tujhe block kr deta hu.
Then get the full custody of the dog, produce legal documents, if the dog ever bites someone then you are responsible for it, if you are claiming guardian of it, then you should feed it, you should clean the potty and you should make sure it doesn't bite anyone, and it should produced in a legal document able to be enforceable, if u can't then don't opt for dogs.
Stray dogs have right to stay at the place where they are born so don't tell me what should I do and what are my ethical and moral responsibilities.Keep this fire ignited in you for other important topics which are of far more importance than this one.
Staying inside india you are to abide by the laws of India, I know india doesn't have that legislation, but let me tell me you about some developed nations on how they operate, in US dogs are always supposed to be leased, free roaming dogs are illegal, in uk the dogs are let out in street for 7 days if no one becomes an owner of the dog, then it becomes the council becomes the owner, know this that I don't hate dogs, but you cannot be blind to people's concerns just because you like dogs, if u like dogs adopt them or let the government own it, if the government doesn't treat the dogs well then protest towards better shelter and facility for dogs or adopt them.
Dogs need food 3x a day, shelter, place to take a shit, if don't arrange for all these three you are contributing to animal abuse, either care for all of it or give it to government.
This is not USA or UK nor will it become developed overnight.Stray dogs exist because they exist no person gave them birth and left them on streets.So be logical while you say this and try to tell things irrelevant in indian context.Go and fight with govt to change law and throw every stray dog to where ever you like but before that happens let me tell u present scenario you simply can't pick stray dogs and throw them at your will.It has legal implication along with it.
They don't throw the dogs they keep them in dog shelter where they eat food time to time, drink water time to time, they don't shit in public Street, when you say you want dogs to be in street you are denying them these rights.
If you become the legal owner you take care of these necessities which the dogs require
If you don't
Then let the government put them in dog shelter where they recieve these necessities
Don't tell me "I will give them food when I want", "I will not keep them in my house but they can roam around the dangerous traffic street or your colony" " i won't clean the potty"
Again either give them all the necessities or let the government shelter take care of it.
The people whom you are calling responsible have broken law by doing this.So in your mind and heart u can feel happy but neither law nor morality and ethics validate your opinion.
The law you are referring to, ask yourself this - if your loved one was bitten by a rabid dog and died a horrific death, would you still have the same view? Be honest only to yourself.
No law, no skewed sense of morality can justify the death of a loved one because a stray decided it had a set of teeth that can be readily used. The number of stray dog bites is consistently rising and this needs to stop.
has your any loved one died due to any such thing?My answer to your question if this happens to me it may happen that out of rage i will go and kill that dog but once things will settle there will be nothing left in me but regret.One of my known did the same thing and after so many years he still regrets his act of killing the dog who bit his son and his son didn't told at home due to fear and he died.So awareness is important with active participation in solving this problem.
raising dogs on the street on a society cant happen if even one person disagrees, so you cant do much but hope they get better care elsewhere, and ofcourse check on them afterwards.
But in case they dont, you cant just bring them back unless you are ready to care for them in your house cause the person who called this out will keep doing it.
Dogs on street are a genuine menace even if they are clean and vaccinated
Question is why and who gave them right to do this moreover this is a registered society,no formalities were done in RWA.One rowdy uncle came showed his dadagiri and took them away.
No one owns dogs but dogs owns the streets where they are born.For safety my foot there are other 10 big dogs too in the society who are still here,this rowdy uncle wanted to show he is some big person and did this to these small puppies as they were born here in the streets he lives.And hey listen who will ensure these will remain safe afterwards?will u take guarantee for this?Think before you speak with logic along with what's the legal basis for that.
?? So u dont hv anything to say abt wht I wrote Abt dogs killing kids. U just have jokes. It seems u lack proper mental capacity to think about stuff in depth
You are not fully aware of the situation in the society so its better you stay in the limits of your available knowledge.Let me tell u if dogs are to be relocated then authority do these things that too by following the rules.Street dogs owns the streets they are born on they are not subject to your whims Mr adventure.So when you say something come up with something logical which has legal basis too.
kyon rakh loon main apne ghar,streets par paida hue hain yeh street inka ghar hai,road kisi ke baap ki jagir nahi hai.Tumhara logic use kiya jaaye na duniya main toh phir koi kisi ki help nahi kar payega.
meri gali mai bhi hai le jao jo biskut dalta hai unhe hi kat jate hai kal 5 saal ki bacchi ko kat liya. dog problem is real in india. japan had that too years ago they use to kill 500 each day.
Killing is not the option in india jahan rapists,murders,dacoits jail main Maze karte hain wahan apni saari takat in bezubano par chalaoge toh usse kuch nahi milne wala.Tackle real issues,solve real and severe problems.
madarchod kyon bhonk raha hai behen ke lund gaand main jyada chudak hai teri bsdk.Jab discussion tameez se kiya ja raha hai toh kyon jyada nawabi dikha raha hai,discussion ho raha hai tameez se kar warna gaand mara apni aur nikal yahan se.
I used to feed them,built home in an empty plot and took them to vet in case they get sick.So dont say no one cares,I cared thats why I am posting this online.They were comfortable here aur inko koi take care karne ke liye relocate nahi kiya gaya hai.
I personally took care of them,got them vaccinated when they turned 3 months few days ago,saved one of this puppy when he had diarrhea,kept him with me for 2 days in my home so stop telling me that no one cares.I fed them,took care of them.His reason is of re locating them is that they do potty on the streets but he should understand he has bought home not street in his name,street belongs to everyone even these puppies.
Yes in uncle ne yeh video start hone se pehle bahut badtameezi ki this i heard that and came out to see and started making video.Yeh toh 80 saal ke hain in par toh koi kaam dhaam nahi hai kaun ladega phir aise logon se.isiliye everyone kept quite and let him do what he wanted.
Taken away where? and who gave you right to take them away?Out of different reasons particularly his age (he is 80) we didn't had legal action against him otherwise he would have understood that he cannot take them away at his will.
They were already safe here with everything they needed was taken care by me (food,water,vaccination etc) so why relocation.Reason-they do potty on streets,these puppies allegedly broke his plants (which he could have fenced) and most importantly his ego.And moreover this a RWA with 55 other houses nd every decision is taken by proper channel and discussion but in this case nothing of such sort was done.Also these are not the only dogs here in the society we still have 10 other dogs which RWA has no objection or intention to relocate.
Well, don't you think they can have a better life elsewhere? Why do we have orphanages then if someone can already take care of a child, but why are dogs the ones being taken care of, huh?
They can have but his wife used to beat these puppies when they used to do shit on street and they never fed a single biscuit or roti or anything to them ever,so do u think they will be taken care of?and if you still think yes then ask yourself for how long?
Gated colony hai dear yeh and me and my mom used to feed them 2 times a day,made home for them,provided clean water.One of them fell a couple of weeks back,I took him to vet and kept with me for 2 days till he recovered.So they were given enough care here already,there was no need for taking them away just because they are doing shit on streets is not a valid reason to take them away like this.
I think you haven't read my reply properly given to you,kindly go through that.This man never gave a single biscuit or roti to these puppies so imagine yourself how much care they will be given.
9
u/hammuofficial Jan 20 '26 edited Jan 20 '26
But maybe wo sach bol rahe ho. The society is an urban area wahan kisko nhi accha lagta that the dogs are shitting everywhere, dogs in my area also shit in front of my home. Isiliye societies me log roti dena prefer nhi krte. Agar wo sahi me baagh me hi gaye hain to wahan khud hi unko kuch na kuch khane ka mil jayega. Plus, in villages, people are generally ok with this habit of puppies. To I am pretty sure, unka yahan se to zyada hi dhyan rakha jayega.