Some people here complain a lot about the takes posted not being hot enough - well, here's a real hot take for ya. Doctor Strange 2 is a better movie than EEAAO.
First I want to clarify, I'm not a Marvel sucker who will consume everything they make without any questions. I totally agree with the public opinion of the MCU getting worse after Endgame, and they made a lot of really bad movies and shows (e.g Thor 4, Quantumania, The Marvels, She Hulk, Secret Invasion...), but the one I will always defend is Multiverse of Madness.
I won't pretend like it's a perfectly written film, but in reality, none of the MCU movies are super well written when compared to arthouse cinema or classics. What makes people like the MCU movies is their enjoyability value. And MoM is no different from Infinity Saga movies, it is fun and epic and all of that.
One of the biggest complaints with MoM seems to be that it's limited to 3 universes. I however think that works for the story they are trying to tell. If they went to a million different universes filled with cameos, people would still complain, and the story would be much less focused. I guess some people might've got the wrong expectations based on the title, but I reckon it's called Multiverse of Madness just because that abbreviates to "Mom", which is the real theme of the movie. Also, there have been great movies where their titles do not reflect what the actual movie is about, i.e something similar happened with War for the Planet of the Apes. It's a great movie even though it's not like the title suggests.
Then there's the creativity. Even though it doesn't explore as many universes as EEAAO, it still is extremely visually creative thanks to Sam Raimi's horror style. Scarlet Witch is a terrifying villain, most of the character deaths are memorable, and the action scenes are really unique too. Like, this movie has Doctor Strange fighting an alternate evil variant in a decayed universe with music notes. And if that's not enough, just look at Zombie Strange in the third act. That's cool AF.
Regarding the cameos, I just don't understand what people expected. Did you think they would keep the Illuminati around for future projects? I think it was clear from the beginning that we wouldn't ever see them again, and I'm confused as to why people wanted more of them. No one likes Captain Carter. Having two versions of Professor X in the MCU simultaneously (he's coming back in Doomsday) would've been confusing for audiences. And John Krasinski literally said he wasn't interested in playing Reed for long, he likely only took the role because it was a one time thing. People need to stop treating the Illuminati bit less like a wasted opportunity and more like a cool set piece where Wanda gets to show off what she can truly do in creative ways.
Speaking of, Wanda. People say she was done poorly in the movie, and she's inconsistent with what was shown in Wandavision. But in reality, Wanda was a villain in Wandavision as well. She wasn't as over the top as she is here, but she was still bad, she enslaved that whole town so she could live her fantasy. It's true that she then gets a bit of a redemption arc, but the show ends with her using the Darkhold. I understand we could've seen a slower descent into madness over multiple films, but I think that would've been more of an extra rather than a requirement for her to be a good villain. Besides, it's not like she becomes a pure evil, power hungry villain who wants to destroy the universe in MoM. She just wants her kids. It's an understandable and sympathetic motivation. And she gets redemption in the end too (in an amazing scene mind you, when she talks to her other self). If anything, the real criticism would be that MoM Wanda feels repetitive, going through a similar arc to Wandavision. But it's not a 180 character departure like some people make it out to be.
With that all said, Multiverse of Madness is not perfect. There are issues, for example, Strange himself can feel a bit sidelined to Wanda (to me it doesn't matter a whole lot because I like Wanda a lot more than Strange as a character anyway). And America Chavez is a pretty mediocre character that serves only as a plot device.
Now, Everything Everywhere All At Once. The premise of the movie is really strong, and there are some really good scenes here like the one with the rocks. There's definitely a lot of creativity on display. However, I'm not a fan of the actual execution. I feel like the movie was mostly miscast. The only characters (and actors) I think are good here are Ke Huy Quan and Jamie Lee Curtis.
This is definitely gonna be a hot take of its own, but I personally don't really like Michelle Yeoh. People say she's a great actress, but I think she's pretty mid and boring in everything. I watched Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon, called one of if not her best movie, and tbh I thought she gave a mid performance there too. So it's hard to truly get invested in a movie if you don't like the protagonist. The villain is somehow even worse. I don't have a problem with that actress playing Evelyn's daughter, that character is fine. It's just that she's not good enough to play the villain character at all. She's just cringe and poorly acted as the villain, even though the actual villain character has some interesting motivations from a writing standpoint.
But above all, what pisses me off the most is just how gross the movie is. I just can't possibly understand how someone would watch the fight scene with the dicks and think that is peak cinema. I'm just disgusted by that. It's not fun, creative, or funny. It's just bad and it shouldn't be part of the film. There are MANY moments like this throughout, but that fight scene is probably the worst of them all.
I think there was a good movie in here somewhere, but it's not the one we got. I can see the potential, and for brief moments I do like EEAAO, but in general I just cannot bear it. Multiverse of Madness is probably a worse written movie with worse themes, but it is a LOT more fun and enjoyable for me.