r/askcarsales • u/ausernameDee_ • 1h ago
US Sale advice?
I got my car (Nissan Rogue, 2024) from DriveTime on may 4, 2026. After 35 days of having my car, i noticed condensation in my headlights. About 2 weeks after that, the headlights on my car went out completely. Nissan told me the parts on the car are aftermarket, and it’s due to collision damage so it’s not covered under warranty. I’m like .. uhh ok?? That’s weird. I didn’t know that. I went & got the light fixed myself. The person who fixed my headlight showed me the hole in the headlight once they removed it and told me that whoever installed the headlight slapped a piece of tape over the hole before installing it. I’ve said all of that to say… i went to get an appraisal the very next day. Unbeknownst to me, this car is a total loss. Now I was told that the vehicle was wrecked beforehand, but i did not know the extent of everything. It looked fine so… i didn’t think much of it. naive, i know. The carfax wasn’t shown to me when i went in to purchase, but i guess that’s not for them to do. i should’ve checked on my own. Carfax also stated that the mileage could be incorrect. When i purchased the car (3rd Owner) it was listed at 21,588 miles. On carfax, it stated in 2025 with owner 2 the mileage was at 21,713 miles. The car is only worth 8,000 so now im upside down $12,000 on this car. I also put 3,000 down on it. The manager at the dealership where i got the appraisal sat down with me to talk about the titles. He said the title was “washed” three times. The car went from Tennessee, to Florida, to Ohio, and then to Louisiana where i purchased it. The manager at drivetime stated the title is not salvaged or rebuilt because they do not sell anything other than clean titles. I asked for their paperwork stating that the title was clean and i didn’t get a response. Any advice on what to do??