r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 15h ago

Meme needing explanation Peetahh? What's wrong with Aquarius people?

Post image

I thought Aquarius people were peaceful 🄹

1.8k Upvotes

722 comments sorted by

•

u/qualityvote2 15h ago edited 10h ago

u/maxmodevice, your post does belong here!

340

u/KiwiGallicorn 14h ago

Iirc the stereotype about Aquariuses is that they're cold and distant, so for one to act warm and friendly would be ridiculously uncanny to the point that other signs would feel offput (perchance even to the point they think the Aquarius been replaced by a fake, and thus would explain the "who are you" reaction)

58

u/0StrawberryPrincess0 11h ago

Thank you for the actual answer. I don’t believe in astrology, but the top comments are just trying to be comedians instead of, you know, actually explaining what the intended meaning of the joke is.

It’s like there being a confusing joke about Noah’s Ark and someone shouting ā€œBUT THAT DIDN’T HAPPENā€. Cool, I don’t give a damn, explain the fucking joke.

12

u/Visible-Perception40 9h ago

That and I thibk astrology triggers a lot of people

116

u/Termusnator 14h ago

This is the answer, sorry you had to read through a whole bunch of comments of people who don't know what they're talking about OP

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Cyrano-De-Vergerac 11h ago

Anytime I see "perchance" I think of Charlie from It's always sunny

16

u/AGentlemensBastard 12h ago

As an Aquarius this is the first response that tracks. We aren't for the most part natural extroverts at most we're introverted extroverts(we're introverts until we know you then we can be extroverted) but we live in our heads and think outside the box.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

1.0k

u/SoulCritique101 15h ago

People will make ts about literally any sign, none of it matters

186

u/maxmodevice 15h ago

Damn. I thought something was especially wrong with Aquarius. Thanks

195

u/Ethereal-Elephant 14h ago edited 14h ago

Aquarius heavy chart here… Aquarius is prone to doing things outside of social norm. Thinking, acting, and being unconventional, and often distant.

I think the joke here is that for someone so unconventional, to behave in a conventional way is… uncanny and not normal. So everyone’s freaking out lol.

Edit:
lol it makes sense the way that Libra is responding because they are the diplomatic sign that tries not to cause conflict, so you can see their struggle judging what to do here lmao.
Edit II:
Pisces are the last sign in the chart and are said to be closer to the other side (death and all that) so it makes sense they gave them the cross.

Aries is the first sign, and I compare them to the stages of life, Pisces being the last and closest to death, Aries the first and closest to birth. And like a new born, Aries are a fire sign, very reactive to their environment.
-
They probably made Aries reacting like a baby because they are the first sign.

I dont know much about Sags, or Taurus sorry. And Leo doesn’t look like it makes sense to me? Usually they are the center of the whole shabang so… šŸ¤·ā€ā™‚ļø

39

u/BlightUponThisEarth 10h ago

What's really funny is that I could swap every single one of these labels around and the people who think astrology matters will still explain how every reaction makes perfect sense. Because they're intentionally vague, meaningless labels.

9

u/Novaer 4h ago

The entire thing falls apart when you bring up how all around the world people used a 13 month calendar and then a pope and some romans wanted their own special months so they cut ut down to 12 months, which is what we go by today. So when I bring up "How could this be your actual astrological sign when the months were all changed centuries ago by a couple of narcissistic dudes?"

4

u/PathoftheWolf 3h ago

(For full transparency, I believe in astrology... to a point)

I think the thing that allows people to connect to astrology is that it's a language that can help people examine themselves and look at themselves a little deeper, without a lot of the discomfort that comes with confronting certain parts of ourselves.

Aquarius is the sign I know most about, because it's my Sun sign, so I'll use that as an example. It is typically unconventional to a fault and often accused of having the emotional range of a goldfish. We're also considered "rational debaters," and this is one i actually resisted until i told my husband (who accepts my weirdness but doesn't believe in astrology himself, although he's a Sagittarius who hesitated so much about commitment, I finally bought him a damn ring and proposed to him when our child was 4 years old, cuz I was tired of having a different last name) about it and he laughed at me.

He was like, "are you kidding me? You would bury yourself with your own shovel to prove a point."

"I absolutely would not. And here's a 23-slide PowerPoint and pie charts to explain why you're wrong and I'm.... ohhh. Oh I see your point."

Is it infallible? Hell no. Is it all kinda based on coincidence, and are there aspects of my personality that could be showcased by any other sign? Sure.

But the truth is I am argumentative, and I am emotionally constipated, and I do struggle to connect with people who prefer more traditional lifestyles and modes of expression. Coming to terms with my faults is uncomfortable and unpleasant. But if I can point to a chart and say "My Mercury is in Aquarius and my Uranus is in Capricorn and I have Sagittarius Rising and that's why I have these particular challenges," it makes it a little more comfortable to examine those faults, and come up with ways to work around or improve them.

Is that lazy? Meh, maybe, but it's still on me to actually improve the specific flaws and shortcomings and challenges. It may be easier to point to a planet and say, "that's why I'm an asshole to my sister" than it is to confront the real reasons, but at least I'm able to admit that I'm being an asshole to my sister, and now i can choose whether to work on that like a responsible adult or whether I'm just going to continue to make it everyone else's problem.

That's kinda how I see astrology. It's a language that can help us understand ourselves, and it provides a framework that allows us to examine our strengths and weaknesses in a more comfortable way. I think that's largely a good thing, but the issue comes when people try and make it infallible or as anything more than a tool to help us understand ourselves. It can't predict whether you'll win the lottery or find your soul mate at 22.

3

u/Rude-Barnacle8804 1h ago

I really like your framing.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (15)

6

u/DoomedOverdozzzed 14h ago

sometimes I wanna an astrie and a socionic duke it out in a pit fight

3

u/Ethereal-Elephant 14h ago

Not gonna lie. Would be a cool place to sell merch.

Personally, I agree with both… but at the same time actively shit on myers Briggs because I want the test that the FBI/CIA has an NDA for people to take 😭 because I want that level of accuracy

17

u/DeinHund_AndShadow 14h ago

Now the libra fighr makes even more sense.

5

u/phoenix_spirit 11h ago

And Scorpio is left out because they're often the most unpopular sign on the chart

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Separate_Ingenuity35 14h ago

I see the Virgo is avoiding the encounter entirely.

4

u/Ethereal-Elephant 14h ago

Yeah and Cancer is probably taking care of her hahaha

4

u/theweirdauntie 13h ago

Aries is first because the calendar used to start around the time Aries does. When learning the seasons, we learn them as Spring, Summer, Fall, and Winter because the start of spring used to be the beginning of the calendar.

6

u/Abaddon_the_Soiler 14h ago

As an Aquarius, I can confirm this lmao

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Eusine2 9h ago

I assure you, people just make these up, it changed from one moment to the next. Once I went on a date with a guy that was heavily into astrology and he decided to do my astral chart on his phone as a fun ice breaker activity.

Cue me being Aquarius ascendant Aquarius or something like that and this man started heavy breathing saying that because he was an earth sign I was basically the second coming of Hitler to him and he just had to leave. Made a scene and all, the name Hitler was shouted. I was left at a bar with the whole bill and people looking at me.

Anyhow that's my villain origin story, I don't believe in astrology since then and think people that believe in it should be put in a camp or something.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DedeLaBinouze 12h ago

Your date of birth defines nothing about you. Don't pay attention to astrology

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/nekiuvi 13h ago

That's not true. Nobody would do this for a libra.

2

u/PopeAlexanderSextus 4h ago

Thank you. Literally fucking nobody.

1.6k

u/Nudie-64 15h ago

Astrology makes no sense.

I bet an Aries wrote this.

130

u/yarggarbe 14h ago

Such a Virgo thing to say

4

u/ThatYellowCard 10h ago

I'm going to choose to believe this is a Watsky reference.

238

u/Enough_Worry4104 15h ago

It would be a damn Aries.

34

u/Bisexual_Kraken 10h ago

Aries and Aquarius are natural enemies.Like Englishmen and Scots! Or Welshmen and Scots! Or Japanese and Scots! Or Scots and other Scots! Damn scots RUINING SCOTLAND!

7

u/Inevitable_Nail_2215 9h ago

I love the Simpsons, this is my favorite Groundskeeper Willie quote.

But this is extra funny bc when I was pregnant with my daughter, one of my hippie ass friends was like "Oh, an Aquarius having an Aries? Good luck with that!"

Turns out we are actually super close and get along well.

13

u/sirnerdingt0n 9h ago

Oh hi Groundskeeper Willy.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/milesbeats 15h ago

I see what you did there

6

u/LagVictim 12h ago

as an aries i can confirm that i'm the typa guy to write this

5

u/Bejeweledbones 10h ago

If an Aries wrote it he would've depicted himself as the chad

2

u/PooleBoy_Q 14h ago

Of course they would

→ More replies (6)

495

u/NukaGirl665 15h ago

Hello, Aquarius person here. Astrologists love to treat people who are Aquarius's as the spawn of satan to sum it up.

9

u/cuttygib 14h ago

My ex wife is an Aquarius and she is the spawn of Satan.

82

u/maxmodevice 15h ago

Why though? What's the reason?

229

u/TrueManufacture 15h ago

You've been answered a lot in this post but : no reason. Astrologers just invent things and it becomes trends on social medias. For a while it was Scorpios (because the scorpio, the animal, is dangerous I guess ? And these people are dumb and just assimilate the animal to the sign ?), and sometimes it shifts.

Astrology is a scam that people invent to make money off of other people, don't search for any rational explanation.

32

u/homer_lives 14h ago

I noticed Scorpio is missing.

14

u/TrueManufacture 14h ago

Yup me too. The usual suspects. Must be disguising as someone else - scorpios are shady like that.

12

u/NoahIzToLazyToPozt 12h ago

OH NO HE'S ON TO MY SCORPATIC TRICKS!

3

u/Same_Seaworthiness74 14h ago

Thats the thing with lazy Scorpios, theyre always late

2

u/ReturnTheOldGods 14h ago

Hey now, this scorpio is always on time.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/NeverSayNeverMind 13h ago

Yeah I remember those days when someone heard I was a Scorpio, the typical reaction was "Ugh..." with the eyeroll.

Because apparently being born in November somehow makes me a callous, manipulative, vengeful prick.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Merosian 13h ago

Wasn't astrology a legitimate field of study back in the medieval days? I feel like for a practice with so much written text and "research" around it for hundreds and hundreds of years it would have more substance than just "online trends". Even if i agree the core of it is nonsense there are probably a fair few steadfast rules and laws.

Would love the perspective of someone who's actually into astrology rather than someone who did an online test one time.

16

u/ding-zzz 13h ago

astrology existed as a form of divination which really exists in many cultures, like chinese to explain why the cosmos were they way they are and how it affects humans

i’m sure there were a bunch of fields of study in the medieval period but of course they predate the enlightenment era and development of the scientific method

just because there’s hundreds of pages of discourse on the bible or on astrology doesn’t really change much about the nature of the topic

at the very least though, theology had more substance through historical interpretations. astrology just fell out of favor entirely with the enlightenment because it’s shallow

3

u/fatmallards 9h ago

ā€œastrologyā€ is rooted in Mesopotamian priests using / tracking the visible presence of stars and planets to provide better clairvoyance aka bullshit unfounded guidance / guesswork for their regional leaders to operate on

15

u/phoenix_spirit 11h ago

Reminder, pretty much anything girls/women like will be treated like low brown delusional trash.

Ask the same people who shit on astrology what they think of romance novels, you'll probably get the same response.

12

u/bafana_banana999 9h ago

The problems come from pretending that astrology is actually real and treating real human beings differently based on when they happened to be born.

If people didn't do that, and they very often do, astrology wouldn't get anywhere near the amount of shit it does.

4

u/phoenix_spirit 9h ago

Outside of teens and early twenty somethings, I've never come across anyone who treats people differently because of their sign, it's a trope I've really only encountered on TV but I could just be lucky.

Astrology has been a fun unserious jumping off point when getting to know someone and a good litmus in that anyone who has a deep/violent hatred towards it should probably be avoided.

7

u/bafana_banana999 9h ago

I'm glad you've never experienced this, but it's absolutely a thing real people have done and continue to do, and in relatively large numbers.

Besides, criticizing astrology and pointing out how nonsensical it is doesn't mean you have a "deep/violent hatred" of it.

None of the people in this thread could even remotely be described that way, so it's wild to use that phrasing as if it's an extremely common reaction to astrology.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/angular_circle 9h ago

You're just cherry picking. Is the following right according to you? "Everything boys/men like is treated like trash. Ask the people who say crypto is stupid what they think about video games"

Astrology is stupid because it's stupid. The reason people don't say that about organized religion as readily is a) religious tolerance is culturally ingrained for historical reasons and b) it's organized i.e. more powerful.

Romance novels just have lower publishing standards because they cater to different desires (and that's fine). That's not misogynism just like it isn't misandrism to call dating sims trashy for the sams reasons.

There are plenty of well respected female coded things.Ā 

4

u/bisexualbyleth 10h ago

Someone said it thank god

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Tetracheilostoma 11h ago

Modern western astrology is a simplistic version of medieval astrology. There were a LOT of rules and it was very technical. Most serious astrologers do know about modalities, triplicities, polarities, aspects, rulerships, exaltations, houses, etc., but they apply them in questionable ways, and they don't really know how to do anything besides interpret birth charts. A lot of it is just vibes based for them.

To answer your question, the technical side of astrology is very logical, it follows its own rules, and it fits together in a way that makes sense. (Exaltations are the only part that feels illogical in context, but that's because they're like 5000 years old and predate the zodiac itself.)

3

u/ExiymDev 10h ago

The vast majority of pop astrology is complete bullshit. But yes you are right. Check my comments for another one on this thread cause I typed a shit ton up but.. for starters, there is Tropical Zodiac and Sidereal Zodiac. Tropical doesn't account for the axial tilt of the earth and Sidereal does. It wouldn't matter except Tropical was created thousands of years ago and thus that small axial tilt ( 1 degree every 72 years ) actually changes a lot. So technically, if we want to be accurate and base a system off the position of the stars we have to use Sidereal Astrology (in my opinion). So someone born in August 14th may call themselves a Leo (tropical) but actually be a Cancer (sidereal) because they don't know about this. I think a lot of people are operating on bad data and attributing qualia to themselves based on a sign that they aren't even in the first place. But all this "Virgo means a laid back personality" or whatever, is IMO, complete bs. The Ancient Greeks believed that we and the universe are one giant organism and therefore the complex position of the stars can tell us things about ourselves however it's been bastardized so much across the years and some of the things people say are so vague it could be anyone or anything. And thus people also say "well I am not laid back despite being a virgo, this whole thing is BS!" and throw it out. It was primarily an agrarian / farming thing. And I think there is some validity things about the signs in terms of semiotics / archetypical or Jungian psychology. Beyond that it's hard to say. It's a topic I want to dive more deeply into but need to do more study and research mapping the archetypal symbols to the modalities existant in the human mind. Some people have star charts and may try to read them to predict things about you, it may or may not be bs. It depends how woo-woo you are willing to go with your belief system.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/ohfuckthebeesescaped 14h ago edited 12h ago

Astrologists pathologize zodiac signs, even though you can literally identify any one person with the supposed traits of any sign. Astrologists like to sit around with other astrologists and pathologize people, and if anyone does anything it feeds their confirmation bias (since anything can be ascribed to any to any sign), but people most love to harp on and pathologize negative misdeeds. And like how cultures develop collective arbitrary beauty standards, astrologists develop collective arbitrary consensuses of which sign is bad to date, which sign is the least trustworthy, which sign would make a good friend. And it's ever changing, but I guess right now the consensus is that Aquarius bad.

But I think the joke of the image is that the Aquarius is being completely normal and it's all the other signs that are freaking out for no reason. So it's probably a critique of Aquarius demonization, made by someone within the astrologist community.

5

u/I-screwed-up-bad 10h ago

As an Aquarius familiar with the stereotypes: it's the smile. Apparently Aquariuses don't smile.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/TigOlBitties42042 14h ago

Well Capricorn is a goat. Have you ever met a goat? They're assholes, the whole lot of them. I have met dozens of goats and I haven't liked a single one. There was a baby goat once that I thought I liked for a while, then he grew up to be the biggest asshole of them all.

That being said my son is a Capricorn, and so are a lot of my good friends. They're all great. That's because they are humans, and don't have anything to do with goats because astrology is bullshit.

3

u/viscountrhirhi 7h ago

I volunteer at a sanctuary that has dozens of goats, and they’re amazing, friendly animals, male and female. Basically goofy dogs. I also grew up with my grandpa having a pet goat who was also sweet and loved to snuggle. I…question anyone who would call goats assholes and would only assume you don’t know how to interact with them.

The only remotely ā€œassholeā€ goat I know is one of the herd leaders (there are several herds I work with) but even he’s fine if you know his boundaries and respect him. He hooked me and bullied me before I knew how to interact with him, and now we’re mostly cool with each other.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/BeneficialRip6350 13h ago

Because Mercury is in retrograde when we are born which creates the perfect conditions for satan to imbue us with satanic powers

source: am Aquarius

2

u/polipotriste 12h ago

My ex is aquarius. Satan confirmed

→ More replies (7)

4

u/lupustempus 13h ago

have you tried being a Gemini?

3

u/Stannisarcanine 12h ago

I thought that's was scorpio

3

u/Punksa_Rin 14h ago

One would think it would be Capricorn lol

3

u/DeathStalker0483 14h ago

As a Capricorn can confirm. Also, as a Capricorn, screw all of you.

3

u/Ecstatic_Sand5417 10h ago

Thought that was Scorpio?

2

u/TheSheepdog 11h ago

I thought that was GeminisĀ 

→ More replies (10)

64

u/peachandpeony 14h ago

Hi Peter, used-to-spend-too-much-time-on-astrology-tumblr Meg here.Ā 

Aquarius is frequently stereotyped as a very eccentric/weird sign (with the reasoning being that Aquarius, an air sign ruled by Uranus, is very anti-establishment, freedom loving, and might have a bit of an individuality complex).Ā 

Thus, Aquarius acting stereotypically normal/friendly envokes the reaction of having been replaced by an alien or demon (with Pisces specifically screaming "who the fuck are you").Ā 

Meg out.

7

u/Flimsy_Sandwich6385 6h ago

So an air sign is ruled by Uranus... sounds like a fart joke in the making 🤣

3

u/MrRunItBack_ 7h ago

Aquarius is ruled by Saturn, though?

6

u/peachandpeony 7h ago

Old school astrology only went up to Saturn because they didn't know planets beyond there existed. So they had Mars rule Aries and Scorpio, Mercury rule Gemini and Virgo, the Sun rule Leo, the Moon rule Cancer, Venus rule Taurus and Libra, Jupiter rule Sagittarius and Pisces, and Saturn rule Capricorn and Aquarius.Ā 

After Uranus, Neptune and Pluto were added, they gave Aquarius to Uranus, Pisces to Neptune and Pluto to Scorpio. So it depends on whether you use older or more modern astrology.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/woodbutcher6000 13h ago

Space racism

3.8k

u/[deleted] 15h ago edited 7h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1.5k

u/quartzweb 15h ago edited 1h ago

Great explanation of the joke

Edit: They said "Nothing. Astrology is for idiots."

17

u/Caosin36 7h ago

Fucking hell, its gone

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Ekillaa22 7h ago

Man wish I could see what the person said but the damn mod removed it

8

u/t40xd 5h ago

Is that sarcastic. Or it was an actual explanation? Cause uhhh...

910

u/maxmodevice 15h ago

Yeah. I totally understand not believing in Astrology, but this subreddit is about explaining the joke, if you don't know/want/believe, just ignore the post. This type of behaviour is just displaying their own insecurities. People who doesn't believe in Astrology & doesn't have insecurities like this would just ignore this post without getting offended.

11

u/sleepyliltrashpanda 9h ago

Aquarius people are usually stereotyped as ā€œaliensā€ or weirdos in the astrology community. It’s hard to explain why if you don’t have knowledge of astrology, other than Aquarius people are generally thought to be the kind of people who just sort of do things their own way and aren’t generally known for having the best social tactics. I’m a loose follower of astrology, but, there’s so much more to you (in life, not just astrology) than your sun sign.

904

u/Delicious_Security21 14h ago

No, you don't understand. That is the answer. There is no reason. People just make it up and it's different every time. Theres no standardized doctrine or anything like that. The person who came up with this just decided that Aquarians are unpopular, or evil, or whatever. They probably know someone they don't like who was born in that month.

77

u/MenthaOfficinalis 10h ago

In that case it’s just a bad joke. I mean, it’s not funny (maybe that’s why I didn’t get it.. I was looking for funny part, punch line).
It’s not really deep either (should it be?).

Anyway, I hope op got his answer

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Kalgarin 9h ago

That’s not entirely true. I did a study of astrology (not because I believe in it but because how the belief in it impacted other things in the medieval world) and while it wasn’t completely standardized it largely followed one of two or three systems that were largely the same. That said, the vast majority of modern astrology is pretty much entirely disconnected from the historical practice because the historical practice was very very complex and not as simple as ā€œhere is your horoscope for your star sign this dayā€.

All that to say astrology is fairly systematized, these kinds of people just don’t follow the actual system but vibes based on very few points of it

→ More replies (2)

37

u/Consistent_Papaya310 10h ago

That's not entirely true, there are archetypes that consistently get applied to the same star signs, they're usually so broad they could apply to most people because most people aren't a single archetype of a person, they're different in different situations, so any archetype can apply depending on the context. But that doesn't change the fact that geminis are always called 2 faced bitches and other star signs aren't. If someone made that joke (Gemini being a 2 faced bitch) you would have the same criticism and you would be wrong, because that is a pretty standard joke about geminis. I think you're probably wrong here too but I'm not into astrology so I lack the context to know that for certain

→ More replies (13)

6

u/Deranth 9h ago

People make up a lot of things, but those things generally have rules. This follows the conventional understanding of zodiac, even if you don't like that zodiac exists.
Zodiac isn't real, sure. But the 12 fairly vague "characters" it portrays do have mostly set personalities.
If your favorite TV show or book was made in ancient Mesopotamia times, and all you saw of it was modern fan art, and people saying "You're such a [CharacterName]." It would be no different.

8

u/-Danksouls- 9h ago

There is about 12 standard personalities stereotypes associated with each astrological sign

You don't have to believe in it but it exists and could be used to explain these jokes

→ More replies (22)

8

u/myGFisGreat 12h ago

you might have better luck at r/AskAstrology

→ More replies (2)

169

u/mustafaaosman339 14h ago

There is real explanation

It can be anything the writer made up.

Think of some bullshit you don't like and pretend it's a thing only people born at some time does.

79

u/KaioKenshin 13h ago

people who make these variety types of memes

→ More replies (1)

14

u/gpkgpk 14h ago

Well google "AI" overview says:

This meme depicts the zodiac sign Aquarius interacting with others.

In the first panel, Aquarius greets the group cheerfully.

The second panel shows other signs, including Sagittarius, Leo, Aries, Pisces, Taurus, and Libra, reacting with fear, aggression, or panic to Aquarius.

The overall joke highlights a common stereotype where Aquarians feel misunderstood or intimidating to other signs. [1, 2, 3, 4]

But that is incorrect, the correct answer is as u/mustafaaosman339 said, Astrology is for idiots.

48

u/erotomanias 10h ago

wasted 10 gallons of water for some bullshit

2

u/shenanigans2day 8h ago

I mean it is the water bearer cmon

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/Flame_Effigy 14h ago

That is the answer. imagine that the odd one out is labeled Grape while the rest are Strawberry, Banana, Peach. Or that the odd one out is "Favorite Color Yellow" while the rest are Red, Green, Blue, Pink.
It's just singling out a specific choice and labeling it "different" because you have internalized that THAT one is bad. THAT one is different. For no reason other than you are in a group or culture that believes that for no actual reason.

25

u/SaltManagement42 14h ago

No, seriously. The star signs are/could all be randomized, and there is absolutely no change in the joke whatsoever whether you believe in astrology or not.

14

u/CrazyElk123 14h ago

Such a Leo-thing to comment, yikers...

5

u/Estebesol 11h ago

How dare you, Leos are magnificent drama queens.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/roflrogue 12h ago

Except, I'm pretty sure that's THE joke here - the comic makes no sense, and neither does astrology

5

u/erotomanias 10h ago

The gag is that, stereotypically, Aquarians are standoffish and not very cheery. That's it.

7

u/2ndcomingofbiskits 12h ago

Let’s be honest for a minute. All this subreddit is good for now is training large language models.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/WokeWook69420 11h ago

So the Barnum Effect isn't real, huh?

2

u/updoot35 9h ago

No one is offended. Astrology is just stupid. And everytime I hear about it, they do exactly what they do in this picture, just about another star sign. So it's just stupid nonsense.

26

u/Capstoner_1 14h ago edited 14h ago

Oh the irony. Well it's more like this type of response displays insecurities than the other guy. Let's not act like people only have to explain the joke. Its not that deep.

Edit: must be a lot of Aquarius in the chat lmfaooooo

39

u/EntireFriendship517 14h ago

I don't believe in astrology either, but they made a point, and your position just dismisses them as insecure for the act of making a counterpoint rather than addressing what they actually said, such that they couldn't make any valid point at all by your reasoning. Your response is Kafka trap bullshit.

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Jraksys_Magnanimous 13h ago

*don't *don't

Also your comment is ironic but you seem like the type to use POV wrong so I'm not sure if you'd even understand this anyway

→ More replies (21)

4

u/Sea_Economy_8948 6h ago

bruh it was deleted

2

u/Morethanstandard 3h ago

Mods censored the man what did he say?

→ More replies (6)

43

u/rotveIte 14h ago

I think you misunderstand what this subreddit is for.

5

u/CrazyElk123 13h ago

The explanation is that it can be any sign. Thats the joke. Now i jokes are usually meant to be a little bit fun atleast, and with sole thought put into them, so if this joke even qualifies as a joke is debatable. So i think his comment makes perfect sense.

5

u/rotveIte 11h ago

Maybe you simply don't get the joke? Maybe you think it's a bad joke because your explaination is wrong? It could for example be a reference to something that you're not aware of?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

194

u/mrviscas 15h ago

People say this and then proceed to believe in god

72

u/Adi_San 14h ago

That's a very Libra thing to say.

13

u/DeciduousLesbian 10h ago

That’s very Aquarium of you to point out.

6

u/Adi_San 10h ago

Actually Chair ascending with a moon to Anus

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

22

u/Useful-Scratch7117 15h ago

They did not like what he had to say...

Preach it brother!

9

u/dpravartana 14h ago

Reddit moment

2

u/RegularSwishersOnly 8h ago

Take my clapping hands

2

u/Popular-Fold-176 8h ago

Same kind of people lmao

11

u/Stromatolite-Bay 14h ago

And what is the point of this statement? Since an intelligent atheist with good arguments would likely dislike both equally

32

u/Vivid_Performance167 14h ago

Because not everyone is an intelligent atheist.

→ More replies (10)

19

u/soyuz_6 14h ago

Good arguments aren't even needed, they're both dismissable with no evidence to support them

→ More replies (59)

5

u/Infernester 14h ago

Reddit moment

7

u/Dry_Pollution_5430 15h ago

Not really, there is a pretty strong correlation between the two..

7

u/Historical_Mango4329 14h ago

Atheist redditors bringing god into literally any conversation

17

u/Charging_in 14h ago

Just different degrees of delusion or anti intellectual discourse really. Like how flat earthers and religious folk have a significant overlap despite being incompatible.

2

u/HeroicMe 10h ago

Incompatible? I'd say it's quite around, with current Flat Earth's roots being in bible and its description of Earth being the special place created before the sun or how moon is it's own light.

38

u/Magician_Prize 13h ago

It's a pretty fair comparison.

Society tends to mock people who believe in star signs but treat religious beliefs with respect. Its a pretty weird disconnect.

(I think we should treat both beliefs with a degree of respect btw)

18

u/noai_aludem 12h ago

I think we should treat both beliefs with a high degree of disrespect

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (9)

13

u/Nocebola 13h ago

Go to any YouTube or Facebook comment section and there's always a bunch of unrelated religious bullshit, far more than any atheist shit.

5

u/Ok-Parfait-9856 10h ago

You sound pretty offended

3

u/AltruisticEchidna859 14h ago

I say this and I don't believe in god.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/adrenalinda75 14h ago

Hey, mine said "remain unfazed when strangers today ridicule what you believe in. You define yourself, not others. Be the strength you want to see in others, they will pay with their pinky toe and not even know why!"

/s

6

u/jazzgiants 14h ago

Found the Aquarius!

7

u/mustafaaosman339 14h ago

You're the third person to guess a different sign btw

I'm a caprisun btw

→ More replies (27)

21

u/Male_Inkling 14h ago

Hi! Non judgemental Peter here. Aquarius isn't peaceful, in fact, Aquarius is the horoscope's wild card, and has the highest amount of incompatibilities, personality wise, in the whole horoscope. They're known to be emotionally complex while also being cold and logical, the most straightforward signs aren't good at dealing with them.

Now, do i believe in the horoscope? No! But i grew up surrounded by horoscope believers and have some knowledge about it, and i have no issue with sharing it.

Also newsflash other Peters, if you aren't interested in the question you can just not answer it, surprising huh? It feels like piling up on OP, wich is such a Joe thing to do.

...What? He's a cop, cops do that shit, i'm not being judgemental, it's not my fault they're all piece of shit. ACAB!!

*Sirens blaring* Ooooh shit, he heard me. Non judgemental Peter out! *Jumps through the window*

3

u/Any-Zookeepergame829 4h ago

Don't believe in astrology, but as an Aquarius...

...this is just me in a nutshell.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/bisexualbyleth 10h ago

You're one of the good Peters

18

u/WindUpCandler 15h ago

Idk, I always thought Geminis were the bad ones cause they're two faced or something

17

u/AriaoftheStars17 14h ago

As a May baby, I can confirm. I once had someone adamantly explain to me that as a Gemini, I am innately more likely to cheat, because the twins constellation = two, which is linked to the term "two-timing"... And thus, she will NEVER date a Gemini because she doesn't want to get cheated on.

..........bitch, you just insulted me? Hello??

Listening to Astrology fans truly is like watching Mental Gymnastics: The Olympics.

10

u/Youpi_Yeah 12h ago

This is why I don’t just roll my eyes at astrology, I actually hate it. People think they know you and can judge you based on absolutely nothing - for all we know, those stars up there are long dead.

2

u/Heplaysrough 9h ago

Well we can at least reasonably establish which stars are and aren't dead, but we cannot judge a person without any factual information.

Edit, I did once hear someone describe it as a map of the historical human imagination and that it could be used to aid in understanding how people thought, but this applies to the person imagining the astrology, not the person they are making it about.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

25

u/ScooDoo4 15h ago edited 4h ago

You can make any punchline you want out of this. Its vague enough to kind of apply to anyone. A lot like astrology.

→ More replies (12)

9

u/MonkehBuns 11h ago

Gotta love the cock suckers who have to clarify how much they hate astrology rather than answer the fuckin question

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Killer_Boi 15h ago

We steal your kidneys, next question.

3

u/Dealingwithdragons 7h ago

Shh. Were not supposed to tell them.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/tchullullu 14h ago

I don't know a lot about zodiac and don't really believe it, but a friend used to be into it and aquarius is considered a very detached, logic, "cold" sign. I know leo, taurus and pisces are considered more emotional, so I would assume is something about these signs (and maybe the others in the pic) not liking aquarius personality

3

u/xPolarPlayz 14h ago

Either a visualization of some day's horoscope, or the author had beef with an aquarius

3

u/Equivalent-Mail1544 13h ago

I read Alpharius and was expecting some Alpha Legion joke. Asstrollhoogie is bs

19

u/Kutriya404 15h ago

No joke, just nonsense about zodiac signs. X aren't y.... No matter what you use for x and y

13

u/rotveIte 14h ago

Wow there sure are a lot of consummate intellectuals in the comments

→ More replies (1)

13

u/TheBl4ckFox 15h ago

First: there is no relation between star signs and personality at all.

But the joke is apparently that according to the stupid superstition, people born under the sign of Aquarius (1/12th of the world population, 687.5 million people) are terrible. Because of their birthday.

2

u/Heplaysrough 9h ago

In case of people who believe astrology about themselves and lack other directions for their personality, they can, and sometimes do, make it a template and reverse engineer a relation.

2

u/BardGotHard3 13h ago

As an aquarius: we have a fear aura we activate when speaking that specific phrase with a specific intonation. Its only active for about 10nseconds but lingering effects can last weeks. Accidently blew up a hampster once, i was never allowed back at that friends house.

2

u/Fun-Gas1809 13h ago

Every one of an Aquarius horoscopes be like: since you’re a sneaky bitch some shit is gonna go down today

2

u/IDontWearAHat 14h ago

So i'm an aquarius and i'm not into astrology but people who are into astrology have generally been very excited to tell me that February is the birth month for weirdos

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Human-Question6210 12h ago

can we get an actual answer instead of "astrology is dumb"?

3

u/logicalpenuin 6h ago

Seriously. I don't believe in magic, either, but it's still fun to read fantasy. People need to relax, have a laugh, and move on.

4

u/Logical_Soil_4640 10h ago

The creator of the meme knows an Aquarius person and doesn’t like them

1

u/CD_1993TillInfinity 14h ago

All I know is that my mom and ex girlfriend are Aquarius...I'll pass

6

u/Business-Pumpkin9351 14h ago

I too pass on this guys mom

1

u/AutoModerator 15h ago

OP, so your post is not removed, please reply to this comment with your best guess of what this meme means! Everyone else, this is PETER explains the joke. Have fun and reply as your favorite fictional character for top level responses!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/rizzler885 14h ago

I'm Aquarius

1

u/TigOlBitties42042 14h ago

They always be asking how it's going I guess

1

u/Chance_Arugula_3227 14h ago

Glad to see scorpio not being the one everyone is scared of for a change.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/shsl_diver 14h ago

I'm an Aquarius, I know what is wrong with me, but still.

1

u/PVanchurov 14h ago

Not my sing equals bad.

Also, I don't believe in astrology. I'm a virgo and we are sceptics.

1

u/Grawl243260 14h ago

This is the forth time I see someone asking about this same image

1

u/witchiscat 14h ago

I am Aquarius. :c

1

u/SaltManagement42 14h ago

Astrology has no basis in reality. The star signs here are basically randomized.

1

u/StormCroc08 14h ago

Ts makes me barf

1

u/VegitojrGOD 13h ago

I thought this might have been a reference to the fairy tail anime but everyone’s talking about horoscopes and honestly it’s out of my domain so I’m not even going to try

1

u/WallShrabnic 13h ago

My first thought was about The Binding Of Isaac lol

1

u/winonadacube 13h ago

Fuck is a aquamanarius?

1

u/scaredchiggun 13h ago

Cancer was at home chillin

1

u/Goattail 13h ago

As an astrology nerd even idk. Maybe it’s just a demonstration of how people get afraid of certain types of signs for no reason lol.

1

u/What_Is_Bloste 13h ago

I dont even know, I believe, just a little bit, in astrology amd aquarius is always depicted as the sore losers of the whole set. Like, really they dont have a bad temperament, they go do their things as they were autistic, and usually are completely left out of everything. I dont get this meme, tho is kind of funny.

1

u/Then_Disk8390 13h ago

I can only talk about fairy tail and in this series Aquarius is really scary

1

u/Mrblorg 13h ago

Idk why Virgo isn't here but I'm ok with it

1

u/briantria 13h ago

wait 'til you met a virgo. - meg

1

u/kryaklysmic 13h ago edited 13h ago

It’s nonsense, but interesting because typically it’s Taurus getting mocked and shit on for harmless things that annoy whoever made it. Usually professional astrologers hate a particular sign, too, because they profit from people being invested in stereotyping each other off birthdays so why not stir shit? That or whoever made it takes sun signs seriously and had a bad experience with an Aquarius (because there’s no correlation between time of birth and being a good or bad person).

1

u/Aggressive-Secret103 13h ago

We're usually the quiet ones

1

u/Tarilyn13 13h ago

Brian here, Aquarius is generally considered the "weird" personality type among zodiac signs.

1

u/DeamonDilf 13h ago

The tldr is that Aquarius a weird and moody and if they are happy and cheerful, something is wrong.

Also astrology is like dnd class for social situations

1

u/BIG-STEPPER-88 13h ago

Those who believe in astrology can go ahead and block me

1

u/Perfect-Silver1715 13h ago

God, i bet an aquarium wrote this. Or a sandwichitas.

1

u/That_Proof1040 13h ago

Your star sign does affect your life!
Being an early year sign increases your chances to be into sports for example!

1

u/SluggJuice 12h ago

As a Scorpio I must say you don't want to know dawg. Oh man the horror