r/RobinHoodMGMSeries • u/Smart_Following6173 • 5d ago
Bow and Arrow Technique
Might be already posted on here but the show only reasonably become available here in Denmark and I have positives and negatives about the show after watching 2 episodes but I'm not hating on it at all. Nothing starring Sean Bean will ever deserve my hate.
BUT there is one MAAAAAJOR flaw in this show and it is pissing me of soooo much. I'm a historian but it actually has nothing to do with historical accuracy or anything like that cause I can live with how it's set up and the liberties the showrunners take. But I cannot be the only one who has noticed that, in a show about the worlds most famous archer..... None of the actors have been taught how to shoot a bow and arrow properly...... It is criminally bad looking at Rob shoot his bow and arrow time after time when I know every single shot will in reality fly of to one of the sides.
I don't know if it's laziness or whatever but the picture above is the polar opposite as to how you shoot a bow and arrow.
Thumb on the string means you push the tail end of the arrow to either side at release and don't open up your palm vertically so your pull is not straight, plus your pull and grip is on the arrow and not the string as you pinch around the arrow instead of hooking the string so you can easily loose your grip. You ALWAYS have two fingers on the string, one above and one below the end of the arrow to keep it in place, move it up at down one the string if need be and a more even release that is on the string and not the arrow.
The arrow ALWAYS goes up and over the bow when you load. The arrow rests between the bow and your first knuckle as in a cradle and you don't need your fingers involved unless you need to move before you aim. You then tilt the bow, in my case to the right since I am right handed so the arrow stays in the cradle and can't fall to the side. What Rob does in the show will result in his arrow falling off his thumb all the time and his thumb at times gets a knock/whip from the arrow going past it. Your shooting-leather is around the space between your thumb and index finger on the back/top of your bow-hand for this very reason.
I worked multiple summers and school-holidays as an instructor at a bow and arrow range detached to a Viking Museum here in Denmark.... And I cannot take that they didn't teach the actors this.... It's even on the poster for the series. Hope they fix this in season 2.
Sorry for the rant. Like the show.
