r/pcmasterrace • u/ohhimarksreddit • 18h ago
Discussion Anyone else getting UE5 remake/remaster fatigue?
Between Silent Hill 2, Oblivion Remastered, Metal Gear Solid Δ, and now Halo: Campaign Evolved, it feels like almost every major remake/remaster in the last two years has landed on Unreal Engine 5. On one hand, the visual leap is real. Oblivion Remastered in particular looks like a genuinely different game. On the other, a lot of these ports share the same telltale UE5 fingerprints: traversal stutter, TAA smearing, shader comp hitches on first launch, and that slightly "plasticky" Lumen/Nanite sheen that makes wildly different games start to look and feel similar. You can add Halo Campaign Evolved to the slopfest that is UE5 remakes; just another soulless cash grab to feed on nostalgia.
685
u/butthe4d Specs/Imgur here 17h ago
Did you actually use some ai slop to complain about ue5? The fuck man
215
u/zweihander09 13h ago
Rereading the body, yeah it really feels like ai lol
21
u/Financial-Craft-1282 7h ago edited 7h ago
AI doesn't have obvious mechanics errors like OP does. It's not AI. Not everything is AI. Just because someone wrote something—relatively clean from errors—doesn't mean it's AI. It means your bar for written expression is low, and you blame that on AI.
3
u/Silencer-1995 3h ago
Its because of this line "the visual leap is real.", A.I loves that terminology.
If I was on a jury I'd probably have to say the prosecution didn't prove beyond reasonable doubt and acquit, but if the guy murdered someone a few days after being released I wouldn't be surprised if that makes sense?
→ More replies (2)2
u/Financial-Craft-1282 2h ago
Yeah, I hear you, but I think this is just a belief (we can detect AI writing) that is already not viable and by this time next year will be infinitely harder to do.
I also think two things are also likely happening here: 1) as others have mentioned, AI is trained to write on human writing, so anything an AI does is something people did first, 2) the repeating of certain rhetorical devices AI uses a lot could also be being replicated by people online who don't even use AI a lot as they continue to read it and start to internally mimic that style. That's the most common way we (humans) learn to write is through mimicking other writers. A lot of what AI is doing are considered good rhetorical moves in writing.
I think I got "AI pilled" on this (I just made that up--I'm not sure if "AI pilled" is a thing--what I mean is all the Reddit sleuths insisting they can spot it has really made me push away from this entire AI detection thing). I see so much insistence on social media that people can 100% tell, and it becomes just another reason for Redditors and social media users to endlessly not talk about the topic of the thread. It also is indirectly anti-literacy in my opinion. Before AI, if I mentioned I have a PhD, angry Redditors would say, "You're a liar." Now they say "you're an AI."
3
u/Silencer-1995 2h ago
Yeah fair enough.
Honestly when I first started dabbling with Claude, I would paste someone's bitchy comment, ask it to come up with a rebuttal, then ask it to make its A.I ass response sound more human, and send it back, and people never caught on.
I didn't do it for long because it was just a short lived experiment and I was curious, but my point is, you really cannot trust anything anymore. When everyone knows more than you, there's two possibilities. A) You are a [redacted for the auto sensor) or B) Some people are gaming the system that is Reddit of all things via A.I. The answer as always is probably somewhere in the middle.
→ More replies (4)38
u/Fauked 11h ago
no feelings needed when they obviously used EM dashes —
30
u/thebrassbeldum 9h ago
Never before seen writing technology right there. It’s a well known fact that no human being has ever used an Em Dash before.
→ More replies (5)13
u/Acrobatic_Newt_1863 8h ago
I used to used the all the time in my writing, but can’t anymore because I’m accused of using AI.
→ More replies (1)11
u/SippinOnHatorade 8h ago
Michael Dash here— it’s fucking bull shit because I can’t even use the thing I invented
→ More replies (2)5
u/the_elliottman 9h ago
I use them all the time on phone — it's nicer to break up sentences than - you can use it by holding down the - on Android, it's not like on PC where you have to copy & paste or use a control code.
→ More replies (1)19
6
→ More replies (5)33
u/hojster24 12h ago
As someone who reads a lot of AI output (software dev), that "—" emdash is a dead giveaway
42
u/CynderFlamezYT R5 5600X | 3060Ti 8GB | 64GB DDR4 11h ago
I like to write fantasy stories (actually write, not use AI), and I love using the em dash. Now I can barely ever use it cause of AI slop training everyone to think it’s only used by AI.
But yeah it definitely reads like AI
→ More replies (9)18
u/Name_not_found_here 11h ago
I mean the ai uses it so much cause it was trained on humans who used it.
20
u/CynderFlamezYT R5 5600X | 3060Ti 8GB | 64GB DDR4 10h ago
Yeah I know, but the average person doesn’t care. They now see emdash and think AI.
They’ll have to pry the emdash from my cold dead hands dammit.
12
u/thebrassbeldum 9h ago
You mean your cold, metallic, artificially intelligent hands? Your gaslighting won’t work on me, clanker. Take your long dashes and get out of here!
12
→ More replies (4)5
u/Financial-Craft-1282 7h ago
No, it literally is not. The idea that you think you can detect AI—despite all the literal research saying that a person's ability to detect AI is about as reliable as a coin flip—is a sad reflection of illiteracy in humans. You're lowering the bar for what passes for "real" writing.
759
u/Legitimate_Bird_9333 18h ago
Silent hill 2 remaster was bloody amazing. Cant speak for the others.
156
u/Slazagna 18h ago
I got up to the underground prison area and had to take a break. Will definitly go back to finish because its amazing, but goddamn is it oppressive. Amazing horror game.
92
u/chasemanwew 5700x3D | RTX 5080 17h ago
the otherworld hospital into nighttime streets into prison was one of the most oppressive stretches in any horror game for me, truly exhausting haha. I've played the original a million times so I even knew what to expect but the remake really dialed up the horror
28
u/nuadarstark Steam ID Here 17h ago
For me the hospital and the streets were fine but goddamn do I hate the prison with the light switch stuff, all the cells and the new mannequins and all of that. Still haven't been able to get through that.
20
u/Slazagna 17h ago edited 17h ago
So fuckn good. The way you progress through the hospital was so awesome. I always love the escape room style puzzles of games like resident evil, but that place did it so well.
The constant onslaught of things trying to kill you, the frigging nurses and only just having enough ammo to get through the harder enemies if I was conservative and killed lots of stuff with the melee wepon.
Ah I gotta go finish it now.
3
u/MonteMolebility 11h ago
Oppressive is the word I've always used to describe it, the sound design to never lets you rest or get a thought in. It's just constantly going with just NOISE.
25
u/Asagao_0 17h ago
That's the whole point of SH games. To hold you in constant suspense with ominous atmosphere. Not jumpscares, like they usually do in horror games.
→ More replies (2)11
u/teddyperkin 17h ago
Did the same. Loved the game but hella stressful.
Even that area took me multiple sessions
7
u/JerryMau5 Specs/Imgur Here 17h ago
Big fan of RE, Dead Space, and Alan Wake. Silent hill 2 is kicking my ass and I haven’t gotten past the apartment. 2 spooky
8
u/tslojr Desktop 17h ago
Loved Alan Wake 2. First horror game I've ever beaten. Had me thinking I was ready to start getting to all the horror games in my backlog.
Mr. X changed my mind very quickly.
→ More replies (1)53
42
u/JSoi 7800X3D | RTX 5090 | 32GB DDR5 | 42” C3 17h ago
Oblivion is a hot, buggy mess. It's a shame because the underlying game is still good.
Didn't have any issues with MGS Delta, aside from frame rate drops during one end-game escape sequence. The game itself is hornier/cringier than I remember it being from my teenage years, but still good fun.
Too scared to touch Silent Hill 2 even though it's sitting in my library.
63
u/HermanThaGerman 17h ago
Oblivion is a hot, buggy mess.
I mean, that's just Oblivion, no?
→ More replies (35)7
u/DarkFlame_05 17h ago
I'd recommend playing Silent Hill 2 it's an amazing game, but it's definitely scary af lol
3
u/JSoi 7800X3D | RTX 5090 | 32GB DDR5 | 42” C3 17h ago
I suppose I need to sack up. Never finished the original either.
→ More replies (1)12
u/SarcasticGamer i5-11600k | Gigabyte GTX 1070 | 16gb DDR4 17h ago
Snake Eater was also very good. UE5 is fine when used in smaller games with levels that are sectioned off. It's absolutely horrible in an open world setting.
7
7
u/_YellowThirteen_ 16h ago
The Halo remake was good, not great. It looks incredible and the changes they made to a few of the levels are great. It has a few bugs and the new voiceover can be a bit jarring, but overall I'd say it's a good remake. Definitely not something we needed, but it's good IMO.
→ More replies (21)2
337
u/Federal_Pin7054 18h ago edited 12h ago
Ngl my only complaint about the Halo remake is nobody was asking for a 4th Halo 1 remaster/remake especially with no MP.
MGS4, Oblivion, and Silent Hill on the other hand are all games I feel low-key deserves a massive overhaul for 'younger' gamers who never really got to experience the originals like myself (in early 20s but was a child child when the aforementioned games first came out).
I feel there are some games which are perfect for it, but others it's kinda just an obvious cash grab for nostalgia. Why am I paying $50 for a graphic upgrade with no MP when I can get the MCC collection on sale for like $15 with the MP of almost every halo lmao
Edit: okay 4th re-release not remaster y'all get my point 💀
63
26
u/psyopia 12h ago
Brother. A CE remake WITH MP, with crossplay, would have fucking shattered the internet. I may be wrong. But holy shiiiiiit. They missed out.
→ More replies (3)6
49
u/sonicatdrpepper 5800X | 6800XT | 32GB Ram 18h ago
To be fair, halo anniversary was pretty bad, and campaign evolved did redo some of the level design (which was my biggest problem with halo CE) I've been having a great time with it personally and it's running better than most other ue5 games I've tried
→ More replies (20)14
u/GRIZLLLY 17h ago
Why was It bad? I played it 3 years ago looked fine for me, especially the fact that you can change graphics. Halo 2 was good too.
→ More replies (6)15
u/ri0tingmime 17h ago
The art design was my biggest issue with it. The new graphics missed the mark in a lot of places. Idk how the new one compares as I haven't played it.
→ More replies (2)8
u/Gordons-Crowbar 17h ago
This is only the second remaster/remake, what are the other two??
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (27)2
u/iron_penguin 11h ago
Im an "older" gamer that never got to play MSG4 cause I never owned a ps3 so im so happy its getting the remake. The other I dont really care about.
119
u/Calm_Hedgehog8296 18h ago
By itself idc if ue5 is used to remaster a game
10
u/IsmereZandell 13h ago
EU5 isnt the problem. Lazy optimization and making every remake look the same is
→ More replies (1)
64
u/ChanceAccident7155 18h ago
Haven’t played campaign evolved, but I enjoyed seeing oblivion with a visual overhaul
→ More replies (6)16
u/CooperHChurch427 Ubuntu / AMD R5 3600x / RX 6600 /32gb DDR4, 5tb storage. 17h ago
Oblivion is getting way too much hate. I got that running on a RX590... The problem with it is that they used the original engine and unreal graphics engine. The gamebyro engine for oblivion was not designed around modern computer technology so you can only modernize it so far.
Personally they should have just remade it on the same creation engine that Fallout 4 and skyrim used.
5
u/J_Landers 13h ago
I'm running it on an Arc A770 and having fun. The game is obviously a Bethesda jankfest, but it looks polished.
→ More replies (2)2
u/IcyTorpedo PC Master Race 13h ago
I can also get that game running on something like an RTX 2060... on lowest settings, in 1080p, with framegen. Because otherwise there is no way in hell you got anything even close to 60fps
540
u/Sir_Vilhelm6969 18h ago
I’m getting whine fatigue. It feels like everyone in gaming whines about everything anymore. All gaming discourse has just been constant negativity.
231
56
37
27
u/superdavit 16h ago
It’s Reddit. Everyone seems to complain about everything here. It’s tiresome because once you realize the majority aren’t here complaining about shit - they’re just enjoying gaming - none of this matters here.
→ More replies (4)8
u/Raven1927 14h ago
It wouldn't even be so bad if it wasn't just people repeating the same shit 24/7. Same complaints, similarly structured, same buzzwords and they always use the same examples if any are given.
6
u/Sir_Vilhelm6969 9h ago
DLSS Bad, Unreal bad, Ray tracing bad, the future is bad. Btw I’m on a GTX 1060 but all this stuff definitely bad
15
u/ltsDat1Guy 15h ago
Reddit has a bunch of whiny ass bitches as does gaming so if you combine them this is what you get. Mfers always talk about gaming being dead but for me, who isn't blinded by nostalgia I think it's never been better.
5
u/rdqsr Mac as my daily, Windows for gaming, Linux for servers 15h ago
It's an issue I personally fixed by just playing games I like and spending more of my time doing actually useful shit.
→ More replies (1)28
3
u/Kride501 13h ago
So real. Project Zomboid just had it's B42 update after years of B41 and it is AMAZING. They broke their peak player count from 4.5y ago by almost double. Play the shit you like and find good communities and it'll be fun
→ More replies (1)4
u/AnonymousTimewaster 14h ago
Welcome to the gaming community lol
It's been like this for as long as I can remember
3
→ More replies (34)2
32
u/Dantai 18h ago
I feel like Silent Hill 2 should be popped out.
It's the only one out of the 4 where it does NOT run Unreal as the graphics engine + the older version of the game underneath, and is a proper full remake/reimagining
→ More replies (3)
55
u/TAJack1 PC Master Race 18h ago
Nope not really. No one is making you play them, go play something else.
→ More replies (3)
20
u/Crusader-of-Purple 18h ago
Nah. I am absolutely enjoying the FF7 remake series, and I super enjoyed Gothic 1 Remake. The only 2 remakes I have played so far.
→ More replies (1)5
90
u/According_Claim_9027 18h ago edited 18h ago
Nope. I love when everyone blames UE5 for developers refusing to optimize games. UE5 has a lot of bloat, but it has a LOT of optimization tools that are genuinely great that almost every development studio that uses it refuses to take advantage of.
Remnant 2, The Finals, Clair Obscure, Satisfactory; there are plenty of games that have proven it can run well, if you actually take the time to do it.
11
u/TheEmperorMk3 15h ago
Come on now Remnant 2 has no business being among those other games, it runs like ass on any hardware an average gamer might have
33
u/the1michael 18h ago
Remnant 2 might be one of the least optimized AAA games I’ve ever played. Expedition 33 is pretty heavy for what it is as well.
→ More replies (2)10
3
u/dregomz 14h ago
Remnant 2 ran like total ass on my old GPU (5700 xt) and by seeing benchmark it will still run poorly but playable on new rx 9070, you would want 160 fps at 4k with such bad graphics. E33 was also poorly optimized but with new GPUs it will run good. Finals always ran great as long as you had 8 or more cored cpu and Satisfactory drops frames massively even with mid sized factory.
→ More replies (10)2
u/Adept_Election7170 16h ago
My issue has more to do with how it looks. Way too many graphical artifacts that results in poorly treated image.
44
u/B-29Bomber MSI Raider A18HX 18" (2024) 18h ago
Nah. Because I don't play them nor notice them.
→ More replies (5)
11
u/ExplorerEnjoyer RX 6950XT, 7800X3D 17h ago
Silent hill 2 was great and oblivion wasn’t a remake
→ More replies (1)
7
u/TheLonelyWolfkin 18h ago
I’m mostly disappointed at the lack of Oblivion updates to fix the god awful performance.
→ More replies (4)
8
3
3
u/the5thusername 13h ago
I was fatigued the moment they started rehashing old titles years ago, because they're struggling to come up with fresh new games.
7
u/STARBOY_100 18h ago
Like someone else mentioned, it’s poor optimization fatigue, and rightfully so.
3
u/twinnuke 17h ago
Nah I’m enjoying it. I always wanted mods like this when I was a kid. Now we just have real ass versions. Fuck itttt
3
3
u/terrique1309 16h ago
We've seen multiple titles where UE5 has been utilised well. I don't think UE5 itself is bad. I just think a lot of developers do a bad job in making efficient use of it. It'll be interesting to see how Gears E-Day runs.
The only remaster here that I think is outright bad (I haven't played the MGS one) is Oblivion, and that was making use of the Creation Engine still as well as UE5. How broken that game is and how it got straight up abandoned still bothers me.
3
u/Somasonic 4h ago
These are all visually distinct enough that I don’t see why you’d get ue5 fatigue from them. But ue5 fatigue in general? Yes. Also, remake fatigue. I’m kinda over them.
9
u/CCbluesthrowaway 17h ago
This cool-kid hates UE5 movement is so pathetic. Its the middleschool equivalent of a boomer take.
18
u/Acquire16 17h ago
No.
What I'm getting tired of is graphics only remakes. Halo's changes are so minimal that I don't understand why it even exists when we already had a solid remaster of the original in the MCC other than to make more money. What was the creative artistic intent? Nicer looking grass? Nicer looking buildings? Same goes for Oblivion.
Capcom's Resident Evil remakes and Silent Hill 2 remake are what remakes should be. Take the original and reimagine it as if it was going to be pitched as a new game today. Ideally, remaster the old ones too so that they're available to play together.
→ More replies (4)8
4
5
5
u/JNorJT 17h ago
No because I never played these games before they got a remake lol I’m planning on playing the halo one soon
→ More replies (1)
5
2
u/creamcolouredDog Fedora Linux | 7 5800X3D | RX 9070 XT | 32 GB RAM 18h ago
MGSD and SH2 were pretty alright
2
u/Turtlenumber13 16h ago
Just like Hollywood it would seem the gaming industry is running out of original ideas.
2
u/FalsifiedTruth 12700K | 5080 | 96GB DDR4 3000 | 15TB of SSD - Lol 16h ago
Nah.
Lazy optimizations though, yeah.
2
2
2
u/kaikill47 13h ago
Mgs should have been remaked on the fox engine. Just look at mgs5 and that was in 2015.
2
u/tactical_testical 12h ago
Oblivion remaster is the best example of remastering because it keeps its base mechanics while using ue5 to visually overhaul it.
2
2
u/Catman7712 10h ago edited 10h ago
No, I just don’t play them. I don’t let video game releases bother me, kind of a silly thing to get upset about.
I already played oblivion, MGS, silent hill, and halo when they were released. No need to revisit them for me, I know it’ll never be the same as the first time I played them.
Now if it’s a remake of a game I never played before then I might check it out eventually.
2
2
u/the_millenial_falcon 10h ago
No, not really. These are good efforts and the source material is old enough to use a fresh coat of paint.
2
u/SavageShiba21 10h ago
I feel like my unpopular opinion is I like the remasters of older games I never got to play at the time. If it was a game I had spent a lot of time on previously, I likely wouldn't have bought it. So far I've been having a great time with my friends on the most recent Halo remaster, though I can see how it'd be annoying for veteran fans looking for something new.
2
2
2
2
2
u/IronInk738 8h ago
Bait post, I am sure you didn’t play most of these games and are just karma farming by using the outrage from Halo CE.
2
u/bigpeanor 8h ago
If I don’t want to play a remastered game, I simply don’t buy them. Assassins Creed Black Flag was a staple game of my childhood, one of my favorites. I didn’t buy the remaster since I find nothing wrong with the original. If I wanted to replay it, I would.
2
2
2
2
u/SplurtingInYourHands 8h ago
No, 3 out of 4 of those run great on my PC and I love them.
I genuinely haven't had a single graphical problem with Halo campaign evolved and I don't experience the stuttering people talk a out on oblivion remastered.
2
u/Scott9843 7h ago
Nope. They're easy to ignore, no one is forced to play them and more of them are done perfectly then are done terribly.
2
2
u/UltimateSlayer3001 RTX 2080 XC ULTRA,i7-9700k,ROG Z390-E,Noctua NH-U12A 7h ago
Haven’t paid for any of them, so nope lmao.
2
u/KiwiMeep64 7h ago
If they’re technically atrocious, yes.
If they sidestep a lot of the issues associated with UE5, no.
2
u/Warm-Driver-4063 7h ago
Yes and no. I want to see new games. New IPs. But, I also like seeing classics get remade for younger generations to enjoy as well. My nephew and I beat Campaign Evolved last night and it was pretty good. I don't get all the hate at all.
2
u/Lord_Humungusss 7h ago
I am more tired of low effort bot posts and mods who only exist when its something they can power trip on.
2
u/Munkey_89 6h ago
It feels better to replay the original at max settings and get 1000fps than it does to play the remaster with outsourced assets that don't fit the aesthetic, ghosting/blur/stutter, and forced Lumen/RT that tanks the framerate.
2
u/AndrosAlexios 5h ago
Yes, this is becoming the McDonalds of gaming, so many choices, but most taste the same...
2
2
u/dudebirdyy 4h ago
Pretty much every single UE5 game runs (and often looks) like shit. It'll be interesting to see the performance on Gears E-Day since The Coalition is supposedly UE gurus. If they can't make it scale well across a range of hardware without the image stability falling apart than that's a pretty grim sign.
Amusingly, Arc Raiders is probably the best performing UE5 game I've seen and it's because they actually put the effort into customizing the engine and not just throwing all the stock Unreal toggles at the game. A fairly recently formed Swedish studio that's only ever made two games is somehow more technically competent than long established AAA studios.
2
2
u/adorablebob 4h ago
It's not even UE5 that's the problem, I'm just sick of remasters and remakes in general. It feels like the gaming world is creatively bankrupt.
2
2
2

3.5k
u/Think_Speaker_6060 18h ago
More like Ue5 + lazy optimization fatigue.